A lot of people are looking at Massachusetts’ health care system as a model for how ObamaCare will shape up. And it’s a very fair comparison. For example, this morning the Boston Globe has a story on just one of the many disasters that the Bay State is facing.
Naturally, this being the Boston Glob (a wholly-owned subsidiary of the New York Slimes), they have to put their spin on it
Here’s the Globe’s version of the facts: in the last year, health insurers have submitted 274 requests for hikes in health insurance premiums. The state, which has taken the power of deciding what those rates should be, has denied 235 of them. And then the Glob goes into exceptional detail on how many small businesses are struggling under rising health care, and how difficult it is to keep up the state-mandated health insurance policies.
But buried down in the story is a key paragraph:
Insurers whose rates were rejected — most of which posted operating losses for 2009 due to job cuts at companies they sell plans to — received yesterday’s decision with anger.emphasis added
That’s right. These evil, greedy, selfish, malicious insurance companies actually lost money offering insurance in Massachusetts. And the primary cause: the firms they contracted with cut jobs, which meant that premium payments were also cut.
In most cases like this, the two businesses involved — where the current arrangement isn’t working for either of them — would likely renegotiate and find a way to come to an agreement.
But this isn’t most cases. This is Massachusetts, the home of mandatory health insurance, the bluest of blue states. (Quick recap: Democrats hold one of two US Senate seats, all 10 US House seats, every statewide elected office, and over 85% of the legislature. Further, the one Republican in a position of power is Scott Brown, who succeeded Ted Kennedy last January. And in what cannot be a coincidence, the last three Speakers of the Massachusetts House, all Democrats, were driven from office after being convicted of corruption.)
So, in Massachusetts, when a situation like this arises, it’s the state’s right to step in and settle the matter. In this case, they’re deciding that the insurance companies can just suck up the losses better, so they get to.
Of course, what the article doesn’t mention (and, apparently, the state didn’t consider) the possibility that the insurance companies could look at their books and say “screw this, we don’t need to lose this much money every year.” In other words, they could just close up shop and get the hell outta Dodge.
How does this scale up on a national scale? Insurance companies, when confronted with a mandate to lose money, won’t be able to just close up shop and focus in places where they are free of such regulation.
No, they could just get out of the health insurance business entirely.
Hell, under existing law, they’d have to. These insurance companies are publicly traded, and they have a fiduciary responsibility to make money for their investors. Any board of directors that continued operating in a field where they not only do not make a profit, but cannot make a profit, will get itself sued out of their seats by investors. And if the government ties in the health insurance business into other forms of insurance — say, those that issue home or auto or life insurance also have to offer health insurance — then they could just get out of business entirely.
That is the key element of incremental socialism. It’s the theory that if you just make things a bit less friendly for capitalism, a little bit at a time, one nibble at a time, then people will adapt and adjust and accept it. The frog won’t jump out of the pan. You don’t eat a pig like that all at once.
But sooner or later, there comes a tipping point that sneaks up on nearly everyone. A few people realize that they’re stuck in a losing game (“even if you win the rat race, you’re still a rat”) and will stop playing. And then a few more will “go Galt.” And a few more. And before most people realize it, the driving engines of the economy have turned run themselves dry.
One of the first signs will be when the government starts deciding not only how much “profit” is acceptable, and who isn’t allowed to make profits.
Just like in Massachusetts. Which most everyone agrees is a model for ObamaCare.
