Cindy Sheehan, the mother of a U.S. soldier killed in action in Iraq, has written a column for The Huffington Post that’s getting some attention in the mainstream media.
I thought I’d respond to some of the statements she makes.
This is George Bush’s accountability moment. That’s why I’m here. The mainstream media aren’t holding him accountable. Neither is Congress. So I’m not leaving Crawford until he’s held accountable.
Why is this the President’s “accountability moment?” Because Cindy Sheehan and the anti-war activists tell us it is? It seems to this observer that the President’s “accountability moment” happened back on November 2nd, when he was put back in office by a majority of electoral votes after receiving a significant majority of the popular vote. The President has been held accountable for Iraq by the American people, and those people put in back in office for another 4 years.
]]>< 
Its just sad, grief has clearly drivent the women mad. I’m pissed at those who are pushing her forward rather than comforting her in her grief.
Tob
You are a toady if you side with the devil agaist a mom
oh, and Rob boy ‘If you say so, Cindy.’
Wow – such repartee!
You are a toady if you side with the devil agaist a mom
Wow – such repartee!
You should hold your tongue (typing finger) fool. Your response was no better, if not far worse . . .
Is the use of the name “toady” an example of your “repartee” Calvin or are you just playing stupid?
On second thought maybe your not playing
“double dittos” rob. she’s lost her way, and she’s disgracing herself.
thunder crashed over crawford last night and “SHUT THE HELL UP AND GO HOME” could be heard.
just for the record rob, she never mentioned anything about “forcing” kids into the military, she said “encouraged”…
why do people so easily forget that it’s the iraqi criminals that are teh evil ‘devils’? get your heads out of your asses ppl.
Everyone feels for a mother who lost her son. Unfortnately, she has let her anger get the best of her. I know that she thinks she is attacking the person most to blame, but she is misguided. She also doesn’t realize that all her “support” isn’t support at all but, rather, an attempt by the President’s enemies to take cheap shots at him without mussing up their hair.
The President loses this issue as soon as he acknowledges her. If he doesn’t talk to her, he’s unfeeling. If he does, then she can Say Anything (cheap plug for Rob) and get away with it since she is a grieving mother. Any repsonse from the President will either agitate the mother (unfeeling since she lost her son) or sound conciliatory and, thus, guilty.
He loses no matter what he does. There is hope though. In most cases, these types of protests die out because, eventually, people get tired of hearing the same thing over and over again. They will tune her out. Only the whackos on the extreme left will continue to pay her any attention. They can scream and shout all they want, but we al know what they are.
‘You are a toady…’
You are a poohpooh head
I saw some crosses in the vicinity with names on them. I hope the families of soldiers killed iraq sue Code Pink and the rest of them for uanuthorized usage of the name/image of their family member in this disgusting attempt at emotional blackmail. I don’t have any sympathy for this woman any more – she is not the only mother who lost a son in this war. Why is she acting like she is? What makes her pain and sorrow more special than any other mother’s?
You know if there were some people out there that would go down there and protest against the protestors. Alot of this crap would be such a big deal. Especially if some soldiers families did this and showed they supported the president.
There’s plenty of military families that support our president. I dunno if it’s not being covered or if they’re not physically showing support.
I would gladly protest against the protestors.
Bush and his hip pocket cronies now have to deal with their agendas of lies and deceptions in order to go to war. All off you Bush supporters…not troop supporters… are blind…still…but the majority of Americans are waking up. The meltdown has begun and you can’t stop it. You can’t stop truth…no matter how much smearing you do.
61% She must have learned math from Ted Rall.
Why do we automatically assume a mother must be virtuous? Would it be wrong to side against Andrea Yates or Lucria Borgia?
I am sorry that Cindy Sheehan lost her son, but let me pose a hypothetical. What if instead of every intelligence agency in the world being wrong about Iraq’s WMDs they had been right? Wouldn’t we be a lot sorrier now? Especially if he had launched a strike at Israel or the US. That’s the choice that was facing us. what would all of you be saying if Bush had allowed the status quo to be maintained and merely lobbed a couple missles at Afghanistan and called it good?
