That’s what Assemblywoman Barbara Lifton (D-125th District) is proposing in the wake of the New York high court’s decision that the state constitution does not recognize same sex marriage.
“Let’s get government out of the wedding business and have everyone, equally, have a civil arrangement,” she said.
The proposal Lifton supports would replace the word “marriage” with “civil commitment” in state laws, creating a legal contract she said would be accessible to everyone, while leaving the religious aspect of the union to religious institutions.
“Why should state government become a religious institution?” she asked.
Ms. Lifton makes her idea sound so simple: it’s just replacing one word with another, that’s all. But it’s much more than that. It fundamentally turns the institution of marriage, the union of a man and a woman before God and man, into nothing but an impersonal and emotionless legal contract akin to a business transaction. In other words, if gays can’t marry, then no one can.
Stanley Kurtz at The Corner responds to Ms. Lifton’s proposal:
And as we’ve seen with [Michael] Kinsley and [Jonathan] Turley, if we’re no longer talking about “marriage,” multi-partner “civil commitments” will surely follow. In any case, it wouldn’t take multi-partner unions to make the abolition of civil marriage a disaster. Just removing public support for marriage as an institution would be damaging enough.
This proposal has no chance of passage right now. Yet it’s a clear sign that as same-sex marriage spreads, more and more people (including traditionally religious opponents of gay marriage), will begin to look to the abolition of civil marriage as a “solution.” This is the reality of what same-sex marriage has brought: not a strengthening of traditional marriage, but calls for its abolition.
Indeed.
Added: If this proposal were to pass, does that mean that a New York man will no longer propose marriage to a woman, but he will instead propose a civil commitment? Just imagine that scene: the man and woman are at a posh, romantic New York restaurant. He gets on one knee, presents her with a beautiful diamond ring, looks lovingly into his girlfriend’s eyes and asks, “will you enter into a civil commitment with me?”
You may think I’m being ridiculous, but considering how the PC crowd has had quite a bit of success removing politically incorrect language (Merry Christmas) and behavior (praying in public school or any mention of God in public school) from public life, the passage of a proposal like Ms. Lifton’s would give the PC thought police ammunition to work toward eliminating any mention of the word marriage from public discourse. Since marriage would no longer exist, the phrase “we’re getting married” would be labeled “outdated and bigoted,” not to mention meanspirited toward gay civilly committed couples because, as long as the term marriage was still used, it could cause them to feel like second class citizens. Instead the traditional institution of marriage would be relegated to people’s homes and churches, absent from public life.
It may sound crazy right now, but I can see the moonbat left pulling something like this.



“Les, it’s not a logical reason, but a moral one.”
Well at least you admit there is no logical reason that 3 men can get ‘married’ if 2 men can.
So you are saying that there is a moral reason 3 men can’t get married? What is that moral reason?
Give it up, totally matt; rwilymz already conceded that there is no Constitutional reason that 3 men can’t marry if 2 men can marry :
”
If you wish to see “three people” marriages, then petition your lawmakers. But when it happens, you cannot deny the three person marriage to three men OR three women without running into Equal Protection.”
Got that? :
“But when it happens, you cannot deny the three person marriage to three men OR three women without running into Equal Protection.””
HITLER WON AN ELECTION. What kind of person are you? I’ve been accused of moral relativism for urging calm when dealing with psychos with nuclear weapons. You’re clearly a relativist, though, which is morally indefensible.
So, you seek an empire? I mean, there is no other way we can make sure a government isn’t horrible outside of us directly controlling it and dictating all of its policies.
Thanks, but no thanks. I’m not interested in imperial conquests, personally.
We’re giving Iraq a chance to choose their destiny.
If they choose poorly, it is their problem, not ours.
As for Hitler — if anybody in Europe or the US ever told him “no” when he started taking over countries, he would’ve crumbled years earlier. His own generals knew they couldn’t hope to fight a war with any remotely competent army.
IT IS!
As long as somebody thinks so.
A cogent argument to back up this indefensible point would be lovely.
There is no *need* for the opposite sex within marriage
…nor is there need for only 2 people.
…nor is there need for non-family members.
Notice how easily your strained logic works for a lot of issues you don’t claim to agree with?
because procreation could occur as it does in the Handmaid’s Tale, or even in test tubes.
Since the genetic material would have to come from outside the marriage, your point would be laughable if it was not so painful.
[Marriage as loving bond] is VERY different from [marriage as one-way contract (wife can’t opt out, and has very few rights)];
Marriage between man and woman and marriage between man and man is not just fundamentally different, it is a complete change of the entire concept.
whereas [marriage as loving bond between a man and a woman] is so similar to [marriage as loving bond between a man and a woman, or two of each] that I can’t even believe you made me address this point again
You’ve yet to address it in anything resembling and intelligent or logical manner. Don’t blame me for pointing that out to you.
You’re just being stubborn.
I feel the same of you.
Notice how I’m not whining about it, though?
As for the “fundamental aspects” of marriage: do you mean a man’s right to beat his wife with a stick no wider than his thumb?
Why, yes, that is exactly what I was referring to. I’ve often defended the abuse laws of the past. Why, I have a hard time NOT defending them on a daily basis.
…or you could point to what I wrote that even approaches the ballpark from where you’re swinging at your self-created softballs from.
You want to talk about a lack of logic? Well, what kind of logic is “because that’s the way it’s always been done!”?
What kind of logic is “Well, yeah, it’s equal — but it’s not the equality I like. And screw the ‘whackos’ who win majorities opposing this in every state where it gets on the ballot”?
t’s not logic, it’s an emotional appeal to tradition. Bill O’Reilly is a traditionalist, and he’s a very stupid man. Again: do better!
In a news flash, I am not Bill O’Reilly.
Try arguing with me and not the straw men you seem so fond of concocting.
To question the sincerity of an entire movement that is demanding equality in the eyes of the law: yes, you are.
Well, I do find it necessary to run my beliefs by you. I’m glad you clarified it for me.
So, since you apparently have come to the conclusion that you are, in fact, God — is there anything else us lesser mortals should think or believe?
Hate to get you upset and all.
How does letting gay people get married cheapen the idea of marriage for you?
The same way you claim that polygamistic marriages would cheapen marriages. Or incestual marriages.
All can easily be justified using the identical phrases — heck, verbatim phrases — you use to justify this.
Marriage isn’t like Harvard Law School, where you get to brag about the credential based on its exclusivity.
Then care to explain why you are so passionate over something that is not “special” in your eyes?
Just trying to piss in everybody else’s pool?
Some mouth-breathers in the Bible Belt actually might actually believe that The Gay is trying to take over the world, and that being allowed to get married somehow plays an integral part in their scheme, but you’re smarter than that.
Thank you for caricaturing an entire portion of the country as troglodytes. Pretty open-minded of you there.
Notice how I’m not saying gays are, you know, “bad”?
Why is it so hard for you to do the same?
People questioned the motives of First-Wave feminists and civil rights activists, but history has shown those insincere sceptics to be complete and utter douche bags.
Then we watched the civil rights groups and feminist groups morph into laughable coalitions backing such reprehensible laws as “hate crime” legislation and making the phrase “Betty, that’s a nice shirt” an open invitation to legal action.
Yup, things NEVER go the opposite extreme.
And I know you know you’ve lost this argument. You’re being ridiculous, Mike. Gay marriage advocates cannot win support in the public forum, so they have to get the courts to impose it on people, which will lead to gradual public acceptance, as it did with bi-racial marriages and no-fault divorce.
Do you REALLY want to defend no-fault divorce? THAT was a winner of a policy.
And, apparently, groups now don’t want to even go through the effort of trying to convince people. They simply want to convince a group of lawyers who are unaccountable to go along with really specious reasoning behind their case.
Who says they can’t win? I mean, sure, calling all of America bigots and the like isn’t going to win you many votes.
But you can TRY and MAKE A CASE FOR YOURSELF. Nothing will guarantee you a lack of social support for your policies like refusing to even attempt to make the case.
Don’t like things being imposed on you? Well, don’t get born in a developed nation next time.
I could the same to you — but unlike with you, I actually support the whole evil “democratic process” and if the gay marriage advocates got it passed, I’d applaud them for it.
But your side doesn’t feel you have to. You’re too good to lower yourself to try and make a case that changing something in as fundamental way as humanly possible is a good idea.
Don’t complain to others because your side won’t spend any time or effort trying to make their argument.
And I don’t claim to be in the mainstream. I’m proud that I’m not, actually.
And here comes the elitist crap that turns the country off your “message”.
Have you heard some of the shit Americans will believe? And the piece of shit movies they’ll pay to see? But creationists in the Bible Belt aren’t in the mainstream either.
Yes, you’re just too gosh-darn wise to fall for what those average Americans think.
Those rubes, eh?
And keep in mind that I’m not thinking too highly of what you believe, so your elitist brush can go both ways. I’m just too civil to do that.
BTW, nice of you to mention creationism, since it could not possibly have less to do with this topic than it does. It’s not even a remotely cogent analogy.
They’re a vocal minority who only care about imposing their morals on other people and I’d be happy to see them all go live in a giant bunker in Utah or Alabama or wherever and leave us folks who aren’t afraid of Spongebob Squarepants’ ambiguous sexuality here to deal with the Armageddon.
To quote you:
They cannot win in the public forum. Don’t like things being imposed on you? Don’t live in a developed country.
Notice how easily your arguments — weak as they are — can be used to justify a wide array of things?
And the elitism is REALLY a nice touch. The reason your side wants to go to court is that you have such contempt for the public-at-large — heck, a hatred of those who disagree with you — that you want to be able to “make them” do what you want and taunt them while doing it.
Bullying by tort is quite an innovative tactic. Loathesome, but innovative.
