
One thing about media coverage of the election that makes me chuckle, is the notion that the candidates are running effective, targeted campaigns. While this notion is true for some campaigns, in the present season it is laughably off the mark. Trump’s unhelpful posts and comments are well known, and the Harris campaign has already shown serious unforced errors. More on that in a little while, but my starting point is that media is based on the story they want to sell, the narrative, not the actual facts at hand. The reason media does that, is because they exist to sell a story, and for that they need to make people believe in the drama they are creating.
The 2024 Election is unique in the fact that Trump is the GOP nominee for the third straight time. Aside from anything else, that means the 2016 and 2020 elections are especially relevant in the context of 2024. So let’s take a quick look back at those elections, and what they tell us.
People who don’t like Trump, and that is most people, don’t like to think of Trump as beating the odds, but that is what Trump did in 2016. Trump entered the 2016 campaign in the summer of 2015, and of course Trump had no prior experience in Politics. When that point is understood, Trump’s primary wins leading to the Republican nomination are very remarkable, and reveal things about Trump’s intelligence, the timing of his campaign, and conditions in the nation during that election season. The prevailing narrative from the media of that time is that Trump won because Hillary Clinton was such an abysmal candidate, but that story dilutes the accomplishments of both Trump and Clinton to win their party nominations. While it’s true that the DNC preferred Clinton over Sanders for the nomination and played around with some delegates to make sure she won in the end, Clinton still had to establish her political chops in taking the initial lead. And pretending Trump was just handed the GOP nomination not only insults his work and strategy, it also insults the more than dozen serious GOP contenders, ranging from Governors to Senators. But the media played the tune they wanted people to hear.
Clinton led in the polls throughout the 2016 campaign, and the media probably helped create a false impression that she would win easily. Clinton also made an important mistake in spending time and energy in a lot of stops in states she could not seriously hope to win, which hurt her late in the campaign when Clinton exhausted herself physically and she failed to make critical appearances in the Rust Belt states. But that helps remind me that elections are a long campaign, especially national races with so many states and districts to consider. Something we should keep in mind as we look at 2020 and 2024.
A lot has already been written about 2020. In a prior post I noted that Trump improved his share of the popular vote in thirty-three states, yet he still lost to Joe Biden, which helps to explain why Trump found the loss so hard to accept. The reason Biden won, by the numbers, is because he improved from Clinton’s 2016 numbers in every state. The only way that odd condition can happen, is because the share by third-party candidates dropped significantly from 2016 to 2020.
Basically. the 2020 election can be placed into one of three causes:
1 – Biden was so popular that he won 81 million votes, and it just so happened that minor-party support dropped from 5.7% of the total vote to 1.9%;
2 – Biden’s campaign cheated to steal the 2020 election; or
3 – Voters strongly disliked both major candidates in 2016, leading to more than one in twenty voting for someone other than Trump or Clinton, but in 2020 they decided they had to choose one or the other, dropping the minor-party shar to under one in fifty. Trump gained some support but remained largely unpopular, while Biden was popular enough to gain a greater portion of the changing voters.
Looking at these one at a time, the first and second options fall apart quickly from discussions already had, so it defaults to the third option. The significance of this, is to consider what level of minor-party support will occur in 2024. To put this in context, here are the minor-party support levels for US Presidential elections since 1944 (eighty years ago):
1944: 0.7% minor-party share, incumbent candidate won re-election
1948: 5.3% minor-party share, incumbent candidate won election but was a surprise
1952: 0.5% minor-party share, challenger won election
1956: 0.6% minor-party share, incumbent candidate won re-election
1960: 0.7% minor-party share, challenger won election
1964: 0.4% minor-party share, incumbent candidate won election
1968: 13.9% minor-party share, challenger won election (incumbent not re-nominated)
1972: 1.8% minor-party share, incumbent candidate won re-election
1976: 1.9% minor-party share, challenger won election
1980: 8.3% minor-party share, challenger won election
1984: 0.6% minor-party share, incumbent candidate won re-election
1988: 1.0% minor-party share, incumbent party candidate won election
1992: 19.6% minor-party share, challenger won election
1996: 10.1% minor-party share, incumbent candidate won re-election
2000: 3.7% minor-party share, challenger won election
2004: 1.0% minor-party share, incumbent candidate won re-election
2008: 1.4% minor-party share, challenger won election
2012: 1.7% minor-party share, incumbent candidate won re-election
2016: 5.7% minor-party share, challenger won election
2020: 1.9% minor-party share, challenger won election
So minor-party share has ranged from 0.4% (1964) to 19.6% (1992) of the total vote, and only one incumbent party candidate has won re-election with more than 1.8% minor-party share (Clinton in 1996). Basically that means Kamala Harris has to hope for a low minor-party share.
The current RCP average says there is an 8.5% minor-party share, while 270towin says 10.67% of voters support a minor-party candidate. That’s bad news for Harris by the history here. But to understand why, you need to understand the demographic landscape
Some demographics get a lot of attention in the media, like how Democrats do better with unmarried women while Republicans do better with married men. But few people pay attention to variable demographics, such as Black Men or Suburban voters. What I mean by ‘variable demographics’, is a group which can change significantly from one election to another. Attention to those variable demographics, especially in battleground states, can give important indicators to who is winning or will win the election.
The state polls released do not often have useful demographic detail available to public, but I can see how battleground states’ demographic results in 2016 and 2020 compared to national norms.
Let’s look at the key demographics and observe which ones could drive the outcome. Trump won the majority of Male voters in both 2016 and 2020, along with White voters, Married voters, voters who never went to College, Republicans and Rural voters. An average of the national polls in RCP with cross-tab data as of August 15 shows Trump has 16.6% average support among Black voters, continuing from 8% in 2016 and 12% in 2020. Trump has risen in support from Hispanics from 28% in 2016 to 32% in 2020, to a 38.9% average support in current polling, and Trump has risen in support from Asian voters from 27% support in 2016 to 34% in 2020, and now sits at a 37.3% average support from Asian voters. Trump has also improved his support in Urban areas, from 34% in 2016 to 38% in 2020, to an average of 39.8% support in current national polling averages.
The narrative in the media these days is that Harris is strong and in position to win. The actual numbers tell a very different story.


