That’s what Assemblywoman Barbara Lifton (D-125th District) is proposing in the wake of the New York high court’s decision that the state constitution does not recognize same sex marriage.
“Let’s get government out of the wedding business and have everyone, equally, have a civil arrangement,” she said.
The proposal Lifton supports would replace the word “marriage” with “civil commitment” in state laws, creating a legal contract she said would be accessible to everyone, while leaving the religious aspect of the union to religious institutions.
“Why should state government become a religious institution?” she asked.
Ms. Lifton makes her idea sound so simple: it’s just replacing one word with another, that’s all. But it’s much more than that. It fundamentally turns the institution of marriage, the union of a man and a woman before God and man, into nothing but an impersonal and emotionless legal contract akin to a business transaction. In other words, if gays can’t marry, then no one can.
Stanley Kurtz at The Corner responds to Ms. Lifton’s proposal:
And as we’ve seen with [Michael] Kinsley and [Jonathan] Turley, if we’re no longer talking about “marriage,” multi-partner “civil commitments” will surely follow. In any case, it wouldn’t take multi-partner unions to make the abolition of civil marriage a disaster. Just removing public support for marriage as an institution would be damaging enough.
This proposal has no chance of passage right now. Yet it’s a clear sign that as same-sex marriage spreads, more and more people (including traditionally religious opponents of gay marriage), will begin to look to the abolition of civil marriage as a “solution.” This is the reality of what same-sex marriage has brought: not a strengthening of traditional marriage, but calls for its abolition.
Indeed.
Added: If this proposal were to pass, does that mean that a New York man will no longer propose marriage to a woman, but he will instead propose a civil commitment? Just imagine that scene: the man and woman are at a posh, romantic New York restaurant. He gets on one knee, presents her with a beautiful diamond ring, looks lovingly into his girlfriend’s eyes and asks, “will you enter into a civil commitment with me?”
You may think I’m being ridiculous, but considering how the PC crowd has had quite a bit of success removing politically incorrect language (Merry Christmas) and behavior (praying in public school or any mention of God in public school) from public life, the passage of a proposal like Ms. Lifton’s would give the PC thought police ammunition to work toward eliminating any mention of the word marriage from public discourse. Since marriage would no longer exist, the phrase “we’re getting married” would be labeled “outdated and bigoted,” not to mention meanspirited toward gay civilly committed couples because, as long as the term marriage was still used, it could cause them to feel like second class citizens. Instead the traditional institution of marriage would be relegated to people’s homes and churches, absent from public life.
It may sound crazy right now, but I can see the moonbat left pulling something like this.



If we were to set aside the religous implications of “marriage,” then I doubt that many people would oppose same-sex unions so vehemently. The separation of church and state in this country requires, however, that we do just that. I do not understand how intelligent people who understand this still argue so passionately against SSM.
I have not heard a single good reason for excluding gays from the CIVIL institution of marriage. Will someone please give me one GOOD reason that is not based on the Bible.
Contrary to what many believe, marriage was for thousands of years a property arrangement between families. Women went from being the property of her father to being the property of her husband usually in exchange for other goods. Rarely was she given a choice in the matter.
The concept of practice of marriage has changed throughout the centuries, and the world did not come to a screeching halt. Changing it again to make it more inclusive will not be the end of the world.
This comment was deleted because of its grossly offensive language.
Civil debate is welcome, but I will not tolerate such disgusting language on my thread.
Kim
matt
“Legalizing gay marriage will not open the floodgates and wash away social norms, “
Heh. Wash away this one particular social norm, but we promise none of the other ones will change.
Sure they won’t.
But more importantly, (and more stupidly, on your part) :
“..polygamy (said relationships are inherently unequal and subjugatory).. “
1.Two men marrying is equal but 3 is not? How?
2.Two men and two women all getting married together is subjugatory? How?
3. Who the hell are you to tell anyone that 3 people can not get married?
(hint to everyone else besides matt and rwilymz : they won’t answer those questions with anything that makes sense. watch and see.)
It’s my choice to hate a fudge packin cock sucker, and if I don’t want to accept a bulldike or a sugar britches into MY society, then I won’t.
No, Tim, you do not have to accept anyone. You are welcome to wear your white gowns and burn your crosses (in your own yard).
I ask you, though, how one man marrying other man affects you at all? Will it make you love your wife any less? Will you stop having children? Will you withdraw from society and hide in your trailer? How will it affect you?
Les, just admit you hate the gays and stop pussyfooting around with word games and number counts.
“Les, just admit you hate the gays and stop pussyfooting around with word games and number counts.”
Heh. See?
Avoiding my points, just like I said.
Accusing me of ‘hating gays’.