I would like to be more understanding to Ms. Sheehan in her greif but I can’t.
The rest of their family think she is a self-serving nut. The heroic boy volunteered to serve his country with full knowledge of the dangers of war. He is the story, not her.
I declare this a liberal accountability moment. Anti-war protesters weaken resolve, embolden the enemy, lower morale, which in the end gets more soldiers killed.
There are few people worldwide who cannot sympathize with a mother’s (a PARENT’S) grief at the loss of a child.
Such that, here we have a woman, an individual, who has capitalized upon that sympathy — whether she’s done so intentionally or is out of touch to the degree that she does not perceive about what she is motivated and by whom is a good point to consider here, given the groups and other individuals with whom she’s affiliated — who is dispiriting that sympathy and denigrating her son’s service.
Bin Laden says he intends to destroy the United States, Castro opines similarly for similar reasons, and many others who endorse and assist terrorist groups/means along with them…they all rely on the ongoing dissipation of faith in the country’s efforts, in our nation as a group and civilization. Unfortunatley, the Left in the U.S. is all too eager to assist that process and what I can’t figure out is why. It’s either irrational egoism by attention-seeking persons or irresponsible antisocialism, or, probably both, but what the Left proves over and over again is that they are all too willing victims of those who intend true suffering, if not destruction, upon our democracy.
But, again, to what end? What’s the “end result,” the profit, if you will, the benefit of the “anti war” sentiments, particuarly: they never actually want an end to violence, but an escalation of violence — it just depends on how “violence” is defined because the Left uses psychological and economic violence like a rapier.
I think most the rest of us just aren’t intimidated. War is a terrible thing, yes, but sometimes there are no other choices — responding to threats from those who are barbaric isn’t realistic when it’s done with free sandwiches and pretty pink teeshirts and hats. No one likes war, wants war, but maligning those who protect and defend when necessary is entirely dishonorable. Even when it’s done by a grieving mother.
I watched the O’Reilly appearance and there is just no way…no.way…that O’Reilly could ever be described as “attack(ing)” this woman (or others who make similar claims). He questioned her. He posed alternatives to her positions. He provided her time — more than usual — to speak, to express herself. He didn’t malign her, he didn’t humiliate her, he made no untoward suggestions or comments…
I think what it is is that this woman has a very slim grasp on reality and that she is being manipulated terribly because of that by those who are almost certainly aware of what they’re doing, and how.
Would Michael Moore attach himself to the emotional carcass of a mother who supports the war? Of course not! Beyond exploiting her for cheap propaganda, Sheehan’s worth to the left is ZERO. It’s sick.
Sheehan, willingly or not, is being used by radicals that include leftwing Jew haters and fascists. Some way to “remember” your son!
Although Stewart does seem to be a dreamer, this: ” Bush and his hip pocket cronies” was a nice turn of phrase. Who says that the cognatively impaired can’t be literate?
And Suzy, I wholeheartedly agree with this: “I think most the rest of us just aren’t intimidated. War is a terrible thing, yes, but sometimes there are no other choices”. Growing up in the Cold War gives one a sense of fatalism. We pretty much believed that a nuclear conflict with the old USSR was inevitable and that we would lose, (socialist supermen, command state and all that) but we internalized the saying, “Better to die on your feet than to live on your knees”. I still marvel that we survived and that Ronaldus Magnus ended up toppling the commie superstate.
Tob
The most important question Ms. Sheehan could and should be asking is one to herself. And that is: Am I honoring my son’s death with this vigil?
Given the unabashed media coverage and the gaggle of columnists using this as fodder for their ant-war agendas and platforms, Ms. Sheehan’s is undermining the very troops she claims she wishes to protect.
in fact, her actions empower our enemy to to believe that if they kill just one more soldier, detonate one more IED to take out a column of Marines, that America will turn tail, run back home and become the very “paper tiger” bin Laden and his sick brethren believed we were on September 10, 2001.