And all of your examples of the SCOTUS issuing immoral, fucked-up judgements are extremely dated.
“Sure they screwed up before. But it won’t happen NOW. No chance of that.”
Hamdan vs. Rumsfeld isn’t, but it’s not in the same ballpark as Dred Scott. It’s a different issue, one that both sides can debate.
Yes. Applying the Geneva Conventions to groups specifically listed as not being covered BY THE CONVENTIONS is quite the topic that can be debated.
But whether gay marriage should be legal? Nah, no need to debate THAT.
The difference here is that rather than argue both sides empirically and/or ideologically, hardening the trenches, and then shaking hands (or hocking loogies) and walking away from the battlefield, you’ve been routed.
You seem to mentioning, with some frequency, some “victory” you’ve “won” here.
Sounds like you’re trying to convince yourself of that. If you call empty rhetoric, shallow logic, and elitist emotionalism “winning”, then you’ve performed admirably.
Note how I don’t mention how I’m “routing” you here, even though it is painfully obvious that it is the case?
It’s because I don’t NEED to mention it. Reality is too hard to miss.
If you are shooting for logical consistency, you’ve not done yourself or your family proud.
Sorry.
I’m done rebutting every single point you feel like trying to make.
You started?
When?
Conservatives reading this thread either went away because there is nothing left to be said or they agree with those of us who accept the logic of same-sex marriage advocates.
Or they found you tiresome.
I’m sure your theory is more sound though.
Hee hee hee.
You’ve made it very clear that you don’t like the SCOTUS stepping in and righting the ship, and that’s fine, but I suggest you go start your own country where the majority has an unqualified right to exert its influence.
But how will I live without you telling me what is right and wrong? I mean, you’re the dispenser of all worldly knowledge and all.
You can’t accept the distinction between 1) majority rule buttressed by court checks and 2) an oligarchy, so I’m done with this issue.
Or, more precisely, you’ve never had a point and are getting pissy that I don’t buy into your whiny emotional rhetoric and that I won’t call you homophobic slurs because, deep down, I don’t care if gay marriage is legal or not.
Take a deep breath and re-read a lot of this thread, because I think that you and other opponents of same-sex marriage have made as good a case as possible against it and lost the argument beyond a shadow of a doubt. Remember it when the SCOTUS forces Congress to respect gay couples’ wishes in the near future.
Again, another mention of how your side “routed” us.
Is it hard having to convince yourself of something you know to be false?
Les, it’s not a logical reason, but a moral one.
And with you being God and all — your morals are the only ones that matter.
And anyway I replied to your shitty slippery slope argument. (Search for “Don Juan”.) You guys got smacked down pretty hard, but it’s not your fault. It’s an issue that same-sex marriage advocates cannot lose in principle, so it’s a matter of time before that homophobe Scalia and his sidekick Clarence are replaced by people from this generation.
Wow, more slurs of men far wiser than you.
Quite frankly, the gay community’s biggest problem in the world are “advocates” such as yourself. You take somebody like me, who only opposes the tactics, and makes me hope they never get to marry simply because I find you tiresome.
They have to persuade 5 out of 9 very well-versed legal scholars.
So, as I said, you like VERY limited democracy.
Your elitist nature has come out loud and clear and it makes you, honestly, a rather unpleasant person.
-=Mike
Hm, I seem to have written more than I expected to and probably still not been clear. Ah, well, on with the show –
—
“It fundamentally turns the institution of marriage, the union of a man and a woman before God and man, into nothing but an impersonal and emotionless legal contract akin to a business transaction.”
Nope. The word “marriage” is being used for two rather different things. Don’t get hung up on the religious side – that is where marriage is. But on the State side, it is a license recognizing a [limited] partnership, no more (and no less). Its purpose, when some truly brilliant bureaucrat dreamed it up for The Republic of Rome (pre-Empire) was and remains to ease a burden on government by being a cheap and easy (and sneaky, as the reason was obscured even then) way for people to achieve the effect of a will without having to contemplate death or even realizing they were doing so. In return for the license fee (collected by priests, in turn administered or licensed by the State), the State would apply a standard set of rules on the estates of people who died intestate. Before, dying without a will almost guaranteed a legal squabble: now, contesting the distribution of the estate would involve going up against the whole of the government, not just cousin Joe from Widespot-in-Road.
Will a man have to propose a “civil union” rather than a “marriage” then? Again, no: get married by your religious custom, and optionally get the same license as always from the State – no difference, except it may be called something other than a marriage license. Yes, optionally: you can be married within your religion and choose not to get the license, or conversely get the license without a religious ceremony. That is the way it works now! A few states will even forgo the fee, reasoning that a couple co-habiting for a certain length of time have established themselves with the same rights – usually called “common-law marriage”.
Will gays, polygamists, polyganists, etc. be able to get the State license? Not unless they already can. Somewhat related, I checked my own State’s law a while back: the homosexual thing is not addressed (the drafters fell into the language trap), but I noticed that the religions whose officiators can issue the license are explicitly stated and rather limited. A Shinto priest, for example, is not empowered to sign the license because that religion is not listed. OTOH, a number of judges, the Clerk of the Supreme Court, and oddly one town’s sherrif may issue the license, so if you can persuade one to do so it is not clear that it would be illegal.
You oppose the concept of the Supreme Court. You think 50%+1 of Americans need to think something is good in order for it to be made law. So you think that if slavery had been supported by the majority (as it was), that there could be no justification for making it illegal.
That’s all I need, Mike. You won’t address these critical counter-examples, because your position commits you to mob rule. You have lost this argument. Why? Because by claiming that the will of the people ought to be the only thing that matters, you commit yourself to accepting a lot of absurd and immoral conclusions. Doesn’t matter that they’re hypothetical–that’s how thought experiments work. And some of the examples aren’t even all that far-fetched. What if Milosevic Jr. (no such person) won an election and claimed that he was going to continue to “cleanse” the region of Albanians? “Will of the people! Let ’em do their thing!” would be your reply.
Well, it’s the wrong reply. It’s a failure to acknowledge and respect the universality of human rights, which transcend democratic processes. Same sex couples ought to be entitled to equal protection under the law, and the SCOTUS will see it that.
Ergo, you lose.
And where I come from, and with the people I hang out with, I have no problem with you calling me an elitist. I’m not running for office, and I’m not a high-level political consultant. I think that an exasperatingly large number of Americans hold stupid beliefs (i.e. creationism, that there is a place called “Hell”, that homosexuality is “unnatural”), and I’m proud to say that while I may not be smarter than them, my beliefs are better. Because I’m not a relativist. You are, remember?
And Les, I’m waiting for you to reply to my objection to polyamorous relationships, namely, that human psychology prevents an equal partnership within such relationships. Sure, the Mormons will scream “But we wanna!”, but again, morality isn’t about a show of hands.
Man, I’m tired.
“…and the SCOTUS will see it that [way eventually].”
“..human psychology prevents an equal partnership within such relationships.”
And when 3 people come forward and say ‘No, we’re fine with the equality of our threeway partnership and we demand to be married’ , then what? Their ‘human psychology’ is o.k. with it; who are you to say no?
‘Human psychology’ impels males and felmales to have sex with one another. If 1% of the population wants to be with the same sex, should we institutionalize that with ‘marriage’? If 1% of the population wants to be polygamous, should we institutionalize that with ‘marriage’?
If same-sex-marriage proponents were honest and said ‘we demand ss marriage. we also concede that if there is ss marriage, then there is no logical reason to prohibit three-way marriages.’, that would be one thing. But that is not the way the debate is portrayed to society.
Fact: if ss marriage is allowed, multi-marriages will be allowed.
(For the record, I really do not care if two guys (or whatever) shack up together. I see it as none of my business. However, it is not a Marriage.)
I’ve returned, sorry for the unavoidable abscence.
“Sorry, d_Brit, but your “logic” does not pass the test of historical accuracy. Please define “millenia of accumulated societal wisdom.” If you think that marriage throughout the centuries has been some version of the 1950s utopian “one father/one mother/2.2 kids/dog/white picket fence”, then you need to go back to your history books. The institution of marriage and ideas about child-rearing have certainly changed and evolved over the centuries. True, they did not include same-sex couples, but that change would be smaller than other marital changes over the years. Consider how radical it would have been for marriage to change from a simple property arrangement where the married couple may never have learned to love each other to an institution where the couple themselves fell in love and made the decision to marry. The institution survived radical re-definitions and will continue to do so.
Posted by: VA Gamer”
With the exception of a very few groups here and there, monogamy has been the norm for well over 2000 years. That monogomous relationship was commonly incorporated into extended families; grandparents, uncles, aunts, cousins, etc. all living together in a larger group dynamic.
There is a reason why the vast majority of society’s adopted the monogomous, opposite gender marriage dynamic; millenia of experience has demonstrated it to be the optimum arrangement for child-rearing and thus the most stable basis upon which to rest societal interactions. It best ensures the future benefits for posterity.
For you to state,”that change(same-sex marriage) would be smaller than other marital changes over the years.” is a patently false and even ludicrous assertion.
As example you compare arranged marriages with ‘modern’ marriages (with thier 50% failure rate and 75% re-marriage failure rate) the negative impact of divorce upon the children of failed marriages is all around us in the increasingly prevelent single-parent households with ‘young adults’ inability to bond in a mature relationship that withstands the test of time.
Then many, out of defensiveness, try to assert that neither a male role model nor a female role model is needed in the raising of children. Which is the defacto assertion of same-sex couples using scientific technology to gain what nature will not provide them.
Undoubtedly Prior Generations are rolling in their graves astonished at a level of immaturity and obtuseness that can barely be comprehended.
As for arranged marriages, you reveal the typical modern patronizing attitude toward what you have never investigated.