So old. So lame. So predictable.
I have absolutely no problem with easy access for gays to the basic protections afforded married couples (medical approvals, wills, etc).
I do, however, strongly believe marriage is and ought to be between ONE man and ONE woman.
Further, I truly believe that much of the ATTACK on the institution of marriage is not so much a desire of large numbers of gays to marry (the stats say otherwise) as it is a way to attack yet one more underpinning of American society. Living in the SF Bay Area I routinely hear the argument that
“Marriage is a joke, just look at the divorce rate…therefore WE want to be able to marry (and presumbaly divorce) as well”. Huh?
Marriage needs to strengthened and ENCOURAGED, not dilluted and DISCOURAGED.
It’ll be too late to change course when the lefties finally figure out they have destroyed the country and their families are dying along with the conservatives they hate. The terrorists and the (just say the word) queers are not concerned with anyone but themselves. They can’t keep the population going so the world would die under their leadership, or maybe they think a bunch of clones will take over. Haven’t they heard that the so called successful cloning successes have now all proven failures. You only create medical monsters and failures in a bowl. I notice that the antique MSM has failed to report on the results (failures) of cloning after a few years.
I see cloning as accurate as the ice age a few years ago and now the global warming hype by a few failed scientist and Algore. All BS.
Marriage these days has to do with love (although that’s a relatively recent development in the history of human relationships). Love is a human emotion experienced equally by gay and straight people. It presupposes a focus that cannot be forked between multiple partners. There is one literary character I’m aware of that you could use as a counter-example, but Don Juan de Marco is supposed to be fantastical, an absurdity. As in, no such person has or will ever exist, because it is conceptually impossible. A Mormon can claim, accurately, that he loves each and every one of his wives, but he cannot claim that he does so all at the same time, and thus it is an unequal “partnership”. It’s predatory, and it doesn’t make a bit of difference what polygamists think of polygamy, any more than it matters whether or not there were slaves who liked slavery. Polyamorous marriage is too distinct in kind from gay marriage to work as a slippery slope argument.
And the slippery slope to beastiality is just stupid, because animals cannot consent. And neither can children. Incest won’t work either, as it does actual harm to society, whereas homosexual relationships do not.
As for the comment about women being somehow necessary for raising normal children, that’s false. Gay and lesbian couples make great parents, the only difference being that their kids are more likely to be tolerant of other lifestyles.
Okay MikeSC, some of your points are worth thinking about, but why not legalize gay marriage? You can twist and bend the law to defend the illegality of it, but the law would clearly accommodate it. So why not? (Same goes for Les, except none of your points were worth thinking about, as they were already debunked before you made your post.)
I hope no one quoting Heinlein forgot his depictions of civil unions in his works.
I can not agree that limiting marriage as currently defined is strictly a religious argument. A strawman is set up that is then attractive to tear apart.
The conventional marriage union is a societal construct (that religious mores support). Just because the most vocal supporters of conventional marriage are religious, does not make the argument one of religion alone.
If our society changes and/or desires to change a basic child rearing and basic human relationship structure we have followed for centuries (there are many anthropologic example of other possibilities, and creative minds have imagined untested ones as have Heinlein), then let the society, if it is democratic, decide democratically.
Divorce rates are a sad statistic demonstrating a decline in an individual and group will in our society to make a serious promise/commitment and keep it. I don’t think that broadening the definition of folks who can make a serious marriage commitment is going to have a positive effect upon that statistic.
Personally, I’m all for a graded legal status (learner’s permit, restricted permit, daytime only permit) requiring demonstrated economic stability, maturity, and participative citizenship before allowing a limited marriage license, with reproductive/adoptive/child rearing rights withheld for a two year period after the initial contract. No concern regarding sex of the two individuals necessary.
Aren’t you glad I’m not King?
I agree that marriage should be strengthened and encouraged. That is why I support SSM. Two people who love each other and wish to support each other should be encouraged to marry. What does it matter whether it is a man and a woman or a man and a man or a woman and a woman?
Somebody is intentionally missing the point.
If we accept that marriage is the joining of two people, and if we accept the notion of a fidelity commitment between these TWO people, then in no case can a “homosexual marriage” be “equal” to a “hetersexual marriage” because the former cannot produce offspring without outside intervention.
I recognize that not all heterosexual couples are capable of producing, and that not all want to. But the fact remains, it is a non-negotiable fact that it requires both genders to create new life.
It is true that marriage has been a property arrangement in many instances, but I’ve heard much more debate in my many years about children being born out of wedlock, than I ever have about property rights.
Incest won’t work either, as it does actual harm to society, whereas homosexual relationships do not.
How so? By many accounts, few people are as inbred as the royal families of Europe.