To empower and embolden our enemy this way, puts our troops in greater danger and only serves to stain the memory of those lost, and to make their loss truly in vain—particularly those and that of Army Spc. Casey Sheehan.
Casey volunteered for the Army. He was constantly aware of the danger. Soliders in training are repeatedly told this. To feign or imply that Casaey did not know this is a lie.
God rest Casey’s soul. God rest the souls of all our fallen soldiers. I think and pray for all of them. But this is not the way to honor them, Ms. Sheehan. This is not the way.
Bush is stoked about this Sheehan thing…It has cleaned the slate of his last F-up…Karl Rove, and as far as I can see it was either a mother with one less child, or raising the TERROR ALERT. We are fucked already so…. Bush in ’08!
“Bush in ’08!” That must be Jeb.
It’s amazing and pretty darned amusing how frightened conservatives are of this former Catholic Youth Minister and Mom, Cindy Sheehan. All the press she is generating has got you folks pretty freaked out, from the looks of the previous posts. Now THAT”S entertainment! So just stay freaked out and yell really loud because it just means more press about this. And by the way, it’s a tad early to be declaring any kind of victory for Rove since the Federal Grand Jury investigation isn’t over until October. Yes, Bushbots, you SHOULD be scared. Your house of cards is crumbling, one cowardly criminal at a time.
“Yes, Bushbots, you SHOULD be scared. Your house of cards is crumbling, one cowardly criminal at a time.”
Still waiting for the one. 😉
Tob
I am not sympathetic toward this stupid woman..I dont think her loss has caused her to go mad..she is simply a moonbat who is using her sons death to make a name for herself and her silly cause..she is an incoherent mouth piece for those who wish to see America fail.
Btw here is Sheehan’s response to the letter on Drudge, which incidentally has disappeared from his page:
Still putting out the O’Reilly fires of me being a traitor and using Casey’s name dishonorably, my in-laws sent out a press statement disagreeing with me in strong terms; which is totally okay with me, because they barely knew Casey. We have always been on separate sides of the fence politically and I have not spoken to them since the election when they supported the man who is responsible for Casey’s death. The thing that matters to me is that our family — Casey’s dad and my other 3 kids are on the same side of the fence that I am.
Oh Toby, Toby, Toby. It’s coming and you know it. Just come on and admit you’re scared. By a Mom. So go on, give this some more press. Scream and shout and whine and spew vitriol all over the blogosphere. Show up in Crawford and do it there too. We welcome you with open arms. It only helps the liberal cause. What a lovely gift! So thank you. Really, thank you. 😉
Sheehan met with Bush last year and said nice things about him after the visit. Now she wants to join the Left Wing Pity Posse (ala Kristin Breitweiser and the 9-11 Jersey Gals) so she wants a do-over.
I say: No Mulligans! That was the other President.
But enjoy the Crawford ambiance and perfect weather for camping. Normally it’s well over a 100 degrees this time of year, but it’s only in the high 90s with 90 percent humidity and an occasional gully washer to make sure the mosquitoes don’t go thirsty.
Wow, evidence of the misinformation machine at it’s best, capitano! Watch something besides Fox News and read something besides Drudge, would you? It’s important to stay well informed so you don’t look like a total DoucheTard. Unless, of course, that is what you are going for. In that case, mission accomplished! We are laughing AT you, not with you, capitano. Just so you know, since you obviously don’t pick up on much. HA!
S wonders: “But, again, to what end? What’s the ‘end result,’ the profit, if you will, the benefit of the ‘anti war’ sentiments?”
I’ll tell what it is: They are wannabes. They know they are so clueless that they can’t possibly succeed within the existing system. So they want to get rid of it. Unable to carry out this function themselves, they align themselves with anyone who appears powerful enough and ruthless enough to do the job they won’t do themselves. And then they think that, after the revolution, they will be in power. They will have control. Their word shall be law. They will have life-and-death power. They will be able to eliminate all who aren’t exactly like them.