Most arranged marriages were and are NOT insensitive to the necessity that the couple like each other and demonstrate compatibility and a willingness to enter into what is considered (in society’s who use(d) arranged marriages) a sacred covenant, God ordained.
In times past, parents loved their children, female as well as male, just as much as today. Parents arranging a marriage for their children naturally sought a good match so that the union would be stable and of benefit to their children and thus extend to both family groups.
Hollywood and our modern society’s immature glorification of aolescent infatuation is responsible for our warped view of arranged marriages, using our natural outrage at the occasional injustice of a ‘forced arrangement’ to impugn any value to the practice.
Have you forgotten Romeo and Juliet? Their fictional nature is irrelevent because Shakespeare was writing a story that his audience could relate to, as every playwright must. Writing more than 500 years ago his audiences were quite familiar with romantic love. Great love affairs have been known since time immemorial, its nothing new and has undoubtedly been around since mankind developed individuality.
It is you whose historical perspective is very narrow when you talk of the 50’s, implying that I am advocating an idealized version of ‘Ozzie and Harriet’, with its nuclear family.
It is you who fail the ‘test of historical accuracy.”
As for the institution of marriage’s ability to weather this storm, certainly it will but for those able to see past the immediately obvious, it is the inevitable legal consequences of same-sex marriage that will provide the fatal ‘quicksand’ which marriage as an institution cannot survive.
The ‘equality of application’ is only manifest as to number, not gender.
Then the burden of proof lies with you to demonstrate why the gender criterion can be used discriminatorily instead of inclusively in this case.
I am agreeable to satisfying that burden in a subsequent post, though I have already laid out the basic presumptions of my position. However, it is you who has advocated change. It is thus incumbent upon you to satisfactorily address sincere objections to suggested changes. Especially when prior generations did not view restricting marriage to opposite genders as discrimination.
Same-sex marriage advocates deny the relevance of gender for equal application. Your exception is ad hoc, and follows either from tradition (not a good way to argue anything) or prejudice (ditto).
Simple denial of relevance does NOT equate to proof of irrelevance. Common law has held for time immemorial that gender is relevant; ultimately the burden of proof is upon the advocate for change.
Your disparaging of tradition reveals a youthful arrogance that assumes that good reasons for the establishment of precedent either never existed or are now false.
That is a presumption that experience frequently exposes as naïve.
Labeling a position which states that unintended negative consequences shall necessarily progress from the advocated change is NOT inherently prejudicial but it is a way for an intellectually challenged advocate to attempt to ‘win’ the debate.
“Thousands of years” is wholly irrelevant to the issue.
Wholly irrelevant…You are not only being pedantic but more pertinently, purposely obtuse.
I disagree. I think arguments against SSm based in traditionalism are pretty weak if said tradition has been, traditionally, incredibly elastic and vaguely defined.
I am NOT arguing against SSM out a simple position that it violates tradition. To misunderstand or mischaracterize my assertions as: ‘that’s not the way we’ve done it in the past’ ignores my central assertion; the inevitable legal consequences that progress from the inclusion of SSM within a newly redefined concept of ‘marriage’.
I am only using historical precedent and ‘tradition’ to challenge the idea that the increased knowledge of modern generations necessarily equates to increased wisdom.
You are well aware of the great antiquity of the institution of marriage. No doubt you are also aware of the long route society’s have taken to reach the consensus that children are optimally raised and society are best served through loving, monogamous, publicly committed couples of opposite gender. (Heterosexuals abysmal inability to meet that standard in no way invalidates its worth)
When did history check and see how well institutionalized gender-blind civil unions would serve society?
Sorry, not clever enough by half, this is a circular argument.
Liberals are biological evolutionists, not social evolutionists.
Please elaborate on your intended definition of a ‘biological evolutionist’ especially as it pertains to the discussion. If legalization of SSM isn’t social evolution, in this context, what is an example of social evolution?
There is no reason to assume that because our culture won out over, say, Native American cultures that children and families are better off as a result. All it shows is that one society beat another in a conflict. Irrelevant.
??? Sorry, how exactly is this relevant? I know it’s late and I’m certainly getting tired but this escapes me…
Those differences have been judged by almost all society’s to be essential in the raising of children into healthy adults.
Based on empirical research? Or based on incredulity at the very IDEA of buggerers having children? Why, they can’t even fornicate like Christians! And everyone knows how delicate lesbians are! Boys would develop no masculine traits in a lesbian “household”! (/jokes)
Actions speak louder than words. How we choose to raise our children is quite possibly the most profoundly important choice we make, certainly for the children and society, this is undeniable.
Do you really mean to suggest that we need scientists conducting ’empirical research’ to confirm that loving parents, in a committed relationship, providing a positive male and female role model for their children is the optimum arrangement?
To seriously suggest so is to argue with reality and our inherent nature OR you must necessarily presuppose that the gender differences that are naturally necessary for the reproductive process are strictly limited to the physical. That the male and female mental hard-wiring that we all undergo in the womb is of no societal consequence in the raising of children. Upon what would you base that assertion? Other than wishful thinking, that is…
On gays in the military: So you reject the assertion that it harms unit cohesiveness?
YES!!! You think gays are so unpatriotic that they would rather stare at hot Marine ass instead of doing their job? Canadians allow women into combat roles (rightly so), and thus far there have been no reports of patrols in Afghanistan getting ambushed because they were all too busy having sex with each other.
Really… Consider that: Men and women in the military are separated when bathing, etc. To not do so would certainly lead to a breakdown in unit cohesion, with natural sexual impulses creating difficulties.
Separating hetero and homosexual men and women from each other is impractical and would certainly lead to discomfort, as soldiers would know that some of the their sex were looking at them in a covetous manner. Just as hetero women would if they were forced to bath with men. We don’t reprimand women for a natural discomfort when ‘ogled’ by men, and in circumstances requiring public nudity it would be especially understandable. How is a hetero discomfited by sexual interest they are constitutionally incapable of returning, less understandable?
Throw men and women together in the pressure cooker of combat and you certainly will get increased sexual activity. Increased sexual activity inevitably leads to pregnancies. Do you seriously doubt this? BTW, exactly what are the statistical pregnancy levels of those women in combat units?
Not to be pedantic, but you left out the constitutional qualifier as to the state having the power to make any law it wants…
Don’t be silly. He meant laws that are within their authority to issue. He obviously knows a thing or two about what he’s talking about, so you could assume he understands that the Constitution applies to Congress.
I knew what he meant. I was responding to his patronizing attitude toward Darlene. Or do you think he shouldn’t have to partake of the same ‘medicine’?
Your logic is based in the premise that your secular relativism is superior to every previous generation’s perceptions about the optimum societal infrastructure. What absolute arrogance, you must be a baby boomer. Or have you simply accepted the pablum your college instructors fed you?
Well, you obviously didn’t go to college (which is fine) because you don’t know how to use the term “moral relativism”. Liberals are not relativistic on this issue. This is a human rights issue, and human rights are universal. To argue, though, that gay marriage is bad because a majority of Americans are opposed to it is paradigmatically relativistic. … Posted by: Totally Matt
I purposely chose the word ‘secular’ rather than ‘moral’ because it is the source of his morality.
As for college, you’re right that attendance is not a ‘qualifier’ for the worth of an assertion, or veracity in discussion.
However just to provide ‘full disclosure’ I hold two degrees and attended college for six years.
More importantly, the truly educated never graduate…when you are 57, and still learning as am I, then we can have a meaningful discussion about the difference between wisdom and knowledge.
Liberals are ‘relativistic’ on every issue, you believe in ‘shades of gray’ excluding black and white. (The truth is that reality is composed of both) Your problem is your inability to discern one from the other.
Upon what do you base ‘human rights’? Without Divine providence, you only have the rights that the ‘mob’ grants you in any time and place. Hardly a ‘universal’ principle, much less an eternal ‘right’. But ‘human rights’ that we grant to each other through agreement that they MUST exist (because we say so) IS a necessary liberal rationalization.
I am not arguing that same-sex marriage is bad because the majority oppose it. That is your false characterization of my position.
I am saying that same-sex advocates are ignoring the law of unintended consequence. That those consequences are legally inevitable and that they will prove deeply injurious to society’s most basic structural foundations.
Just for clarification, the above post was directed to Totally Matt.
Now I have to get to bed and get some sleep, talk about masochism…
I’ll return tomorrow, good night all.
Most arranged marriages were and are NOT insensitive to the necessity that the couple like each other and demonstrate compatibility and a willingness to enter into what is considered (in society’s who use(d) arranged marriages) a sacred covenant, God ordained.
d_Brit, the institution of marriage pre-dated the Christian Church. Romans established the institution as a property arrangement. The Christian Church did not even get involved in the marriage business during its first few centuries. They viewed it as the purview of the state. They were more focused on the debate of the need for celibacy in preparation for Christ’s second coming. (See St. Augustine’s “City of God,” “Confessions,” and letters). Celibacy was considered the best option. For those who could not remain celibate, marriage was the alternative.
Unfortunately, the word “marriage” carries too much baggage. We must separate religious “marriage” (d_Brit’s “sacred covenant”) from the civil “marriage” (legal contract between two people).
I would fight for a church’s right to define religious marriage in whatever way they deemed appropriate. However, it is pure discrimination to keep gay people from civil marriage. Perhaps we need to get the government out of the “marriage” business altogether. Maybe everyone should be granted a “civil union” from the government. Would that sooth those of you who oppose same-sex CIVIL marriage?
You oppose the concept of the Supreme Court.
Again, argue the points I make and not the ones you invent, ‘K? I support it FAR more than you support voting.
You think 50%+1 of Americans need to think something is good in order for it to be made law.