It is logically impossible to say that incestual marriage would cause any harm, whatsoever, to society.
As for the comment about women being somehow necessary for raising normal children, that’s false. Gay and lesbian couples make great parents, the only difference being that their kids are more likely to be tolerant of other lifestyles.
There is not an actual study in existence that argues that gay couples are as good as straight couples when it comes to raising kids.
Not one single study.
Okay MikeSC, some of your points are worth thinking about, but why not legalize gay marriage? You can twist and bend the law to defend the illegality of it, but the law would clearly accommodate it. So why not? (Same goes for Les, except none of your points were worth thinking about, as they were already debunked before you made your post.)
Shokingly enough, I don’t care if it gets legalized.
My beef is HOW they are going about doing that.
THIS is what a legislature is there for. To make an end-run around it is deplorable and something I cannot ever respect.
For me, gay marriage advocates are dramatically worse than the Religious Right because the Religious Right got their influence through the ballot box, which is the way it’s meant to be done.
Scrapiron, if you are allowed to get married and raise kids, then gay people sure as hell better be allowed to. Read what you just posted! I mean actually READ it, and absorb your own words! You are out of your mind, dude.
To the other conservatives (assuming that’s what Scrapiron is–he might actually be a DU lurker having some fun)–you can claim not to be merely homophobic, but you should make some noises about this lunatic in your midst to pay lip service to the notion that you are not merely bigots.
And Justrand… who are you “quoting”? Do you have such a low opinion of gays and lesbians that you think they’re all out to undermine society by pleading for the right to marry just so that they can go through costly divorces? I don’t expect that you have any gay friends, but really, how can you actually have such a crass opinion of such a large number of Americans? And how would allowing more couples who are in love with one another to marry each other “dillute and DISCOURAGE” the institution of marriage? You know what needs to be addressed? The crazy divorce rates in the red states. (http://www.infoplease.com/ipa/A0923080.html)
Unless you want to blame Southerners’ marital problems on the homosexual menace, which would be a totally awesome argument to listen to in divorce court.
It’ll be too late to change course when the lefties finally figure out they have destroyed the country and their families are dying along with the conservatives they hate. The terrorists and the (just say the word) queers are not concerned with anyone but themselves. They can’t keep the population going so the world would die under their leadership, or maybe they think a bunch of clones will take over.
I will address scrapiron’s lunatic rantings because I want to make a point. Many of you who oppose SSM claim that it is the LEFT that wants to use SSM for some nefarious purpose.
To set the record straight (so to speak), I am a conservative. I am Christian. I voted for Bush (twice) AND I support the right of gay people to marry the partner of their choice. I believe that SSM is something that conservatives should support since it STRENGTHENS the institution of marriage.
If people wish to “save” the institution of marriage they should focus on limiting divorce, not denying the institution to 2-7% of the population. Call me cynical, but I believe that many of these people who oppose SSM on the grounds that they want to “save marriage,” will not touch divorce laws because that may affect them. Attacking gays does not affect them.
How many of you who oppose SSM have been divorced? Just curious…
Sigh… Chuck, they’re equal in dignity, and in value (for the persons so joined), but not in identity. And it doesn’t require both genders to have children, only their biological material. Gay men can donate to sperm banks which lesbian couples can go to. But the child-bearing-feasibility argument you brought up is in fact reduced to absurdity by the point you brush away, namely, that if gays can’t marry because they can’t have kids, then how is it justified for senior citizens or infertile adults to get married without referring to the other reasons that demonstrably ought to be extended to gay couples as well?
There is not an actual study in existence that argues that gay couples are as good as straight couples when it comes to raising kids.
Not one single study.
Provide a study to the contrary, then, from an academic source (and not a Christian think tank). Otherwise go to a park in NYC or San Francisco and watch the gay couples with their kids, and you tell me that they shouldn’t be able to raise kids. All of my friends from non-traditional households (parents never married but still common law, mother artificially inseminated by a donor she never met, two moms) are very well-rounded people (and–shock!–very liberal), whereas a lot of the people I know from broken nuclear families are variously effed up.
For me, gay marriage advocates are dramatically worse than the Religious Right because the Religious Right got their influence through the ballot box, which is the way it’s meant to be done. So for you the anti-miscegenationists were worse than the racist bigots because they went through the SCOTUS and not the ballot box, then? Of course not! I know you didn’t mean it.
This issue allows the Republican congress to ignore its Christian base, but to try and kiss and make up during election years by targeting a group of people who overwhelmingly vote Democrat. Cynical, yes. True, yes.
“It’ll be too late to change course when the lefties finally figure out they have destroyed the country and their families are dying along with the conservatives they hate. The terrorists and the (just say the word) queers are not concerned with anyone but themselves.”
