Here is more must watch video from Liz Cheney who presents the best defense of the Bush administration national security record than just about anyone. What is really funny here is Rachel Wener’s Huffington Post comment in the link to the video: “The Cheney family argument that torture did save lives has been undermined by recently released memos.”
It is funny because in the video Joe Scarborough exposes the dishonesty of the Obama administration for releasing memos from those who say “enhanced interrogation techniques” don’t work, but they keep classified and refuse to release other memos from the CIA and others proving that they did, in fact, work and saved lived.



Thanks for the video! I remember when torture apologists weren’t tolerated in polite society.
Instead, Adrian, we’ve got apologists for head-hackers. But I’m sure our ‘abandonment’ of torture will produce the desired benefits – in that the beheadings and mutilations will be done with a SHARP knife instead of a dull one.
I think we’re going to find the redefinition of ‘torture’ is going to have much more than political ramifications… and when there’s another attack I’m sure you’ll be right up there to make sure any ‘suspects’ have their slippers and comfy chairs.
Hmmm… sounds like someone is borrowing the playbook of a certain Austrian house painter:
Jlawson, I thought you looked like Cardinal Biggles!
It is funny that the blogger says
“those who say “enhanced interrogation techniques” don’t work”
then
“others proving that they did, in fact, work and saved lived”
One side “says” the other “proves” depending on which side you support.
SCSIwuzzy – Dr. Goebbels would be so proud of Obama’s team. Wall Street contributed greatly to The One’s campaign, probably figuring like the German industrialists of the early 30’s “We can control him”. Wonder how their feeling now?
WC
“One side “says” the other “proves” depending on which side you support”
I’m not sure which side you are coming down on since that can be taken different ways.
Personally I believe those who can prove something can be done than those who say it can’t be done.
Obama is to America as Joe Wilson is to Valerie Plame. Liars in love.
Liz Cheney has a future in our party.
a browne – “Thanks for the video! I remember when torture apologists weren’t tolerated in polite society.”
Odd thing is, your comment proves the reverse.
SCSIwuzzy –
Careful – there’s a comfy chair with your name on it just waiting…!
I can’t believe that minors are allowed to see that.
Conservatives, I think it’s high time for you to understand just how much The Left hates torture.
Think for a moment about how the level to which you conservatives hate all the gay couples, hating them so much as to stridently seek to deny to them a right that you yourselves have: the right to marry the adult who you love. Now multiply that level by five. That’s how much we on The Left hate torture.
Get that? Got that? Good.
depp=true
notiz=Here’s a shovel to bury your broad brushing.
Adrian, I can’t believe you’re allowed internet access in the asylum.
Spew Spew Spew, Generalize, Generalize, Ad Hominen, Lie, Distort, Distract.
Its all getting rather tiresome WC, Adrian and Herman et al. Can any of you construct a logical argument that is based on reality? Or at least come up with some witty retorts that aren’t fecal, prurient or purulent?
They are unable epador. I have learned that over the years. ww
Adraine browne said
“I can’t believe that minors are allowed to see that. “
Why do you find it so hard to believe? Your side of the aisle believes that 8 year olds should be allowed to get abortions without parental knowledge.
For everyone that does this, please stop using the accusation of ad hominem incorrectly. An ad hominem is not an insult.
An ad hominem attack is when a claim or argument is rejected on the basis of some irrelevant fact about the person presenting the claim or argument.
Not an ad hominem:
A: “OK, I’ve been following this thread for a while, and I hate to say it, but you’re being an asshole. You’re really taking this whole thing too personally, and seriously misconstruing everyone else’s arguments. Nobody here is arguing that copyright infringement is ethically, morally, legally, or otherwise justifiable. They’re simply arguing that equating it with theft is simplistic and inaccurate.”
B: “…calling me an asshole is called an ad hominem attack, which does not show me wrong.”
This is false because calling B. an asshole is just abuse. A’s argument is not ad hominem. A has carefully pointed out what he sees as the flaws in B’s argument, and based on B’s failure to acknowledge them and general behaviour, has concluded that B is an asshole. This conclusion is quite independent of A’s treatment of B’s arguments.
A real Ad hominem:
Person a. All humans need water.
person b. You just say that because your work for the water industry.
Person b’s argument is false because, where you work, does not disprove the claim all humans need water, Perosn B. is distracting from the argument,
Perhaps your education in science ended before you were an 8 year old, but girls at that age can’t get pregnant, and therefore, couldn’t have an abortion.
jmc – “For everyone that does this, please stop using the accusation of ad hominem incorrectly. An ad hominem is not an insult.”
ad hominem:
1. appealing to one’s prejudices, emotions, or special interests rather than to one’s intellect or reason.