Again, continue arguing points you invent. It makes you look better.
When there is NO law at all about it — the courts have nothing, whatsoever, to rule on. So, a law must be passed.
So you think that if slavery had been supported by the majority (as it was), that there could be no justification for making it illegal.
Again, seeing as how SCOTUS made slavery WORSE, I’m not sure this is something you want to cite them.
Notice how they VOTED for Republicans to END it?
Voting works.
That’s all I need, Mike.
Invented arguments are fun.
You have lost this argument.
Have you started believing it yet?
I mean, I KNOW I’ve handed you your ass. I don’t feel the need to repeat it incessantly.
? Because by claiming that the will of the people ought to be the only thing that matters, you commit yourself to accepting a lot of absurd and immoral conclusions.
Again, stick with arguments I made and not ones you wish I made.
Doesn’t matter that they’re hypothetical–that’s how thought experiments work. And some of the examples aren’t even all that far-fetched. What if Milosevic Jr. (no such person) won an election and claimed that he was going to continue to “cleanse” the region of Albanians? “Will of the people! Let ’em do their thing!” would be your reply.
Seeing as how ALBANIA AIN’T AMERICA, yeah, there is nothing I’d do about it. I don’t want an empire of colonies.
After seeing how people like you gripe about our humanitarian mission in Iraq, your desire for it now is rather clearly a lie.
Then again, Albania couldn’t not possibly ever threaten the US, so you might support that.
Well, it’s the wrong reply. It’s a failure to acknowledge and respect the universality of human rights, which transcend democratic processes. Same sex couples ought to be entitled to equal protection under the law, and the SCOTUS will see it that.
They are given equal protection. You just don’t like equality, which is pretty much a given at this point.
And, again, unless you can find a way to guarantee rights in foreign countries without us possessing those countries, I’m sure we’d all be interested.
And where I come from, and with the people I hang out with, I have no problem with you calling me an elitist.
Your friends are jerks, too? Wow.
I think that an exasperatingly large number of Americans hold stupid beliefs (i.e. creationism, that there is a place called “Hell”, that homosexuality is “unnatural”), and I’m proud to say that while I may not be smarter than them, my beliefs are better.
Thank you, Mein Fuhrer. It takes a special level of non-education to believe as you do.
BTW, I thoroughly enjoyed watching d_Brit take you out back and smack you around. That was amusing, to say the least.
That you are so oblivious to how much of a jerk you are is funny.
-=Mike
This proposal sounds exactly like the old Communist system. Officially the country was atheist, therefore all parties married in a civil office. Really worked for the Communists.
Les: Sigh…
Polygamists can’t claim that there relationship follows from their psychology, because it doesn’t. It’s socialized behaviour.
Gays are born gay. Why anybody would choose to be gay in the United States of Christendom is beyond me. There is no parallel between homosexuality and polyamorous marriage. Stupid argument: debunked. Get a better one.
And d_Brit: prove that people are better off with a mommy and a daddy instead of a mommy and another mommy. No evidence outside of pamphlets available in mega-church gift stores. Nobody with scientific credibililty has authored or signed off on a study supporting this claim. All I have are anecdotes, but frankly I think people are better off in non-traditional households if only because they grow up more tolerant and open-minded. (Hey, maybe cons. oppose SSM because it’ll lead to more liberal voters! Perhaps thousands of them!) =)
Also, Romeo & Juliet were like twelve or thirteen year old kids, so you might not want to bring that up as a good example of how relationships ought to work.
It is thus incumbent upon you to satisfactorily address sincere objections to suggested changes. Especially when prior generations did not view restricting marriage to opposite genders as discrimination.
Who cares about “prior generations”? My grandfather is opposed to gay marriage because he hates gay people. This goes back to the anti-miscegenation analogy. If a majority of the people get something wrong, the Court can get it right. No reason not to let gay people have equal protection under the law, as is their right, apart from a historical distaste for gay relationships. The argument against SSM based on the suitability of the arrangement for propagating the species is moot, unless you want to tell septagenarians or infertile young adults that they can’t get married. It’s a social institution, not a biological one. Humanity might one day cease to exist, but it won’t be because everyone went and got themselves gay-married.
I am only using historical precedent and ‘tradition’ to challenge the idea that the increased knowledge of modern generations necessarily equates to increased wisdom.
This works well in, I dunno, agriculture; but as for moral questions, involving rights and such, history typically gets them flat-out wrong. Women and African Americans know this. Gays do too.
As for “social evolution”… think eugenics. Biology for improving society. SSM advocates want the law to evolve, and society will follow, maybe. But social Darwinists basically believe that weak humans, when revealed as such, can be rejected as chaff. It’s contrary to human rights. I brought it up, because you said that history has shown our concept of marriage to be superior, which is false. All that it shows is that historically, the people with a concept of marriage similar to ours defeated people with alternate models of the family, including native North and South Americans. Doesn’t mean their family models were inferior; it has more to do with their immune systems not being able to fight European diseases.
Do you really mean to suggest that we need scientists conducting ’empirical research’ to confirm that loving parents, in a committed relationship, providing a positive male and female role model for their children is the optimum arrangement?
Yes. Your gut feeling will not suffice. I would agree with you until you snuck “male and female role model” into the equation. I’m unaware of any reason to assume that two lesbians or two gay men would be unable to raise a perfectly normal human being.
BTW, exactly what are the statistical pregnancy levels of those women in combat units?
This is misogynistic. If indeed there is a ton of hot military orgies because Canadian women are allowed to fight, your assumption that they’ll just get pregnant and drop out of service is insulting. A responsible woman in that situation would be on birth control.
If a gay soldier harasses a straight soldier, that would be sexual harassment which is illegal. What’s the problem? Would it make you uncomfortable if a gay man checked you out at a bar? You wouldn’t be flattered? I think you’re revealing yourself to be homophobic.
Upon what do you base ‘human rights’? Without Divine providence, you only have the rights that the ‘mob’ grants you in any time and place. Hardly a ‘universal’ principle, much less an eternal ‘right’. But ‘human rights’ that we grant to each other through agreement that they MUST exist (because we say so) IS a necessary liberal rationalization.
Well, it’s harder for secular liberals to rationalize ‘human rights’ without just being able reference the Bible. Look, I can’t have an argument with someone who thinks that God is the source of human morality. I agree with lots of Christians about a lot of things, but I don’t believe in any supernatural phenomena in the universe and I don’t want to have a theological discussion with you. Humans have evolved morality, I believe. Sometime we get it wrong. But our moral psychologies usually work pretty good, and we can tell when someone else’s doesn’t. Suggested reading: Immanuel Kant, “Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals”; or for a more contemporary flavour, Bernard Williams, “Moral Luck”.
And Mike…
Seeing as how ALBANIA AIN’T AMERICA, yeah, there is nothing I’d do about it. I don’t want an empire of colonies.
So you only care about Iraq insofar as it posed a threat (which it didn’t). If this is your idea of winning an argument, then you’re not as smart as I thought. You glibly accept a reductio ad absurdum of your position. Good. That means you have been reduced to absurdity by virtue of the fact that you disapprove of humanitarian intervention if it’s not in America’s interests. Morally indefensible. Period. You cannot defend America’s involvement in the European Theatre of WW II if you believe what you have just typed at me.
Good to know where you really stand.
I don’t care if you think my friends and I are jerks. Life ain’t a popularity contest. Just morality and the law, right Mike?
d_Brit took me out back to try and sell me a Bible. I wasn’t buying. He’s a traditionalist. You’re a moral populist who is advocating American isolationism while failing to give one good reason why gay marriage should not be made the law of the land that wouldn’t also apply to why slavery shouldn’t be re-legalized if 50%+1 of America wanted it. Get up, dust yourself off, and go find an issue that conservatives do not lose on principle.
To VA Gamer:
Most arranged marriages were and are NOT insensitive to the necessity that the couple like each other and demonstrate compatibility and a willingness to enter into what is considered (in society’s who use(d) arranged marriages) a sacred covenant, God ordained.
d_Brit, the institution of marriage pre-dated the Christian Church. Romans established the institution as a property arrangement. ..
The institution of marriage predates the Romans; They did NOT invent nor establish the institution. We have extensive archeological evidence that the ancient Mesopotamians and the Egyptians had lawful marriage contracts and divorces well over 2000 yrs before the time of Christ.
“Mesopotamia was truly ancient; the history of the region dates back to the first discovered archeological findings in the region, 12,000 years ago, becoming increasingly complex when systems of writing develop and people merge into cities about 5,000 years ago.
The earliest known society was a community established around 7000BC at Jericho.
During the time of Ur-Nammu and Shulgi (2112-2047BC), the first kings of Third Dynasty of Ur; two themes discussed in the laws of these texts are responsibilities of the citizens and repercussions. One societal institution supported by law is marriage. The responsibility to hold on to a wife is enforced by assigning monetary punishment for divorce.”
We have actual Sumerian divorce documents dating from 2038-1990 B.C.
It is reasonable to presuppose that the institution itself greatly predates what incomplete written records we possess.
“Marriage in ancient Egypt” from about.com
“Egypts earliest dynasties commenced around 3,000 BC.
Polygamy was very rare because few men could afford to support two wives and two families. Monogamy was the norm for most ancient Egyptian marriages.
Although many marriages were arranged by families, we know from statues, poetry and paintings that ancient Egyptian spouses did love and respect one another.
There are many indications that husbands and wives in ancient Egypt were often happy and in love, with many touching portraits and statues of families including spouses and their children that reveal marital delight and warmth within the family.”
Unfortunately, the word “marriage” carries too much baggage. We must separate religious “marriage” (d_Brit’s “sacred covenant”) from the civil “marriage” (legal contract between two people).