It’s statements like that keep me coming back to this place, and it actually makes me proud when Scrapiron or one of his ilk attacks me.
Re: rwilymz points:
If there is nothing “special” about the gender of the people involved, then what’s so special about the number? Or the familial relationship between the members petitioning? Darlene
The specialness is manifest in the equality of application. Common Law has dictated “two”; gays want only equal application.
The ‘equality of application’ is only manifest as to number, not gender.
If they cannot then the institution cannot limit itself by another other than age of participants (minors cannot contract).Darlene
More history for yuz: We The People didn’t define “marriage” as “man – woman – one each” in more than about 1/3 of the states until about 10 years ago.
And that is so only because prior to 10yrs ago same-sex marriage was unimaginable.
Sorry to be pedantic here, but I must; …For “thousands of years” there was no word “marriage”. …Additionally, “for thousand of years” the United States of America didn’t exist, …We are talking about a US Law thing here, and that only goes back 230 years…since we’re talking US law, and US state law at that — … — it wasn’t until the last decade that states started legally defining marriage as “one man one woman”. Most states had vague definitions of “marriage”.
“Thousands of years” is wholly irrelevant to the issue.
Wholly irrelevant…You are not only being pedantic but more pertinently, purposely obtuse.
You are well aware of the great antiquity of the institution of marriage. No doubt you are also aware of the long route society’s have taken to reach the consensus that children are optimally raised and society are best served through loving, monogamous, publicly committed couples of opposite gender. (Heterosexuals abysmal inability to meet that standard in no way invalidates its worth)
You have acknowledged that men and women are biologically different. Only the ignorantly politically correct will argue that the biological differences are not manifest in psychological gender differences.
Those differences have been judged by almost all society’s to be essential in the raising of children into healthy adults.
Yet you would overturn the acquired wisdom that millennia of experience has brought humanity out of an arrogant presumption that legal acumen and logic are all that are required in determining the optimum definition of marriage. You cavalierly dismiss all concerns as trumped by a narrow interpretation of the institution of marriage. Obtusely refusing to acknowledge that if gender is arbitrary then number is as well.
We The People have every authority to define social and contractual institutions, but those institutions cannot deny the participation of everyone who chooses to participate. Equal Protection was so important that we put it in the Constitutino twice.
Everyone is free to participate. Under the conditions presently formulated.
Your argument is simply that the social and contractual institution of marriage should be redefined, as justification, you assert that it is strictly and solely a matter of equal protection.
Then we’ll have:
1. Multiple partner civil unions. By Ed
1] only if laws are created forming them; allowing gays to participate in currently-existing laws won’t accomplish this.
But it will accomplish this, because it is the logical extension and inevitable legal consequence of your equal protection argument. The equal protection argument places all ‘conditions’ of the marriage contract, other than the status of being a minor, into the category of legally indefensible arbitrariness. In time, multiple partners HAVE to be legalized because the equal protection clause would legally apply to them as well.
The US military is a public institution that grants special benefits unavailable to people who don’t join AND the instition discriminates (original meaning of the word) on who gets to join ALL THE TIME. Is that a violation of equal protection? Darlene
Frankly, yes. Gays ought to be able to join the military as well.
So you reject the assertion that it harms unit cohesiveness? If so, upon what basis do you base that rejection? Or, if you do accept the assertion, do you again use equal protection as the basis to override all other concerns?
Three people? Six? Darlene
… the issue is not “Three people” nor is it “six”. It is two. Gays wish to be afforded the same rights to join that civil institution created for two that the rest of us enjoy. If you wish to see “three people” marriages, then petition your lawmakers. But when it happens,(my emphasis; so you DO acknowledge it!) you cannot deny the three person marriage to three men OR three women without running into Equal Protection.
You define the issue as two because acknowledgment of the legal inevitability of multi-partner consequence, undermines the wisdom of pursuing the path you wish to see society follow…
Why is this so difficult for you to comprehend?
We comprehend it just fine. Why do you insist that legal definitions are all that matter when discussing society’s foundational infrastructure?
But then, I just answered that above, didn’t I?
Gays can marry today. Darlene
Yeah? Who? Not the people they want to marry.
Ah, it is ALL about wants isn’t it?
The state can make any laws it wants to; it simply has to enforce them equally…Do you get it yet?
Not to be pedantic, but you left out the constitutional qualifier as to the state having the power to make any law it wants…
Amusing how we wonder the same about you, but then it’s not about comprehension, is it? It’s about acceptance…
Oh, but gay marriage is different, because it’s just so icky! And a queasy stomach is more important an issue than anything else …
A queasy stomach is the result of your atrophied moral conscience trying to communicate with an intellect wedded to flawed logic.
