Of late, it appears that President Obama has “gone fission.” He’s making two very significant changes in regards to nuclear weapons.
First, he announced a change in our policy towards the use of nuclear weapons. For decades, the American policy was based on a very simple formula: “WMD=NBC.” Our stated position was that we would feel free to use Weapons of Mass Destruction if we were attacked with Weapons of Mass Destruction, and those were defined as Nuclear, Biological, or Chemical. In the eyes of the United States government, the three were essentially the same — or, as Tom Clancy once memorably put it, “a nuke is a bug is a gas.” And since we only had the nukes stockpiled, not bugs or gases, it meant that if we were attacked with any of the three, our attacker could expect to be reduced to a glowing glass parking lot.
Now, under Obama, the United States has set that aside. Instead, we’ve pared the N off from the NBC group. Now, if a nation is a participant in good faith in the non-proliferation treaty, we won’t nuke them. Period. Left unaddressed is those nations who might use the B or the C weapons — and that is quite troubling.
Biological and chemical weapons are often called “the poor man’s nukes,” as they give considerable “bang for the buck” without the huge costs and efforts involved in making nuclear weapons. The United States has found such weapons distasteful for a very long time, so we put more of our resources into nuclear weapons — relying on them to provide a deterrent to those who would be tempted to use them against us. And it seems to have worked.
Now we have no official declared deterrent against those who would use biological or chemical agents against us. Obviously, we would be free to retaliate with devastating conventional force, but we have arbitrarily taken nuclear weapons off the table.
Secondly, today President Obama signed a new treaty with the Russians that will reduce the number of nuclear weapons both sides maintain in their arsenals.
I’m of mixed feelings of these developments. I’m having a hard time either congratulating or condemning his moves in this area.
In the latter, I’m fully aware that the Russians (and before them, the Soviets) didn’t have the best of records in regards to keeping to arms agreements. And the ones they did sign generally were more to their advantage than ours. But there comes a point where we simply have enough nukes to achieve pretty much anything we could imagine needing to do with them.
In the former, I’m seeing it as another indicator that the historic nation-state is becoming obsolete in certain aspects.
When I was growing up (the late 1970’s and most of the 1980’s), the fear of nuclear war was a very real thing. And I’m not talking about one or two or five nuclear blasts — we were facing full-blown nuclear armageddon, with thousands and thousands of warheads flying back and forth, playing “bounce the rubble” until most of the world was a devastated wasteland and, to quote one of the more vivid observations, “the survivors will envy the dead.” Our hopes for avoiding such a fate was based upon the oh-so-honest MAD principle — Mutually Assured Destruction. We counted on our enemies caring more about saving their own people than destroying us. Our survival was based on our enemy being sane, being responsible, or — if all else fails — being incompetent.
That nightmare, thankfully, is long extinct. (Thank you, President Reagan. You, more than anyone, are responsible for saving us from that.) But now, we have a new nightmare to take its place.
(much more below the fold — man, am I long-winded this morning!)
]]>< 