Personally, I don’t find the ‘baggage’ of marriage all that burdensome. But then I’m not the one trying to redefine it…
… it is pure discrimination to keep gay people from civil marriage.
Yes, it is discrimination.
I simply hold that society has the right to define ‘marriage’ pretty much as it sees fit. That to a certain degree, discrimination is both unavoidable, necessary and in certain cases, beneficial.
That there are compelling reasons why society is ‘discriminating’ against SSM. I am asserting that the legal consequences of redefining marriage to include SSM necessarily and inevitably open the legal ‘doors’ to almost any other ‘marriage arrangement’ desired.
That only minors and animals can be defined as being unable to render consent, so that any other individuals or groups can claim and win their legal case to be legally entitled to ‘marriage’ once the rationale of discrimination is set as the defining legal characteristic determining who may be married.
Perhaps we need to get the government out of the “marriage” business altogether. Maybe everyone should be granted a “civil union” from the government. Would that sooth those of you who oppose same-sex CIVIL marriage? Posted by: VA Gamer
That is not a practical solution. The government cannot remove itself from the various aspects surrounding children, as well as the property, inheritance and financial aspects of marriage.
Proposing the title of a ‘civil union’ in replacement of the word marriage is a case of, ‘calling a rose by any other name’…
“which marriage as an institution cannot survive. “
The sky is falling! Quick, stop the gays!
No one ever explains *why* this will happen. Why will straight couples who want to marry in the traditional sense act any differently after gay marriage is legal? How does it affect current marriages in any way?
Specifically and exactly, lay out how marriage will “die.”
How many wives could the folks in Ur have, d_Brit? Monogamy was the norm because women were expensive to feed and clothe, but presumably you would be the coolest guy in town if you had like a hundred wives and a bunch of concubines too.
I simply hold that society has the right to define ‘marriage’ pretty much as it sees fit. That to a certain degree, discrimination is both unavoidable, necessary and in certain cases, beneficial.
Well I simply hold that society has the right to define ‘person’ pretty much as it sees fit. That to a certain degree, discrimination is both unavoidable, necessary and in certain cases, beneficial.
After all, I, a Republican, would benefit from black people being classified as one-half of a person, as it will prevent the Democrats from getting elected. I would benefit from women being classified as ‘near-persons’, so that they deserve our respect but we cannot be held responsible when Jim Beam causes us to raise our hands in anger.
Sounds stupid, I know. It’s stupid because subjugating questions of individual and minority rights to broader questions of social benefit and majority taste is crazy at face value.
As for your repeated insistence that gay marriage will open the floodgates to overall social decline, you need to give some evidence; and as for it ruining the institution of marriage, you need to find better arguments that the slippery slope to Sodom that you think we’re constructing. Gay people have the same reason to oppose polygamy (it’s inherently disrespectful of the dignity of the partners involved, typically women) and incest (it’s typically predatory and extremely psychologically damaging) that straight people do.
You need better arguments here. I encourage you to vote for representatives who will champion the illegality of homosexual marriage, if that is what is most important to you, but as with many of the greatest advancements in civil liberties, this will go through the courts. You’re in your mid-to-late fifties, so I understand your perturbation; my dad feels the same way, but my mom (raised strict Roman Catholic) has a very gay brother, and he and his friends opened her eyes to the fact that gays aren’t harmful, and that they ought to be afforded every right and dignity that straight members of society are.
A hundred years from now, this debate (not the one right here, but the overall national dialogue) will seem quaint.
*than the slippery slope
Jeebus, words is hard. I’m going to the beach.
d_Brit at July 8, 2006 04:21 PM
Quibble: Rome did not establish marriage, but the Republic of Rome (pre-Empire) did establish the “marriage” license, and it was for reason of property not propriety. SEe my previous post.
Totally Matt:
d_Brit: prove that people are better off with a mommy and a daddy instead of a mommy and another mommy…
You presuppose that for children, 50% of the human race is unnecessary. You presuppose that a father figure is not of unique value to a child. You are either being disingenuous or you are so wedded to a ‘mental construct’ as to have divorced yourself from reality, nature and common sense.
I think people are better off in non-traditional households if only because they grow up more tolerant and open-minded. (Hey, maybe cons. oppose SSM because it’ll lead to more liberal voters! Perhaps thousands of them!) =)
Tolerance and open-mindedness are not synonymous with acceptance of any proposed mental construct invented out of whole cloth. “You have to believe in something, or you’ll fall for anything”
Also, Romeo & Juliet were like twelve or thirteen year old kids, so you might not want to bring that up as a good example of how relationships ought to work.
Are you being purposely obtuse? VA Gamer was asserting that prior to a few centuries ago marriage was about property exchanges and had relatively recently evolved into contracts based upon romantic love. I said, “Their fictional nature (or age) is irrelevant because Shakespeare was writing a story that his audience could relate to, as every playwright must. Writing more than 500 years ago his audiences were quite familiar with romantic love.” I was establishing that romantic love was well known as a basis for marriage to Shakespeare’s audience thus demonstrating that marriage did NOT recently ‘evolve’.
Additionally, we have written records that as far back as 642 BC the Egyptians were changing their view of arranged marriages to include input from the prospective bride…
It is thus incumbent upon you to satisfactorily address sincere objections to suggested changes. Especially when prior generations did not view restricting marriage to opposite genders as discrimination.
Who cares about “prior generations”? My grandfather is opposed to gay marriage because he hates gay people. … If a majority of the people get something wrong, the Court can get it right. No reason not to let gay people have equal protection under the law, as is their right, apart from a historical distaste for gay relationships. The argument against SSM based on the suitability of the arrangement for propagating the species is moot, unless you want to tell septagenarians or infertile young adults that they can’t get married. It’s a social institution, not a biological one.
“Those who refuse to learn from the lessons of the past are doomed to repeat them” THAT is why you should care about prior generations. Your grandfather’s views are not a valid basis for sweeping aside the wisdom of millennia. Again, “It is thus incumbent upon you to satisfactorily address sincere objections to suggested changes.” you have yet to do so.
Instead you continue to insist that any objection to SSM is solely based in a “historical distaste for gay relationships” that is being intellectually dishonest.
It is a social arrangement instituted to control a biological process for the children sake and to render societal stability. Pragmatically, you cannot successfully separate the two.
I am only using historical precedent and ‘tradition’ to challenge the idea that the increased knowledge of modern generations necessarily equates to increased wisdom.
This works well in, I dunno, agriculture; but as for moral questions, involving rights and such, history typically gets them flat-out wrong. Women and African Americans know this. Gays do too.
That’s a very convenient reading of history. The code of Hammurabi. Greek Democracy. The Ten Commandments. The Roman republic based upon the rule of laws. The Noble truths of Buddha. Christ’s Sermon on the Mount. The Magna Carta. The philosophical writings of Locke, Hume and John Stuart Mill. The Declaration of Independence. The Constitution of the US. The Principles of the Bahai Faith. The establishment of the UN.
NONE of these were accomplished through SCOTUS forcing the American people “to get it right”.
As for “social evolution”… think eugenics. Biology for improving society. SSM advocates want the law to evolve, and society will follow, maybe. But social Darwinists basically believe that weak humans, when revealed as such, can be rejected as chaff. It’s contrary to human rights. I brought it up, because you said that history has shown our concept of marriage to be superior, which is false. All that it shows is that historically, the people with a concept of marriage similar to ours defeated people with alternate models of the family, including native North and South Americans. Doesn’t mean their family models were inferior; it has more to do with their immune systems not being able to fight European diseases.
Eugenics…which Webster’s defines as: “improving the human species by controlling heredity” You said, “Liberals are biological evolutionists, not social evolutionists” exactly how will you evolve society thru controlling heredity?
You left out ‘Guns and Steel’ but exactly what non-monogamous ‘family models’ did Native North and South Americans practice? What alternative to the opposite gender, monogamous pair-bond did they offer?
Do you really mean to suggest that we need scientists conducting ’empirical research’ to confirm that loving parents, in a committed relationship, providing a positive male and female role model for their children is the optimum arrangement?
Yes. Your gut feeling will not suffice. I would agree with you until you snuck “male and female role model” into the equation. I’m unaware of any reason to assume that two lesbians or two gay men would be unable to raise a perfectly normal human being.
Your gut feeling that it is not a concern does NOT equate to proof of the opposite. I have overwhelming historical evidence in support of my assertion. You have only put forward the argument that ‘it’s not right’ and same-sex couples love for their children is ALL that is needed for successful parenting.
Two lesbians or two gay men raising a child presuppose that the opposite genders contributions to child raising are either unnecessary or easily substituted for, while millions of people have personal testimony as to the opposite genders importance in their own childhood.
Gays and lesbians presuppose that children do not need both a male and female role model. THAT idea can only be entertained by someone more interested in a personal agenda than in children’s welfare.
BTW, exactly what are the statistical pregnancy levels of those women in combat units?
This is misogynistic. If indeed there is a ton of hot military orgies because Canadian women are allowed to fight, your assumption that they’ll just get pregnant and drop out of service is insulting. A responsible woman in that situation would be on birth control.
Birth control is not 100% effective as you well know. I was NOT implying that even the majority of women in a combat unit will become pregnant and ‘drop out’. I WAS asserting that unplanned pregnancies must of neccessity, disrupt unit cohesion.
An accusation of ‘hating women’ to derail an honest request for you to provide evidence for your assertions is a despicable ploy. It indicates a level of intellectual dishonesty that is pathetic.
If a gay soldier harasses a straight soldier, that would be sexual harassment which is illegal. What’s the problem? Would it make you uncomfortable if a gay man checked you out at a bar? You wouldn’t be flattered? I think you’re revealing yourself to be homophobic.