Logic cannot examine its originating premise. Our logic no more than yours. The difference is that we are not relying on logic solely; to reach a conclusion about overturning millennia of accumulated societal wisdom.
Your logic is based in the premise that your secular relativism is superior to every previous generation’s perceptions about the optimum societal infrastructure. What absolute arrogance, you must be a baby boomer. Or have you simply accepted the pablum your college instructors fed you?
Word, Lee. While waiting for people to reply or while trying to kill another five minutes at work I idle my time away trying to imagine how many flannel shirts Scrapiron has, what TV shows he watches (assuming he hasn’t shot his TV, which is a bold assumption), which calibre of handgun he keeps under the seat of his truck, and which in his glovebox…
Before you lash out at me, Scrapiron, realize that I’m just making fun of you. It’s lighthearted. I’ll be the first to admit that I’m a dick from time to time, but you seem to think that I, and others like me, are your enemy! I meant it earlier when I said I hope you put those brush fires out, because I sincerely don’t want your home or any of your neighbours’ to be destroyed.
But when you address a liberal/Democrat/moonbat (as though they’re interchangeable), you sound like you’re ready to strangle somebody. We all get mad, but honestly, what’s up? Did a drunk-ass Kennedy run over your dog when you were a boy? Did Maureen Dowd divorce you and take half your stuff? I’m all for heated discussion, but I think you go way over the top.
VA Gamer … Nobody’s stopping gays from living together and sharing their love. Why don’t gays fight for all the perks marriage provides instead of marriage itself? Simple answer. The benefits from marriage aren’t what gays want. They want marriage so it will bring them another step closer to being accepted into society. Why get married? The tax rate is higher. Why not just push for the insurance issue, spousal support…ect
Logic cannot examine its originating premise. Our logic no more than yours. The difference is that we are not relying on logic solely; to reach a conclusion about overturning millennia of accumulated societal wisdom.
Your logic is based in the premise that your secular relativism is superior to every previous generation’s perceptions about the optimum societal infrastructure. What absolute arrogance, you must be a baby boomer. Or have you simply accepted the pablum your college instructors fed you?
Sorry, d_Brit, but your “logic” does not pass the test of historical accuracy. Please define “millenia of accumulated societal wisdom.” If you think that marriage throughout the centuries has been some version of the 1950s utopian “one father/one mother/2.2 kids/dog/white picket fence”, then you need to go back to your history books.
The institution of marriage and ideas about child-rearing have certainly changed and evolved over the centuries. True, they did not include same-sex couples, but that change would be smaller than other marital changes over the years.
Consider how radical it would have been for marriage to change from a simple property arrangement where the married couple may never have learned to love each other to an institution where the couple themselves fell in love and made the decision to marry.
The institution survived radical re-definitions and will continue to do so.
Tim, I assume that you are not gay, so I ask how you presume to know what gay people want. Do they all want the same exact thing? Do you think they will sleep better at night once they get your blessing?
Your argument is silly. Why should gay couples have do do anything different to get the same benefits that their straight friends get? Why should they have to get a lawyer to write a contract for all the rights that are assumed with a marriage contract?
Furthermore, why is it any of your business? Does their marriage somehow affect you?
The ‘equality of application’ is only manifest as to number, not gender.
Then the burden of proof lies with you to demonstrate why the gender criterion can be used discriminatorily instead of inclusively in this case. Same-sex marriage advocates deny the relevance of gender for equal application. Your exception is ad hoc, and follows either from tradition (not a good way to argue anything) or prejudice (ditto). Gender is irrelevant, but age isn’t, because gender has nothing to do with competence.
“Thousands of years” is wholly irrelevant to the issue.
Wholly irrelevant…You are not only being pedantic but more pertinently, purposely obtuse.
I disagree. I think arguments against SSm based in traditionalism are pretty weak if said tradition has been, traditionally, incredibly elastic and vaguely defined.
You are well aware of the great antiquity of the institution of marriage. No doubt you are also aware of the long route society’s have taken to reach the consensus that children are optimally raised and society are best served through loving, monogamous, publicly committed couples of opposite gender. (Heterosexuals abysmal inability to meet that standard in no way invalidates its worth)
When did history check and see how well institutionalized gender-blind civil unions would serve society? Liberals are biological evolutionists, not social evolutionists. There is no reason to assume that because our culture won out over, say, Native American cultures that children and families are better off as a result. All it shows is that one society beat another in a conflict. Irrelevant.
Those differences have been judged by almost all society’s to be essential in the raising of children into healthy adults.
