A little while ago, I made an offhand comment (appropriately enough, in the comments section) about how America has been, arguably, the least successful and the most successful colonial power the world has ever seen. (Hat tip to my Blue colleague, Steve Crickmore, for provoking that thought.) At the time, I said that it might be worthy of a longer study, and it’s been rattling around in the back of my brain ever since.
The United States missed out on the best of the “colonial” era. Unlike the European powers, we didn’t go setting up colonies around the world to exploit and benefit ourselves. I suspect this was partly late-bloomer syndrome, and partly because we got our own start as a colony, and rebelled — that most likely left a bad taste in our mouths for the whole colonial thing.
Finally, in the waning years of the 19th century, we got into the act. But we decided it was too much work to build our own empire. Rather, why not just take someone else’s? That led to the Spanish-American War, and that concluded with us taking over most of Spain’s colonies — the Philippines, Cuba, Guam, and Puerto Rico, among others.
So, how well did that work out? We granted Cuba and the Philippines their independence after a few decades. We kinda-sorta granted Cuban independence after a couple of years, but it was decades before they were well and truly free of American dominance (when they traded that for a Communist dictator). And the Philippines were even more contentious, with a long string of broken promises of independence up until the Japanese invaded and took over. After the war, the US finally relented and let the Philippines go their own way.
Guam and Puerto Rico, however, were a different story. They were made “territories” of the United States, with their people granted full citizenship and many of the privileges (but not all, and none of the obligations) of statehood. Guam, also, fell to the Japanese empire, but we took it back during World War II. Since then, both have flirted with independence or somehow changing their status, but there is no real passion in either place to change the status quo. Indeed, Puerto Rico has had regular referendums on the issue, and “stay the same” has won every time.
So out of four big “colonies,” two have gone independent and two are happy the way things are, as part of the United States. How about other places, where we have taken territory by force of arms?
[F]ar from being the Great Satan, I would say that we are the Great Protector. We have sent men and women from the armed forces of the United States to other parts of the world throughout the past century to put down oppression. We defeated Fascism. We defeated Communism. We saved Europe in World War I and World War II. We were willing to do it, glad to do it. We went to Korea. We went to Vietnam. All in the interest of preserving the rights of people.
And when all those conflicts were over, what did we do? Did we stay and conquer? Did we say, “Okay, we defeated Germany. Now Germany belongs to us? We defeated Japan, so Japan belongs to us”? No. What did we do? We built them up. We gave them democratic systems which they have embraced totally to their soul. And did we ask for any land? No, the only land we ever asked for was enough land to bury our dead. And that is the kind of nation we are.
Yes, we’ve sent our forces abroad. Yes, we’ve invaded other nations. But in each and every case, once the battle was won and the new government established and secure, we only stayed as long as we were welcome. We have forces in Germany and Japan, after we utterly crushed them militarily, but they are there with the consent of the government — and everyone knows that the instant they wish us to leave, we will do so, with a minimum of fuss.
If you need any references, feel free to contact Saudi Arabia and the Philippines.
In Saudi Arabia, we entered at the request of the King after Saddam Hussein invaded Kuwait. We stayed there, because they allowed it. And then, when the Saudis asked us to leave, we did so.
In the Philippines, we kept a sizable military presence after we granted them their independence in 1946. Subic Bay and Clark Field were linchpins in the United States defense system, our two major bases in the western Pacific. Then, when the Philippine government no longer wanted us, we left — no fuss, no threats, no warnings of dire repercussions. We had overstayed our welcome, so we took our leave.
So, as colonial powers, we suck. We got four great ones off of Spain, but none of them stayed colonies for very long. And we’ve had numerous opportunities to add new ones, as we invaded and defeated plenty of other nations and territories (especially during World War II, when the United States militarily conquered most of western Europe and the Pacific), and in each and every case we handed back control to the natives. And while we left our military in most of those places, it was not as an occupying power, but as a guarantor of their independence and our own secuirty.
But there is another theory, one I happen to like. It’s that the United States represents a newer, softer, more subtle, but far more effective form of colonialism than that by the sword. And that is cultural colonialsim.
American culture is, for better or worse, THE dominant culture around the world. Our TV shows, our movies, our form of English, our technology, our currency, our celebrities, are the most popular around the world. The symbols of the United States, to most people, are not the eagle and the Stars and Stripes and the Army and the Navy and the Air Force and the Marines. The symbols of America are McDonald’s, Wal-Mart, Coca-Cola, Hollywood, the almighty dollar, the personal computer (both Windows and Mac), General Motors, Starbucks, Mickey Mouse, Superman, George Clooney, and so on.
We have done what tyrants of the past have never succeeded in doing. We have surpassed Caesar, Stalin, Hitler, Alexander, and a host of others — we have conquered the world. And we did it not by force of arms, but simply by doing things better than everyone else. We have, in effect, “colonized’ the world by making so many people want to be part of us. And we did it all (I believe) by accident. We never sought global cultural domination; the globe beat the path to our door.
So, now that we have this nifty new empire, whatever shall we do with it?
Damned if I know. And I think very few have any real ideas.
There’s one school of thought that says “we better smash it!” These folks are just scared of the responsibility that comes with accepting the role we’ve found ourselves.
There’s another that says “if we ignore it, it’ll just go away.” I don’t think that’ll work; that’s pretty much the formula for how we got there in the first place.
Then there are those who say “we must harness this for the good of all mankind.” There is nothing more dangerous than a clueless idealist, who cheerfully race down the highway at breakneck speeds, flying over the asphalt of Good Intentions — and I think we all know where that road leads.
We weren’t smart enough to plan this to happen this way. Why on god’s green earth would we think that we’re smart enough to assert control now without throwing the whole thing into chaos and unleashing mass higgledy-piggledy?
My idea? Simple. Keep an eye on things for flagrant abuses and offenses, but otherwise sit back and simply enjoy the ride. As I said, we didn’t set out to get where we are, we just followed our instincts, and they’ve worked out pretty darned well — for nearly all concerned — so far. Why mess with success?