Now you compound your insults by stooping to accusations of homophobia.Well if you can’t win the debate on points you can always libel your opponent, right?
It is not an issue of being ‘checked out’ in a bar. It is an issue of creating discomfort in the ranks when of necessity hetero men and women would be bathing publicly with gays, in the nude and the men (or women) knowing that homosexuals are in the ranks and phsyically desiring them.
Men especially are visually oriented and gay men will look with desire upon other men, especially when in the nude. Whether the ‘object of interest’ is gay or hetero will not matter in the least to the homosexual, as it is their inherent nature to find others of the same sex attractive.
Incidentally, I have been checked out by gay men. It bothered me not in the least. So much for homophobia.
Upon what do you base ‘human rights’? Without Divine providence, you only have the rights that the ‘mob’ grants you in any time and place. Hardly a ‘universal’ principle, much less an eternal ‘right’. But ‘human rights’ that we grant to each other through agreement that they MUST exist (because we say so) IS a necessary liberal rationalization.
Look, I can’t have an argument with someone who thinks that God is the source of human morality. Humans have evolved morality, I believe. But our moral psychologies usually work pretty good, and we can tell when someone else’s doesn’t.
It isn’t theological belief that leads me to recognize that without Divine truth there is no basis for placing your idea of ‘human rights’ above Saddam Hussein’s concepts of your ‘rights’.
Yes, it’s clear that you can’t dispute that ‘human rights’ is a human invention. The physical universe cares not a whit for your demand for ‘human rights’ and your rights depend upon the ‘mobs’ agreement as to what your rights consist.
d_Brit took me out back to try and sell me a Bible. I wasn’t buying. He’s a traditionalist.
I see that you belong to the intellectual school subscribing to the “I know you are, but what am I?”
Stubbornly insisting upon mischaracterizing my position as religious or traditional does NOT make that assertion true.
But then agenda-based argument doesn’t concern itself with fairness, accuracy in restating ones opponents’ position, or any other of the ‘traditional’ rules in debate, does it?
“which marriage as an institution cannot survive. ” The sky is falling! Quick, stop the gays! No one ever explains *why* this will happen. Why will straight couples who want to marry in the traditional sense act any differently after gay marriage is legal? How does it affect current marriages in any way? Specifically and exactly, lay out how marriage will “die.”
Posted by: JimK
Many of us are attempting to do just that. It would help if you read the thread. When you’ve done that you should have more appropriately secific questions to ask.
d_Brit
Quibble: Rome did not establish marriage, but the Republic of Rome (pre-Empire) did establish the “marriage” license, and it was for reason of property not propriety. SEe my previous post.
Posted by: John Anderson
In what way is a marriage ‘license’ essentially different from a marriage ‘contract’? As detailed above, we have ME divorce decree documents listing monetary damages from 2018BC…
Of what use to a society would formal divorce documents without marriage contract/licenses?
It is you who is quibbling.
Totally Matt,
I’d like to respond to a comment you made that was not addressed directly to me but does pertain directly to my central assertion that the ‘legalization’ of SSM will necessarily and thus inevitably lead to the legalization of multiple partner marriages.
Polygamists can’t claim that there relationship follows from their psychology, because it doesn’t. It’s socialized behavior.Totally Matt
A plausible but flawed claim. Consider the following:
A 2003 study of young Dutch homosexual men by Dr. Maria Xiridou of the Amsterdam Municipal Health Service, published in May in the journal AIDS, mirrors findings of past research.
The Dutch study focused on transmission of HIV and, found that men in homosexual relationships on average have eight partners a year outside those relationships.
Earlier studies also indicated that homosexual men are not monogamous, even when they are involved in long-term relationships. (Many of those men will be raising children, can anyone seriously doubt that they will communicate those ‘values’ to their children. The vast majority of which will be heterosexual?)
In “The Male Couple,” published in 1984, authors David P. McWhirter and Andrew M. Mattison report that in a study of 156 males in homosexual relationships lasting anywhere from one to 37 years, all couples with relationships more than five years had incorporated some provision for outside sexual activity.
“Fidelity is not defined in terms of sexual behavior but rather by their emotional commitment to each other,” the authors said. “Ninety-five percent of the couples have an arrangement whereby the partners may have sexual activity with others.”
The state of Vermont has allowed civil unions between same-sex couples since 2000, and a study by two University of Vermont psychology professors compared homosexual couples in civil unions with homosexual couples not in unions, and married heterosexual couples.
Among the Vermont findings, the overwhelming majority of women — both lesbians and married heterosexuals — felt it was not acceptable to have sex outside of their primary relationship. However, 79 percent of married men felt sex outside marriage was not OK, compared to 34 percent of homosexual men in committed relationships and 50 percent of homosexual men in civil unions.
But such open relationships — in which homosexual men accept that their partners will have sex with others — are not harmful, said Anne Peplau, a psychology professor at the University of California at Los Angeles. “There is clear evidence that gay men are less likely to have sexually exclusive relationships than other people — but this is not typically harmful to their relationships because partners agree that it’s acceptable,” said Miss Peplau.
So according to your assertions TM, Gay men’s behavior springs from their inherent ‘psychology’. A psychology that sees outside partners as acceptable. Not much of a stretch to multiple partner marriages after all, is it?
But let’s not limit evidence to mere surveys. Let’s look at what society’s that have already formalized SSM are experiencing.
In March of 2004, it was reported that the local youth wing of Sweden’s governing Social Democrat party had endorsed the idea of replacing marriage with a gender-neutral, multi-partner-friendly marriage system.
Around the same time, the youth wing of Sweden’s Green party called for formal recognition of polyamorous (i.e. multi-partner) relationships.
When called upon, Justice Minister Piet Hein Donner reaffirmed the legality of multiple partner cohabitation contracts. Donner also went so far as to assert that contracts regulating multiple partner cohabitation can fulfill “a useful regulating function” (also translatable as “a useful structuring role”). In other words, the Netherlands Justice Minister has articulated the rudiments of a “case for group marriage.”
Green party spokesman Femke Halsema, a key backer of gay marriage, has affirmed her party’s support for the recognition of multiple partner unions.
In a real world case, a Serge Régnier had been married to his wife Christine for four years when Christine’s unmarried sister Karine moved in with the couple. Karine wanted children, and after discussing the matter with her sister and brother-in-law, it was agreed that Serge would father children with Karine and live with the women as a threesome.
Into this ménage à trois came Judith, a childhood sweetheart of Serge. Serge had told Christine when he married her that, if she were ever available, Judith would have to be welcomed into their house.
When Judith divorced her first husband and showed up on the Régniers’ doorstep, all agreed to admit her. The result is one husband, three wives, and 30 children, with several more children hoped for by the wives.
Serge is unemployed, and the entire family is supported by government subsidies. The women say there is no jealousy among them and they would even welcome a fourth wife if she was “nice.”
When it comes to marriage, culture shapes law.
Polygamists can’t claim that there relationship follows from their psychology, because it doesn’t. It’s socialized behaviour.
There is as much evidence that polygamy is genetic as there is that homosexuality is genetic.
Namely, there is absolutely none.
So, until you can prove otherwise, homosexuality is socialized behavior.
Gays are born gay. Why anybody would choose to be gay in the United States of Christendom is beyond me. There is no parallel between homosexuality and polyamorous marriage. Stupid argument: debunked. Get a better one.
Why would somebody choose to be a criminal?
Why would they choose to be a pedophile?
Choose to be a polygamist?
Try proving a point rather than mistaking empty platitudes for evidence.
And d_Brit: prove that people are better off with a mommy and a daddy instead of a mommy and another mommy. No evidence outside of pamphlets available in mega-church gift stores. Nobody with scientific credibililty has authored or signed off on a study supporting this claim. All I have are anecdotes, but frankly I think people are better off in non-traditional households if only because they grow up more tolerant and open-minded. (Hey, maybe cons. oppose SSM because it’ll lead to more liberal voters! Perhaps thousands of them!) =)
So, you’ve never read…well, ANY sociological studies in your life. Got it.
Arguments borne solely out of ignorance are truly sad, because the believers are dangerous because reality and facts are nebulous things for them if they come in conflict with your beliefs.
Congrats. You’ve just become more closed-minded than the Christians you so bemoan.
The argument against SSM based on the suitability of the arrangement for propagating the species is moot, unless you want to tell septagenarians or infertile young adults that they can’t get married.
Seeing as how you’re the one openly ignorant of history and sociology, you might want to stop digging this hole you’ve placed yourself in.
This works well in, I dunno, agriculture; but as for moral questions, involving rights and such, history typically gets them flat-out wrong. Women and African Americans know this. Gays do too.
Women and blacks got the vote via the electoral process.
Slavery was ended due to the vote and through bloodshed.
Take away idiotic SCOTUS decisions like Plessy v Ferguson and Jim Crow wouldn’t have become ingrained in the first place.
As for “social evolution”… think eugenics. Biology for improving society. SSM advocates want the law to evolve, and society will follow, maybe.
And RATIONAL people would like to see law “evolve” through, you know, CHANGING THE LAW.
If the law can “evolve” into something completely different with no input from the people or their representatives, you don’t have law.
No reason not to let gay people have equal protection under the law, as is their right, apart from a historical distaste for gay relationships.
They have equal protection. But feel free to continue missing reality to protect your absurd worldview.
You are just like the Christians you condemn — except Christians believe based on God’s teachings and you believe because, deep down, you believe yourself to be God.
I brought it up, because you said that history has shown our concept of marriage to be superior, which is false.
No, he argued that the concept of marriage has been consistent and you attempted to argue that changing the reason WHY men and women marry changing is dramatically different than eliminating the whole “man and woman” thing.
Yes. Your gut feeling will not suffice.