2. attacking an opponent’s character rather than answering his argument.
Attacking an opponent’s character is not an insult? Guess I better get a better dictionary.
Or maybe you should.
girls at that age can’t get pregnant,
Yes, they can, and have. They are not old enough to give birth, but old enough to get pregnant. And yes, it’s usually family related. If you don’t believe it, you need to call around and ask nurses who work in abortion clinics.
Herman: You are showing your liberal biases. I do not hate gays and I don’t know of any other conservative personally (and I know many) who hates gays. Being against gay marriage IS NOT “proof” or an indication of hatred. That is what liberals want to believe because they think it furthers their cause and shuts down debate and discussion.
Secondly, what “torture” is defined as is totally an opinion. It is a definition that liberals and conservatives disagree on. You say you are right, we say we are right. Liberals do not have the high moral ground to stand on. You are not automatically “right” because you are a liberal and “liberals are always right”. It seems that the end always justifies the means for liberals unless it might “hurt” those they identify with. I’m not quite sure how that works.
jmc-there are plenty of 8 year olds who are capable of getting pregnant. They don’t even have to have had their periods before they get pregnant-because they get pregnant just before they get their period. Recall that one ovulates before having a mensus.
Granted, their are not thousands of 8 year olds getting pregnant, but are you telling me that if an 8 year old was pregnant and wanted an abortion you, and the rest of the liberals who are pro choice would advocate for her to have an abortion. After all “it might be incest” so she shouldn’t have to inform her family.
The point isn’t that it’s an 8 year old, it’s that liberals think a child as young as 8 should be able to have an abortion without informing her parents, but a 20 year old man in the military is a “boy”, and incapable of making the decision to join the military or not. (There are many liberals who use this kind of reasoning.)
In other words it solely depends on what liberals believe when they determine whether someone is a child or an adult. Which ever fits their agenda the best is what they will use. There is no consistancy.
Exactly. And it’s not okay for a young man to make the choice as an adult to go to war because he “doesn’t know what he’s getting himself into”. But partial birth abortion, where a living child is left to suffer, bleed to death, dehydrate and die is all about the woman making a choice about her own body, and not murder.
JMC
“Perhaps your education in science ended before you were an 8 year old, but girls at that age can’t get pregnant, and therefore, couldn’t have an abortion”
Youngest mother was age 5.
http://www.snopes.com/pregnant/medina.asp
I believe the youngest girl to have an abortion is currently age 9 (at least that I could find).
I got to hand to your marc, you are never afraid to persist in your own stupidity. An attack on a persons character is an ad hominem only if, the attack is used as a reason to negate that person’s argument.
example: A. Dick thinks, Doctors save lives.
B. Why would Dick know anything about doctors Dick is an asshole.
See, it used as a reason to discredit the argument. Now if it went like this:
A. Dick thinks doctors save lives.
B. Well he is right, but he is an asshole.
In this case ‘asshole” is not an ad hominem, because it is not used against the argument. There is nothing illogical about person B. Calling Dick an asshole, he might be one. It has nothing to do with his argument. Just like it is not illogical for me to call you are a moron. You are a moron.
I should amend what I said to “99.99% of girls can’t get pregant before 8.” The girl you mention had a severe hormanal balance which is rare to say the least.
oh, and a question: I assume, you would prefer, that five year old take on the responsibility of mothering? they could go to grade school together.
btw: in Europe, where they have things like that sexual education you conservatives hate, the abortion rate is much lower than here (per capita) becuase teens don’t get pregnet to begin with.
depp=true
notiz=Every time you broad brush is whack time.
Yes Im conservative dicswap.. what has that to do with reason or logic?
” I cant believe minors are allowed to see that”
I cant believe its not butter? So what?
Unless your a donkey? jac ass
I am not sure if I was accused of spewing, generalizing, ad homenizing, lying, distorting or distracting.
Maybe I should say that the released memo prove that torture does not work while the still classified memos are reported by former administration officials to say it did. I think that is a clear statement of my opinion.
When did people become so trustful of politicians and political appointees? I don’t trust this administration or the last 20 to work solely in the best interests of America.
I believe the strategy the Al Queda has implemented is working to a T. Divide the country and drain the coffers. If the Soviet Union was still around and we still had to contend with the Cold War would be in about the same position as they were in the late 80’s. Broke and impotent.
8 year’s old abortions was however perfectly relevant to this post.
“Logic, facts, reason, conservatives like you do hate that shit.”
Logic is not a part of your assumption that anyone would rather see children become parents as a result of sexual abuse and based on facts. We have yet to see you use anything that resembles logic. The sh*t I hate is when you call your method of reason logic, when you know it’s just muddled nonsense.