Because that’s their real problem. They cannot tolerate diffferences of opinion, of thought, of beliefs. The universe is not just as long as any exist who do not think as they do. In a just universe, all of their wishes would come true. Ergo, it follows that the presence of these dis-believers is what prevents the universe from being a just one. It becomes a philosophical mandate (a religious one, if you will) for them to eliminate all others so that the universe will be pure and just and pork chops will grow on trees and the entire Earth will enjoy San Diego weather year-round. Mind you, it’s not anything that the dis-believers do that prevents the universe from being a just one — it’s their very existence, in the same way that James Randi’s presence prevented all of those psychic experiments from working.
Deep in their hearts, I think the moonbats realize that their entire premise is a fairy tale, and that they are doomed to go through life as bitter, disaffected wannabes. But they can’t admit it to themselves, because without that bitterness, their lives would have no purpose. And then what would they do? Enjoy life like other people do? Surely you jest.
OK, I’m like totally humbled and recant my earlier statement.
Crawford really is an urbane mix of Davos and Seattle.
Cousin Dave said:
Because that’s their real problem. They cannot tolerate diffferences of opinion, of thought, of beliefs. Hello Pot? This is kettle. You’re black! Go back and read what I said to capitano. You have to get out of your echo chamber every once in a while or you risk the level of ignorance you display above. Although, as far as entertainment value goes, you are pretty damn funny!
capitano said: OK, I’m like totally humbled and recant my earlier statement. Thanks. I knew you’d come around. Welcome to Reality: where intellectualism isn’t demonized and we can read above an eighth grade level. I’m glad you joined us now, because BOY do you have a lot of catching up to do!
“WE welcome you with open arms”.
“WE are laughing at you”.
what’s with all this “WE,WE” business lulu? you got a mouse in your pocket. you’re starting to sound like one of those terrorist videos. you know, the one’s put out by the type that killed sheehan’s son. you are insufferable.
And you, JAB, are frightened. Oh, and entertaining! “Mouse in your pocket?” DAMN, you ought to be doing stand-up with material like that.
Let me be clear. No one has more right to express their views and receive support for their efforts than those who have suffered the loss of a child that they reared and/or bore. Ms. Sheehan, in my opinion, has exposed the Limbaugh’s, Hannity’s and O’Reily’s for what they are … puppets of the Republican Party. Those who are conservative and share many of the views of these puppets should tell them, the puppets, they have crossed the line.
Why?
Because we are at war with terrorism. And the more divided we become the more of my and your great grandchildren (yet to be born -some of you will get this… the others need to read some philosophy…) will die because we are not united. My President, I know that many people don’t feel that way but if you believe in freedom – we have no choice to accept that, has acted in a manner that fails to take into consideration the importance of unity of the American People. He fails to see that victory in this war will come at a heavier cost if he does not make every effort to achieve consensus. He seems to operate with the arrogance of a dictator. Those of you who voted for him should think about the future. Would that future be more secure if our leader listened to opposing views and made efforts to take a course of action that brings most of America with him. It is you who voted for George Bush who has a responsibility to your fellow American to understand that preponderance of evidence that President Bush lied … mislead and tries to destroy, via character assassination against, anyone who does not embrace his view hook line and sinker. It is you who must hear Ms. Sheehan’s pain and tell President Bush not worry about the polls …That above all else he has a duty to answer to the American People. It is you, the Americans who support him, that need to make him understand that he, President Bush, is nothing in relation to unity of this Nation must have to destroy our enemies.
Did you really just sign off with the name of a dead marine, or is your name really Juan Garza?
(I guess I shouldn’t talk since I am not, in fact, a mantis.)
um….
‘scuse me…what exactly did this woman do to make everyone here so angry?
Just curious.
“Btw here is Sheehan’s response to the letter on Drudge, which incidentally has disappeared from his page”
I’ve been in touch with both Cherie Quartarolo and Melanie Morgan. You can see the comments here.
http://angrygwn.mu.nu/archives/111459.php
http://angrygwn.mu.nu/archives/111600.php
Also, I’ve noted another response from Cindy Sheehan to the rest of her family (which is now minus her husband, apparently), and it’s frighteningly cultish.
http://angrygwn.mu.nu/archives/111632.php
Yes,
I am the real deal. I was not aware of a name sake giving his life for our liberty.