But you expect YOUR gut feeling to suffice, which is hypocritical and idiotic of you.
I’m unaware of any reason to assume that two lesbians or two gay men would be unable to raise a perfectly normal human being.
Your ignorance is well-known. You don’t need to re-testify to it.
This is misogynistic.
Yes, because concerns about sex amongst troops when you advocate keeping straight and gay men together is SO ridiculous to a discussion of UNIT COHESION. Presenting rather clear evidence of the problem is so out of the bounds in a discussion of this.
Of course, if you had ANY evidence (mind you, in all of this time, you’ve yet to actually PRESENT any evidence to back up any of your claims), you’d have mentioned it.
If indeed there is a ton of hot military orgies because Canadian women are allowed to fight, your assumption that they’ll just get pregnant and drop out of service is insulting. A responsible woman in that situation would be on birth control.
Yes, ignore the point. Continue on with that.
If a gay soldier harasses a straight soldier, that would be sexual harassment which is illegal.
And, gee, IN A COMBAT SITUATION, that is such a good idea to make a potential problem.
Really, good plan.
Would it make you uncomfortable if a gay man checked you out at a bar? You wouldn’t be flattered? I think you’re revealing yourself to be homophobic.
So, women who don’t like it when men hit on them are heterophobic? Got it. Men just WANT to be hit on. It’s ALL any man wants. Constantly.
Well, it’s harder for secular liberals to rationalize ‘human rights’ without just being able reference the Bible. Look, I can’t have an argument with someone who thinks that God is the source of human morality.
Because they’re the “closed-minded ones”, right?
So you only care about Iraq insofar as it posed a threat (which it didn’t).
Yup.
You glibly accept a reductio ad absurdum of your position.
Well, we can now add Latin and basic logic to the list of areas you’re clueless about.
That means you have been reduced to absurdity by virtue of the fact that you disapprove of humanitarian intervention if it’s not in America’s interests.
Seeing as how we lack the means to cure ALL cruel treatment on Earth, we have to prioritize. Again, it’s the height of hypocrisy to bitch about Iraq and then bemoan my lack of desire to cure all problems for all people in the world.
Morally indefensible. Period. You cannot defend America’s involvement in the European Theatre of WW II if you believe what you have just typed at me.
Germany was clearly a threat and — this, admittedly, is a technicality — DECLARED WAR ON US IN DECEMBER, 1941. http://www.yale.edu/lawweb/avalon/wwii/gerdec41.htm
However, I cannot justify US intervention in Haiti.
Or Yugoslavia.
Hmm, so we now have history, Latin, basic logic, and sociology on the list of what you don’t quite comprehend. List is getting lengthy now.
I don’t care if you think my friends and I are jerks. Life ain’t a popularity contest. Just morality and the law, right Mike?
You lack morality and ANY understanding of law.
You really are a tiresome troll. You are horrendously dull to deal with and mind-boggling in your utter lack of education.
-=Mike
“Many of us are attempting to do just that. It would help if you read the thread. When you’ve done that you should have more appropriately secific questions to ask.”
I have read every single word of this thread and the question is still not answered. How will a couple comprised of a man and a woman who want to be legally joined and joined in a house-of-worship-of-your-choice service affected by two strangers they don’t know getting married, regardless of gender?
How will my marriage be destroyed by two gay men getting married?
Can you answer those questions without resorting to insults, namecalling or F.U.D. about animals and polygamy?
It won’t impact your marriage.
It will impact the institution of marriage in the future.
-=Mike
“I have read every single word of this thread and the question is still not answered. How will a couple comprised of a man and a woman who want to be legally joined and joined in a house-of-worship-of-your-choice service affected by two strangers they don’t know getting married, regardless of gender? How will my marriage be destroyed by two gay men getting married? Can you answer those questions without resorting to insults, namecalling or F.U.D. about animals and polygamy? Posted by: JimK
Your questions define the issue as strictly one of short-term dimensions. That is a profound error.
Your marriage will most likely not be affected at all. I never claimed otherwise and I don’t recall anyone else claiming that either.
As MikeSC succienctly put it,” It will impact the institution of marriage in the future.”
Sorry to be a bit dense but what is F.U.D.?
As my primary objection to SSM revolves around the issue of the legal inevitability of multiple partner marriage, etc. with that being a completely predictable consequence of SSM, to exclude that leaves me with nothing to discuss with you on this subject.
If you wish me to elaborate on the rationale that leads me to that conclusion, I can and will do so.
I can assure you that my rationale is completely independent of religious and ‘traditional” arguments against SSM.
As I said previously in the thread, I only brought up the traditional argument because of its appropriateness in countering others assertions that ‘modern’ thinking is inately superior to ALL previous generations views.
F.U.D. is “Fear, Uncertainty and Doubt.” It has become shorthand meaning arguments that have no actual basis in anything but…well, fear, uncertainty and doubt. No independantly verifiable evidence, no valid logic, just a lot of beating the drum and trying to raise the emotional stakes of an argument.
You avoided my first question. How will a couple comprised of a man and a woman who want to be legally joined and joined in a house-of-worship-of-your-choice service affected by two strangers they don’t know getting married, regardless of gender?
d_Brit at July 8, 2006 08:07 PM
The marriage contract was far more complicated – and is still in use (even here if you consider pre-nuptial agreements), and still a lot more complicated and costly.
The State’s license basically is quite simple: more than one person agrees to be legally connected in all matters not otherwise covered by law – sort of an unlimited partnership.
Yes, divorces (and of course deaths) occurred before the license. But the Republic’s innovation was that in cases of death where there was no registered will (another fee, by the way, as well as having to acknowledge one’s [future] death) the estate would be distributed according to a formula developed by the State – and taking the State to court was rarely worth the costs. A cheap way of making a will without all the work and expense. Before that, either the State seized everything (no, not usually in Rome) or if a second cousin wanted to take the deceased’s “second-best bed” away from the spouse (or whoever had ripped it out of the house first) the cost of going to court to try to get it was much less costly – and the courts were clogged with such suits and counter-suits.
Note that a legally established will was primary with or without the license – the concern was not having a will. Property, not propriety.
The basic concern has been expanded over many centuries into (for example) hospital rights of visitation. Many hospitals don’t consider (for other legal reasons) an “unlicensed” spouse to be “family” for urposes of visiting a patient in an Intensive Care Unit, and don’t care if the Pope presided at the marriage ceremony.
Again, we are arguing two different things, actual religious marriage and that which the State calls marriage as a form of shorthand since for centuries it had (largely, discounting anomaiies like the Latter Day Saint’s polygamy) been thought of as the same thing by anyone with a voice that could be heard outside friends and family.
– – –
Or perhaps if I state my position itself…
Should same-sex marriage be allowed? Not unless the religion involved allows it. And the State, if it allows its license to be used for same-sex, should not be allowed to force churches to perform their religious ceremonies. Not any change from current usage – two Baptists cannot be married in the Jewish religion (or as more commonly said, Roman Catholic) and vice-versa.
Should the State issue something inclusive, like “in any law or regulation passed prior to this time, the word ‘marriage’ will be replaced by the phrase “civil union'”? In reading some of my own State’s law concerning the license, I cannot find it making any other change necessary, but perhaps a referendum ballot would be preferable to just having the legislature do it: OTOH, perhaps referendum on redefining the word, in law, as “one man, one woman.”?
Does it affect me, personally? Being neither gay nor married nor very religious, not much. I just do not feel comfortable agreeing to the restriction, by law, of women, Blacks, Chinese – or homosexuals. OTOH, I do not want to change the law to say I must allow removing any and all restrictions: I do not mind using the same restroom as a woman, but I’m uncomfortable with using it at the same time… But that is a trained response, I cannot think off-hand of any real reason. Especially if the women’s-room couch and table come with the deal.
– – –
Well, that was incoherent, wasn’t it? OK, I just thing religious marriage and the State marriage license are not actuall about the same thing – else why would the State marriage not need a religious component? One word, two meanings – not at all unusual, browse any dictionary.
“It will impact the institution of marriage in the future.”
How will it prevent a man and a woman from having a traditional marriage in the future? Be specific and exact. You can’t just *say* it will and think you’ve said anything.
This is essentially the conversation we’re having:
I’d like to know specifically how – if the gays are allowed to *gasp* get married legally – a straight, presumably religious couple, would no longer be able to get both legally and ceremoniously married in both the eyes of the state and the eyes of God and live their lives as a traditionally married man and woman, with whatever traditions, precepts and ceremonies thier beliefs prescribe.
“I’d like to know specifically how – if the gays are allowed to *gasp* get married legally – a straight, presumably religious couple, would no longer be able to get both legally and ceremoniously married in both the eyes of the state and the eyes of God and live their lives as a traditionally married man and woman, with whatever traditions, precepts and ceremonies thier beliefs prescribe.” Posted by: JimK
I was not trying to avoid your question. I thought I had implicitly addressed your question when I acknowledged your question regarding the impact of SSM upon your present marriage.
But to answer succinctly and specifically; Gay marriage will NOT directly prevent a couple from personally living their lives according to their beliefs.
Please note that I never claimed otherwise.
Societal considerations however are another matter and we ALL live our lives within a greater whole which DOES affect all of us and indirectly impacts the raising of children. Children and the Family ARE the foundational structural basis for Society.
Your question is focused on the personal impacts of SSM, my focus is upon the future societal impacts of SSM, when imposed legally upon a society.
My contention is that the courts ruling that same-sex marriage is legally and constitutionally valid based upon equal protection AND defining the legal case as solely one of discrimination necessarily and inevitably results in legal consequences.
The only remaining logically objective basis for legal exclusion of any desired ‘marriage’ arrangement will be consent. So, minors and animals have an objective basis for continued exclusion from ‘marriage’.