Based on empirical research? Or based on incredulity at the very IDEA of buggerers having children? Why, they can’t even fornicate like Christians! And everyone knows how delicate lesbians are! Boys would develop no masculine traits in a lesbian “household”! (/jokes)
On gays in the military: So you reject the assertion that it harms unit cohesiveness?
YES!!! You think gays are so unpatriotic that they would rather stare at hot Marine ass instead of doing their job? Canadians allow women into combat roles (rightly so), and thus far there have been no reports of patrols in Afghanistan getting ambushed because they were all too busy having sex with each other.
Not to be pedantic, but you left out the constitutional qualifier as to the state having the power to make any law it wants…
Don’t be silly. He meant laws that are within their authority to issue. He obviously knows a thing or two about what he’s talking about, so you could assume he understands that the Constitution applies to Congress.
Your logic is based in the premise that your secular relativism is superior to every previous generation’s perceptions about the optimum societal infrastructure. What absolute arrogance, you must be a baby boomer. Or have you simply accepted the pablum your college instructors fed you?
Well, you obviously didn’t go to college (which is fine) because you don’t know how to use the term “moral relativism”. Liberals are not relativistic on this issue. This is a human rights issue, and human rights are universal. To argue, though, that gay marriage is bad because a majority of Americans are opposed to it is paradigmatically relativistic. It’s populism, that ugliest of political justifications which holds that moral truths are relative to the will of the people and subject to change. Fuck that they are. Blacks were human beings before they were recognized as such, and gay marriage is good and just so long as the institution of marriage has any meaning in American society. Whether it takes four years or fifty for it to be made legal (as it certainly will) is irrelevant.
Otherwise go to a park in NYC or San Francisco and watch the gay couples with their kids, and you tell me that they shouldn’t be able to raise kids.
OR, in layman’s terms, “go with anecdotal evidence” — which science has said is useless.
Take every single study of the problems of kids in single parent households.
The gay household has even MORE problems.
All of my friends from non-traditional households (parents never married but still common law, mother artificially inseminated by a donor she never met, two moms) are very well-rounded people (and–shock!–very liberal), whereas a lot of the people I know from broken nuclear families are variously effed up.
And while those are nice little stories, anecdotes are a poor substitute for actual evidence.
When you don’t have science on your side, go for anecdotes, I guess.
So for you the anti-miscegenationists were worse than the racist bigots because they went through the SCOTUS and not the ballot box, then?
Since blacks couldn’t vote and gays CAN vote — no, it is not the same thing.
But keep trying to compare the suffering of gays to the suffering of blacks. It’s a SHADE less offensive and ridiculous than PETA’S claims of a chicken farm being similar to the Holocaust.
It’s really absurd, mind you, but a little less than that.
This issue allows the Republican congress to ignore its Christian base, but to try and kiss and make up during election years by targeting a group of people who overwhelmingly vote Democrat. Cynical, yes. True, yes.
It’s funny how much “Democrats” actually, you know, dislike “democracy”.
Why is it an issue now? Because left-wing judges are making it a legislative issue by overstepping their bounds, as per usual.
It’s like blaming Israel for fighting back against constant terrorist attacks.
Before you lash out at me, Scrapiron, realize that I’m just making fun of you. It’s lighthearted. I’ll be the first to admit that I’m a dick from time to time, but you seem to think that I, and others like me, are your enemy!
Gee, why would he think you’re his enemy? You don’t ACT like it, right?
But when you address a liberal/Democrat/moonbat (as though they’re interchangeable), you sound like you’re ready to strangle somebody. We all get mad, but honestly, what’s up? Did a drunk-ass Kennedy run over your dog when you were a boy? Did Maureen Dowd divorce you and take half your stuff? I’m all for heated discussion, but I think you go way over the top.
That you say this while supporting Lee is funny.
I doubt you’ll notice it, though.
Consider how radical it would have been for marriage to change from a simple property arrangement where the married couple may never have learned to love each other to an institution where the couple themselves fell in love and made the decision to marry.
Yes, that is DRAMATICALLY more radical than, oh, changing the sex of the partners involved. That is almost minor.
And marriage has historically been primarily concerned with children. Since gay marriage cannot result in children — your entire argument is null and void.
Why should gay couples have do do anything different to get the same benefits that their straight friends get?
You don’t see ME whining that it is harder for me to get into colleges and get grants and all due to my gender and skin color, do you?
I deal with it.
If all gays want are the perks, then they have the ability to get them. It’s really not even that difficult.
Why should they have to get a lawyer to write a contract for all the rights that are assumed with a marriage contract?
How is it “unfair” when they have access to it?
Are you really trying to use “Well, it should be EASIER” as an argument for your case?
If so, it is a rather weak one.
Furthermore, why is it any of your business? Does their marriage somehow affect you?
Because I dislike the courts making decisions that belong to the legislature.
