Last week, the editors at Wizbang agreed to ban a poster by the username of Lee Ward. Mr. Ward had participated at the site for several years, and at one time enjoyed the rights to edit a spin-off site, Wizbang Blue, created to provide liberal alternative posts to complement the main site’s right-of-center political opinions. The Wizbang Blue experiment failed and Ward lost his editorial rights in early 2010. After that time, his behavior became disruptive, the consensus of the editors was that Ward made no effort to engage in debate but attempted to hijack or derail discussions he disliked. After a number of individual editors announced their intention to ban Mr. Ward from their articles because of his consistent abuse of commenting privileges, a decision was made to ban Ward from the site altogether. The debate, between the site editors and among commenters in a number of articles, including the one announcing Ward’s banishment, has focused on three key points – the right to free speech, the private ownership of the Wizbang site, and the quality of debate when a voice is silenced, for whatever reason.
First, the easy points. The First Amendment of the United States Constitution bans Congress from making any law which abridges free speech. There’s nothing at all in the Constitution that says a person can go anywhere and say or do anything they please, or that the people they attack or deride must put up with it. In fact, insulting a person can actually be illegal under certain circumstances; according to the free dictionary, “assault” is defined as ‘threat of bodily harm coupled with an apparent, present ability to cause the harm’. Those members of the New Black Panthers who stood in front of a polling place and harassed selected passers-by, for instance, fit that description, and so no reasonable person could claim they were merely performing an act of ‘Free Speech’. Obviously, the lack of physical presence seriously impacts the viability of a charge of assault viz a viz a blog comment, but I mentioned the definition for two reasons – first, the clear fact that speech has limits in a free society, and second, the foundation for the statute rests on intent – again referring to the legal dictionary; ‘Intent is an essential element of assault. In tort law, it can be specific intent–if the assailant intends to cause the apprehension of harmful or offensive contact in the victim–or general intent–if he or she intends to do the act that causes such apprehension’. One step back from an actual charge of assault, we see that the intent to attack is out of bounds. Keep that in mind, because I will come back to it. For now, it should be readily apparent that the Constitution of the United States restricts federal interference in religious and political speech, even if commonly found to be offensive. It does not protect a right, specific or implied, of an individual to attack another person or group in a non-federal venue.
– continued –
]]>< 
