I’ve been doing a lot of thinking about the Koran-burning dumbass in Florida, the Ground Zero mosque, and several other incidents in the recent past. And while, at first, there seems to be a bit of hypocrisy involved, it turns out there is a consistency at work in how the incidents are portrayed. A troublesome one, but a consistency nonetheless.
1) The Koran-burning dumbass: it’s his Constitutional right, but it inflames hatred and bigotry and puts Americans at risk around the world.
2) The Ground Zero Mosque: it’s their Constitutional right to build their “Islamic Cultural Center” there, and anyone who opposes their doing so is acting against the Constitution.
3) “Piss Christ:” It’s an exercise in free speech, and to denounce it is tantamount to censorship.
4) Mohammed cartoons: It’s free speech and free press, but it’s tremendously insensitive and should be reconsidered carefully because Islam forbids depictions of their Prophet.
5) “The Last Temptation Of Christ:” Viewed by many Christians as blasphemous and an attack against their faith, but an artist’s creative vision and protected.
6) South Park’s plans to depict Mohammed in cartoon form: a gross insult to the world’s Muslims, and a tremendous display of insensitivity and bigotry.
At first glance, the inconsistency stands stark: in the odd-numbered cases, the rights of the offenders to exercise their rights trump the rights of the offended to not be offended. In the even-numbered cases, the rights of the offended trump the rights of the offenders.
]]>< 