-=Mike
Your reply to Tim is right on, VA Gamer.
I remember reading a column, or perhaps a blog entry, by David Frum claiming that since most gays in Canada did not get married within a year after it was made legal, that this was reason to rethink the whole thing. That’s stupid. It wasn’t made legal for pragmatic or functional reasons, but moral and legal ones.
Since it’s a moral question, it is thus an objective one. A legal right ought not to be revoked because no one chooses to exercise it. Similarly, there is a socially contingent aspect to marriage (but not relativistic–it’s a difficult distinction, which Joseph Raz explains in Engaging Reason) that contains a great deal of meaning for people who enter into a marriage. It may have religious origins (as a sacrament or whatever), but marriage is a social institution now. To suggest that gays might be as well-off with lawyered-up agreements in place of a marriage license misses a great deal of what is important for same-sex marriage advocates, Tim. Gay and lesbian couples ought to have the right to engage in the same practices as straight couples (those which are biologically possible, at least), and what they choose to do with that right is no one’s business but theirs.
One half of the biological material still must come from outside of the marriage, regardless of what scientific breakthrough is employed.
I’m still thinking about the “Senior citizen/infertile couple” argument.
Since it’s a moral question, it is thus an objective one.
Ah, so your morality is the only one that matters, eh?
Got it.
Pretty authoritarian of you there.
To suggest that gays might be as well-off with lawyered-up agreements in place of a marriage license misses a great deal of what is important for same-sex marriage advocates, Tim.
I. Do. Not. Care.
They can get what they want.
If they are hoping for the courts to make people think they’re “normal”, they’ll sadly learn that this strategy will do the opposite.
Gay and lesbian couples ought to have the right to engage in the same practices as straight couples (those which are biologically possible, at least), and what they choose to do with that right is no one’s business but theirs.
And they do now.
Your argument for gay marriage is…what?
-=Mike
MikeSC, perhaps you should familiarize yourself with the pending constitutional amendment in Virginia. It would not only define marriage as between a man and a woman but also void any contract that attempts to approximate marriage. Thus, such contracts, insurance policies, wills, hospital visitation rights, etc would be ILLEGAL.
Please tell me how you think this is fair. A majority of Virginians will be all it takes to make this happen. In the home state of Jerry Falwell and Pat Robertson, this will almost certainly pass. I have long wondered that if slavery would be put up to a vote in Virgina, would it still pass? I cannot be 100% that it would fail.
Were it to pass, Mike, should it be allowed? After all, the democratic majority would have voted for it. Democracy, simply defined, means majority rules WITH minority rights. The role of the courts is to assure that minority rights are not trampled on by the majority.
Should some state courts decide that their state constitutions allows gay marriage, why would that be wrong? They are simply protecting minority rights.
Since blacks couldn’t vote and gays CAN vote — no, it is not the same thing.
But keep trying to compare the suffering of gays to the suffering of blacks. It’s a SHADE less offensive and ridiculous than PETA’S claims of a chicken farm being similar to the Holocaust.
It’s really absurd, mind you, but a little less than that.
Comparing me to PETA, Mike? Well, check and mate, eh? Sheesh. Are you saying that only after blacks were legally permitted to date and marry white women were bi-racial relationships acceptable? And how do you think gay and lesbian (and bisexual) Americans are expected to accomplish anything with ballots? This is why there is a Supreme Court, to protect minorities from the tyranny of the majority.
It’s like blaming Israel for fighting back against constant terrorist attacks.
I’ll bring this up next time I get chewed out for going off-topic (as I frequently do).
Gee, why would he think you’re his enemy? You don’t ACT like it, right?
You’re a nutcase. Is everyone you dislike your enemy? Is everyone you strongly disagree with your enemy? I hope the answers are “No” and “No”, respectively, else you’re a very angry and unstable individual who probably shouldn’t be allowed to own firearms. And I wasn’t defending everything Lee has ever said, but just having a chuckle with him about our pal Scrapiron.
You say that love and other emotions being incorporated into marriage is less radical than allowing same-sex couples to get married. You’re obviously wrong. Gay marriage can result in children because adoption is legal. Same for infertile straight couples. Mike, you can do better than this, and you usually do as you’re pretty sharp. I’m not saying you’re having a stupid day, though, but see this as an indication that this issue is a loser for conservatives. Isn’t there some dwarf with nuclear weapons clamoring for attention in N. Korea right now?
One half of the biological material still must come from outside of the marriage, regardless of what scientific breakthrough is employed.
But same-sex couples don’t mind. Take as long as you like with the infertile straight couples bit, but I’m afraid it’s a winner. 😉
Bleh, sorry about my atrocious lack of ability to use html tags properly, Mike. I think you should be able to decipher which words were yours, and which mine.