I don’t believe in handles to much…
“Scream and shout and whine and spew vitriol all over the blogosphere.”
I have never spewed vitriol and only whined a little bit.
LOL
Lulu, do you even read the posts your commenting on? I’m just waiting for the FIRST Bush administration figure to be indicted or to leave ‘under a cloud’. To my knowledge, there haven’t been any. I declare the Bush administration ‘The most ethical administration in modern times’.
Lulu, are you really you JoeMama or JMAR returned from the banned? 😉
Tob
“what exactly did this woman do to make everyone here so angry?”
I’m not angry, just saddened at this woman pain and angry at those who use her.
Tob
Good point, Zeppo1. Their anger stems from fear. Fear that this WH is being outed for the liars and criminals they are – by a dead soldiers MOM! – and all they can do is stand by helplessly and watch it all happen. And they’re also angry simply because they can’t stand being wrong. They hate that!
Whoa! Someone wrote that us conservaives were “angry,” that Ms. Sheehan had induced “anger” among Republicans, had “exposed” (various media OpEd individuals)…
Next we’ll be reading that Ms. Sheehan can shoot lightnin’ bolts from her arse. No, wait, that was William Wallace, who, by comparison, I admired and still do.
Let’s see…the last time I was “angry” was…you know, I can’t recall feeling “angry” at most anything recently. Concerned about specific issues over time but not “angry.” Certainly I am not nor have been recently “angry” about a person in the news who from her appearances is emotionally troubled (d’oh). Not the sort of person nor her incidents about which I feel “anger” or respond in kind, even. As in, I’m not calling Ms. Sheehan a “sneaky, stupid poopoohead” or something, demanding she come out to CA and “meet with me — and now! Meet with me now! Are you too afraid?”
And lulu, somehow “your” (as in, that group that you use to refer to yourself) “open arms” … um, nothankyew.
The only people displaying emotional disturbance about Ms. Sheehan are Ms. Sheehan and the various upset opinions on this thread, hate mail about Ms. Sheehan (who, supposedly, if the hate mail is to be believed, the rest of the world is harming somehow — perhaps it’s the “we’re not meeting with (her)” thing) and various overheated columns about Ms. Sheehand and Rove and Bush and Rove, and, oh, Bush, and NeoCons and Rove and pink and Rove and…
In all seriousness, you all need to get a grip. I now see, however, how it is that Bill O’Reilly being polite and professional with Ms. Sheehan has caused her so much anxiety. There is nothing that anyone can write or opine that is not an “attack” and/or “anger” about Ms. Sheehan…in the perceptions of some.
The rest of us read about it, write an opinion about it when asked or it is suggested as topic, or our opinion is otherwise solicited (as here) and then go on and do the laundry. Or, in my case, the dishes and then drink a bottle of Pellegrino.
lulu, you should meet “minnie.”
Step out of the office for a few hours and there so many post to respond to.
“My President, […] we have no choice to accept that, has acted in a manner that fails to take into consideration the importance of unity of the American People.”
Juan, I appreciate the civility of you post, but please, it takes two to tango. One side can’t call someone a liar and warmonger and then decry the lack of unity. You can’t be devisive and then complain of division. (I didn’t even need to read any philosophy to figure that out 😉
As far as the worthiness of the war, we just have to disagree. Good thing we each get one vote. God, I love democracy.
Tob
Toby, as I said, “It’s coming and you know it.”
S, Mrs. Sheehan did not appear on Bill O’Reilly’s “show.” Are you sure you aren’t drinking something stronger than Pellegrino? So after doing the dishes, why on EARTH did you decide that you needed to return here and comment? Hmmm?
“”what exactly did this woman do to make everyone here so angry?”
I’m not angry, just saddened at this woman pain and angry at those who use her.
Tob”
Still confused. Who exactly is using her?