The discrimination argument places every other previous criterion for determining marriage into the realm of the subjective and arbitrary.
Subjective and arbitrary are thin ice indeed when constitutional considerations are being weighed.
Those legal consequences arise from the removal of ALL objectively rational objections to multiple partner marriages.
As example, Society and the Courts would be left with no objective basis to exclude 3 men desiring to marry. Nor practically speaking, any other multiple partner arrangement desired.
Acceptance of the ‘discrimination’ argument removes the ‘number’ requirement from consideration because SSM eliminates biological gender and reproduction as THE objective criteria for society’s determination as to who may and may not be ‘married’.
SSM reached through court decrees based in the equal protection clause also legally opens the door to marriage between family members who have reached the age of majority.
While the scientifically verified inappropriateness of children born through incestuous relations is a valid objection to incestuous ‘marriage’; contraception, vasectomies, sterilization, etc., and the legality of abortion make that a somewhat problematic legal objection.
If the objection of children is removed, then the claim of discrimination as the basis for society’s exclusion of ‘familial’ marriage MUST of legal necessity stand. There is NO avoiding that consequence.
It will be a matter of when it is acknowledged, not if.
This is not an example of F.U.D. (BTW, thank you for the explanation 🙂 because my contention is grounded in legally undeniable assertions.
The courts defining SSM marriage as strictly a matter of ‘discrimination’ and thus constitutionally invalid due to the equal protection clause legally ensures the compulsory acceptance by courts of the equal protection argument for almost any other desired ‘marriage’ arrangement individuals and groups may desire in the future.
While I doubt the wisdom of doing so, I have NO legal objections to societies voting to allow SSM and, then observe the results of that arrangement.
However, pragmatic objections to a state legalizing SSM through the vote, then after a period of time deciding it isn’t a good idea after all and then voting to ‘disallow’ SSM marriage, are valid.
Personally, my only objection to Gays and Lesbians marrying centers around children.
Yes, adoption of children by a loving same-sex couple is superior to the child languishing in a institutional ‘home’.
However, I also believe that it is absurd to posit that children do not need a positive male and female role model.
One by definition that only heterosexual couples can provide.
To me, it is the height of hubris when homosexual couples (or single heterosexuals) intentionally ‘create’ a child through modern technology, implicitly asserting that neither a Father nor a Mother is needed for the optimum psychological development of a child.
If you love a child, you want the best for that child. Denying the child you have personally created any chance to permanently bond with either a positive parental male or female role model is an act of profound selfishness and is an inherent and specific indication of unfitness as a parent.
“Well, that was incoherent, wasn’t it? OK, I just thing religious marriage and the State marriage license are not actuall about the same thing – else why would the State marriage not need a religious component? One word, two meanings – not at all unusual, browse any dictionary.
Posted by: John Anderson “
It was a bit hard to follow. Nevertheless I agree that the religious and secular forms of marriage are subtlely different from each other.
When I pointed out that marriage has existed long before the Romans I was not implying that the Romans did not contribute significantly to our modern understanding of the institution.
That said, my main points stand. The concept of marriage has overwhelmingly been practiced and considered the monogomous union of opposite gender couples, for all of recorded history and in all probability long before that as well.
I also maintain that romantic attraction and love must always have been the primary impetus to coupling, it is our very nature and the driving impetus to reproduction. Not sex per se but the emotional ‘connection’ we all desire. Sex is simply the most intense physical expression of that need.
‘Marriage’ is simply the societal institution created to ‘channel’ that natural impulse in a manner that most benefits society, with its children being the future of every society.
Saying things in a long-winded manner doesn’t make them any more true. You;ve not demonstrated any practical, actual ways in which two gay men marrying legally will affect straight couples wishing to observe traditional marriage. You claim you’re noy using F.U.D. but that is precisely what your argument is. It boils down to “OMG if you let the gays marry then anyone can do anything!” Not to mention the religious aspects you could not help but to let creep in.
It’s ridiculous.
This is a fight you will lose someday soon. I, for one, hope it’s not just within my lifetime, but within ten years. I don’t want any part of treating devoted, dedicated gay couples like they were second-class subhumans.
Going to try to catch up from the w/e…
Les Nesman blabbered
rwilymz is just a filthy goddamned Numberist, no better than a racist or a homophobe or a sexist.
Okay, I’ll accept that.
Who the hell does he think he is, telling us that 3 people can’t marry? What gives him the right?
I haven’t done anything to stop multiple marriage; the legislatures have. But when the legislatures prohibited polyandry and polygamy [polyamory, in the lingo] the courts and the cops applied it equally. That is to say, NObody can marry multiple concurrently. Not simply certain people.
Nobody has the right to tell me that 2 is legal but 4 or 5 or whatever is not.
This is a democracy; of course we do. We also have the authority to tell you to wear a seat belt.
Lee shows soff his blinders:
The organized opposition against gay marriages is principally from the religous right.
Look at the black churches, squirt.
…or are black churches another bastion of Religious Right fervor?
MikeSC goes for broke and ends up broke
There is no equal protection argument to make here
Look, Mikey, just because you don’t have the capacity to understand the subject does not mean others can’t. Equal Protection becomes an issue when some people can use a law, or are protected by a law, and others are not. The State has to have an “interest” in order to differentiate. What is the “interest” in preventing black males from marrying white females in the 60s? The “interest” was: “the majority thinks it’s ooky”. Well, that doesn’t matter; “ooky” isn’t a legitimate state interest.
What is the interest in preventing gays from ditto? Essentially, same thing: “ooky”. It turns people’s stomachs.
Well, fine; buy some Pepto. There are still several states which do NOT have “one man one woman” requirements on their marriage laws; gays cannot — under the law — be prevented from marrying in those states. Yet they are. There are several other states where the “one of each” requirement was invented in the last decade, just after this issue came up. There is a very good argument that the requirements were changed just to prevent gays from getting married — which you can’t do. There’s bunches of case law on that.
If equal protection covers two men marrying each other, it also covers a dad and his daughter marrying.
Only if some fathers are allowed to marry their daughters and other fathers are not. Equal Protection means that everyone is presumed to have the ability to use [or the protection of] the same law. We do not have a law that allows fathers to marry daughters, so Equal Protection isn’t relevant.
Darleen can abort an unwanted child.//If you have an unwanted child, you have to support it.//Thus, a legal difference.
And that is wrong as well.
But it’s a different subject.
Notice how you aren’t allowed to advertise “Blacks need not apply”?
Notice how Equal Protection comes up again? “Gays need not apply”.
Marriage between a man and a woman is very much enforced equally.
Here’s what you’re missing, skippy, and the answer ain’t changing just cuz you need to change out of your wet panties: several states do not have “one man one woman” requirements in their marriage laws.
Les Nesman continues to babble:
1.Two men marrying is equal but 3 is not? How?
Because we already have laws allowing two [adult] people to marry. It is not being enforced equally, because certain [adult] people cannot apply. “Gays need not apply”. We do not have laws allowing three people to concurrently marry, so discussion about its equal enforcement is moot.
2.Two men and two women all getting married together is subjugatory? How?
Because the law has defined multiple marriages as a form of fraud. It is [apparently] being enforced equally.
3. Who the hell are you to tell anyone that 3 people can not get married?
Someone who understands and isn’t confused by reality? We live in a democratic republic, and we can have whatever laws we want to have — as long as we apply them equally.
…and as long as those laws are not inherently violative of other Constitutional parameters, but that is a different subject as well.
and Justrand rationalizes:
I have absolutely no problem with easy access for gays to the basic protections afforded married couples
So you want the “special treatment” laws…? The conservatives were correct about one aspect of this whole issue, and this was it. Gays couldn’t get married, so they wheedled “special treatment” — getting the benefits of marriage without marriage, and which were not granted to heterosexuals who were ‘shacking up’ — and this, as if it needs to be said, ALSO violates Equal Protection. Giving some unmarried people certain benefits just because they live together without giving those same benefits to all who live together isn’t equal treatment under the law.
Scrapiron adds the follow gem
The terrorists and the … queers are not concerned with anyone but themselves
Well halle-friggin-lulya! This is true.
But then, so is everybody else concerned only about themselves. Those who are against gay marriage largely do so because it violates their sensibilities in some form or fashion. Some because, well, using the courts like the blacks did 40 years ago is poor form, we need to pass laws instead. Others because it turns their stomachs and they’re, doggone it, all out of Rolaids. EVERYone is concerned about his own sensibilities at all times, and rarely about anything else.
And that’s a nice break point.
Some people have some growing up to do. I’ll leave them to do it now.
dumbass rwilymz slobbered:
“Les :Nobody has the right to tell me that 2 is legal but 4 or 5 or whatever is not.
rwilymz: This is a democracy; of course we do. We also have the authority to tell you to wear a seat belt.”
O.k., dumbass, then let’s take a vote on it. How will that vote work out? Not too good for your side. Every state that has put it up for a vote has had ssm go down to defeat by huge margins.
Nice of you to defeat your own arguments. Heh.
rwilymz continues to show his ignorance:
“Les : 1.Two men marrying is equal but 3 is not? How?
rwilymz: Because we already have laws allowing two [adult] people to marry. It is not being enforced equally, because certain [adult] people cannot apply. “Gays need not apply”.”
No, dumbass. Gays can apply. ANY man is free to marry a woman. ANY woman is free to marry a man.
They just can’t marry the same sex.
The way we do it now defines a Marriage as between one man and one woman.
The way YOU want to do it changes the definition of marriage. The polygamists will say, ‘hey, if gays can just change the definition of marriage to fit their agenda and the court is o.k. with it, then so can we’. And there will be no Constitutional or logical reason to refute them.