
There is a lot of noise about the 2024 Election, and all sorts of opinions about who will win and why. This includes a lot of poll reports in the media. But some clarity can be found by looking at the geography of the election, and sorting out where to find the meaningful positions.
I want to start with one fact that gets missed by a lot of people discussing the election. This is not a national election in the sense that you simply pile up the most votes in total. The United States is a Constitutional Republic, meaning that we elect our President using the Electoral College, and it takes 270 Electoral Votes or more to secure the White House. There are fifty states plus four districts which award Electoral Votes, meaning there are fifty-four contests, not one. Not surprisingly, this fact makes the election difficult to follow for some people, which is why the media usually just looks at the national total to claim someone is winning. But it is possible to work the number contests down to find the ones which will actually decide the election.
There are basically three types of states/districts in this election:
- States/Districts where the Republican or Democrat won the last two Presidential elections for the state or district, with 50.0% or more of the vote in both 2016 and 2020. There are twenty-two states and one district for the Republicans in this condition, worth 183 Electoral Votes, and thirteen states and two districts for the Democrats in this condition, worth 181 Electoral Votes. That effectively reduces the election to fifteen states and one district to decide the outcome, with Trump up 183-181 over Harris at this point;
- States/Districts where the Republican or Democrat won the last two Presidential elections for the state or district, and is also leading now in the aggregate state polling, but did not meet the first category. There are three states for the Republicans in this condition, worth another 52 Electoral Votes, and five states for the Democrats in this condition, worth 31 Electoral Votes. That effectively reduces the election to seven states and one district to decide the outcome, with Trump up 235-212 over Harris at this point;
- States/Districts which failed to meet the standards of the first two ranks. In order of Electoral Votes, the seven states and one district still undecided are as follows:
[] Pennsylvania (19 EV) Trump won 2016, lost 2020
[] Georgia (16 EV) Trump won 2016, lost 2020
[] Michigan (15 EV)
[] Virginia (13 EV)
[] Arizona (11 EV) Trump won 2016, lost 2020
[] Wisconsin (10 EV)
[] Nevada (6 EV)
[] Nebraska, 2nd Congressional District (1 EV)
Trump needs 35 more Electoral Votes to win the White House. Harris needs 58 more Electoral Votes to win the White House. Trump can win the White House with as few as two of the remaining seven states, while it will take Harris wins in at least four of the seven states to win the White House. This, basically, is why Nate Silver says Trump is more likely to win the White House.
It can also be helpful to look at who is leading in the polls in each of the seven remaining battleground states.
[] Pennsylvania (19 EV) : RCP 48.2-45.5 Trump, 270 46.9-46.6 Trump, 538 46.0-46.4 Harris
[] Georgia (16 EV): RCP 48.2-44.6 Trump, 270 48.2-45.6 Trump, 538 47.0-44.8 Trump
[] Michigan (15 EV): RCP 46.3-48.3 Harris, 270 44.5-45.8 Harris, 538 43.8-44.7 Harris
[] Virginia (13 EV): RCP 44-49 Harris, 270 44.3-46.7 Harris, 538 43.4-42.6 Trump
[] Arizona (11 EV): RCP 49.0-44.8 Trump, 270 48.4-44.6 Trump, 538 47.0-44.2 Trump
[] Wisconsin (10 EV): RCP 48.2-48.0 Trump, 270 46.8-47.4 Harris, 538 45.2-45.4 Harris
[] Nevada (6 EV): RCP 47.5-43.5 Trump, 270 46.5-43.8 Trump, 538 46.0-42.8 Trump
[] Nebraska, 2nd Congressional District (1 EV): RCP no poll, 270 no poll, 538 no poll
The outcome by each aggregation site would be as follow, therefore:
RealClearPolitics: Trump 297, Harris 240, 1 unassigned
270toWin: Trump 287, Harris 250, 1 unassigned
FiveThirtyEight: Trump 281, Harris 256, 1 unassigned
At this time, all the major poll aggregators show Trump in position to win.


