The Telegraph UK is featuring an editorial by Janet Daley on how the BCC completely fails to understand the Tea Party movement in the U.S. The piece is succinct enough I almost want to quote the whole thing. Instead I hope the following quote motivates you to, as Glenn Reynolds would say, go read the whole thing.
The British generally and the BBC in particular have a real problem understanding the obsessive suspicion in which the power of central government is held in the US. This is not some funny redneck eccentricity: it is fundamental to the Constitution which gives individual states much greater sovereignty than the countries of the European Union enjoy. The states have independent judicial systems (some states have capital punishment, others do not) and separate taxation systems (some have sales taxes, others do not). Only a Supreme Court ruling can over-turn state law by, for example, declaring something (such as abortion) to be a legal right which a state legislature may not deny.
The rest of Daley’s piece is just as spot on. I’m often baffled in discussions with my more liberal friends. They either fail to see the pitfalls of having a centralized government with unlimited power or they are seemingly naive and are just hoping that this all-powerful government will always side on issues according to their individual beliefs and choices.
It doesn’t work that way. You may be excited, for example, if the federal government was empowered to step in and declare gay marriage legal. Would you be as excited if the government decided that two years of military service for all citizens was a necessary requirement (and that “conscientious objector” isn’t a valid out)? You may be overjoyed to hear that the federal government is going legalize marijuana across all states. Would you be equally happy to learn that it was going to make abortions illegal?
I’ve actually had discussions about systems of government where people suggest that “benevolent dictator” falls above “democracy” in desirability. I couldn’t disagree more strongly. Benevolent dictators are like parents for a society–deciding on things because the society is too immature or otherwise incapable of deciding for themselves. I don’t ever want to give up that right. Not to a single individual. Not to a centralized government.
Edit: A comment on a comment from reader Stan after the break.
]]>< 