“8 year’s old abortions was however perfectly relevant to this post.”
That conversation was stemmed from what adriane said, that he couldn’t believe what “minors are allowed to see”. You’re right about Al Quaeda, except that was happening long before Iraq.
“oh, and a question: I assume, you would prefer, that five year old take on the responsibility of mothering? they could go to grade school together.”
See, you proved my point in only 2 sentences.
Well, no not really, because no liberal wants an 8 year old to have an abortion without parental consent. It is a strawman to say the least. If Rm thinks liberals are bad because they beleive a teenager should be able to do that, that it least is an accurate argument for some.
“It is a strawman to say the least.”
You don’t think maybe he was being sarcastic?
Rm expressed anger over an 8 year old having an abortion. I asked if he would prefer she become a mother.
That is a question not an assumption. pea brains who beleive in the Amero make those kind of mistakes.
ad ho·mi·nem
Pronunciation:
\(ˈ)ad-ˈhä-mə-ˌnem, -nəm\
Function:
adjective
Etymology:
New Latin, literally, to the person
Date:
1598
1 : appealing to feelings or prejudices rather than intellect 2 : marked by or being an attack on an opponent’s character rather than by an answer to the contentions made
Has nothing to do with logic, jmc.
Of course, that is why I followed up with sarcasm.
You also said you “assume” he would prefer that, as if that had anything to do with the argument.
Ad hominem is one of the best known of the logical and systematic fallacies usually enumerated in introductory logic and critical thinking textbooks. Both the fallacy itself, and accusations of having committed it, are often brandished in actual discourse (see also Argument from fallacy). As a technique of rhetoric, it is powerful and used often because of the natural inclination of the human brain to recognize patterns
moron.
http://www.fallacyfiles.org/adhomine.html
“Of course, that is why I followed up with sarcasm.”
Baloney. Even your dishonesty isn’t logical.
“That is a question not an assumption. pea brains who beleive in the Amero make those kind of mistakes.”
And it’s only a pea brain that doesn’t pea brain that doesn’t listen to what others are saying and do his own research. To say it doesn’t exist is just ignorant. The real question is why it existed to begin with, because the dollar is still goin’ bye bye.
“You also said you “assume” he would prefer that, as if that had anything to do with the argument.”
Given the the statement he made that would be the logical deduction to make. before we proceed much further, I suggest you google logic.
reasons for you to learn logic lamed.
So why learn logical fallacies at all?
I can think of a couple of good reasons. First, it makes you look smart. If you can not only show that the opposition has made an error in reasoning, but you can give that error a name as well (in Latin!), it shows that you can think on your feet and that you understand the opposition’s argument possibly better than they do.
Second, and maybe more importantly, pointing out a logical fallacy is a way of removing an argument from the debate rather than just weakening it. Much of the time, a debater will respond to an argument by simply stating a counterargument showing why the original argument is not terribly significant in comparison to other concerns, or shouldn’t be taken seriously, or whatever. That kind of response is fine, except that the original argument still remains in the debate, albeit in a less persuasive form, and the opposition is free to mount a rhetorical offensive saying why it’s important after all. On the other hand, if you can show that the original argument actually commits a logical fallacy, you put the opposition in the position of justifying why their original argument should be considered at all. If they can’t come up with a darn good reason, then the argument is actually removed from the round.
“Ad hominem is one of the best known of the logical and systematic fallacies”
Dude, it’s in the dictionary. It’s an attack on character rather than addressing an issue, logic or no, so don’t try to side-step the definition.
What is illogical about. lets see if you have manged to leanr what a logical fallacy is yet.
well, coming from a trufer like you, how can I deny that?
jmc, you have never learned logic, except what comes out of a textbook. You never use what you have taught, you just tell people what it is.
Dude, it’s in the dictionary. It’s an attack on character rather than addressing an issue, logic or no, so don’t try to side-step the definition.
HAHAHAHAHAHAHA.
http://www.csun.edu/~dgw61315/fallacies.html
translation: “I can’t show anything you said that was illogical, so I’ll just repeat my claim.”
“well, coming from a trufer like you, how can I deny that?”
The more you type, the more dishonest you are. You have no clue what a trufer is, because there is no such thing. Neither do you know what a truther is. You’re shortcut misspellings are showing how really lazy you are when it comes to actual thinking, otherwise you would address the issue at hand, rather than continually telling them “how it’s done”. “Trufer” is an ad hominem, by the way, whether you like it or not.
“translation: “I can’t show anything you said that was illogical, so I’ll just repeat my claim.””
See what I mean? You can’t even understand how to point out logic, only what it’s “supposed to be.”