And another thing. I have recently promised a close friend to stop being mean and to stop calling people names. I apologize for calling you a nutcase, Mike.
Maybe I’ll start previewing this stuff…
Ah, so your morality is the only one that matters, eh?
Got it.
Pretty authoritarian of you there.
That’s not what I said. I’m not advocating prescribing my moral convictions for every human being. Objectivism isn’t universalism. What I was saying, is that the truth-value of the contents of a moral judgement are not subjectively dependent on the will of the person or group who makes the judgement. This is what allows us to say “You’re wrong.” The alternative position, which is untenable, can be summarised as “Right and wrong is in the eye of the mob.” Again: Joseph Raz, in Engaging Reason, explains how morality can remain objective and still allow for reasonable disagreement (as it obviously does).
And now I’m going to eat the hell out of some chicken wings. Don’t tell my friends at PETA! =)
MikeSC, perhaps you should familiarize yourself with the pending constitutional amendment in Virginia. It would not only define marriage as between a man and a woman but also void any contract that attempts to approximate marriage. Thus, such contracts, insurance policies, wills, hospital visitation rights, etc would be ILLEGAL.
Note how it’s being put to a vote? You seem to forget that my criticism is the MEANS gay marriage advocates are going about “Getting their way”.
If a similar vote completely legalizing gay marriage passed, I’d applaud THAT, too.
Please tell me how you think this is fair. A majority of Virginians will be all it takes to make this happen.
That’s Constitutional Amendments for you.
How is this less fair than allowing a small group of old lawyers to make the decision instead?
In the home state of Jerry Falwell and Pat Robertson, this will almost certainly pass.
God knows trashing the state’s voters is a winning formula for electoral success.
I have long wondered that if slavery would be put up to a vote in Virgina, would it still pass? I cannot be 100% that it would fail.
It’s because you’re delusional.
Were it to pass, Mike, should it be allowed?
Yup.
After all, the democratic majority would have voted for it. Democracy, simply defined, means majority rules WITH minority rights. The role of the courts is to assure that minority rights are not trampled on by the majority.
Them’s the breaks. If the majority feels something is wrong, then that is the way it goes.
If the majority voted FOR gay marriage in an Amendment, I doubt you’d be going so nuts for it.
Should some state courts decide that their state constitutions allows gay marriage, why would that be wrong? They are simply protecting minority rights.
No, it is MORE wrong than this as a small group of lawyers makes the decision, rather than the electorate at large.
The gay marriage advocates have decided to not try and make a case.
C’est la vie.
Comparing me to PETA, Mike?
No. Just that your arguments are equally insane.
Are you saying that only after blacks were legally permitted to date and marry white women were bi-racial relationships acceptable?
No. I’m saying that they were always acceptable — they were illegally forbidden as it was clearly unfair treatment.
This is not even in the same state, much less the same ballpark.
I’ll bring this up next time I get chewed out for going off-topic (as I frequently do).
Yes, comparisons are so off-topic.
You’re a nutcase.
Deeply are my feelings wounded.
Is everyone you dislike your enemy?
How can you dislike somebody you don’t know?
And you call others “nutcase”?
You say that love and other emotions being incorporated into marriage is less radical than allowing same-sex couples to get married. You’re obviously wrong.
You proved me wrong so thoroughly, too. Danke.
Gay marriage can result in children because adoption is legal.
And your cause takes another blow.
Same for infertile straight couples.
Again, no. But since you cannot say what couples are infertile immediately, you cannot say “You can’t get married”.
That’d be unequal treatment.
I’m not saying you’re having a stupid day, though, but see this as an indication that this issue is a loser for conservatives. Isn’t there some dwarf with nuclear weapons clamoring for attention in N. Korea right now?
It seems to be passing in every state proposed.
That is a loser?
-=Mike
That’s not what I said. I’m not advocating prescribing my moral convictions for every human being. Objectivism isn’t universalism. What I was saying, is that the truth-value of the contents of a moral judgement are not subjectively dependent on the will of the person or group who makes the judgement. This is what allows us to say “You’re wrong.” The alternative position, which is untenable, can be summarised as “Right and wrong is in the eye of the mob.” Again: Joseph Raz, in Engaging Reason, explains how morality can remain objective and still allow for reasonable disagreement (as it obviously does).
But, if there is fervent disagreement as to what is right and what is wrong — which is the case here — how is it better to limit the people who can vote on the issue to 7 or 9 judges (based on your state) rather than the voters at large?
-=Mike
“how is it better to limit the people who can vote on the issue to 7 or 9 judges (based on your state) rather than the voters at large?”
Because our system is designed to protect the RIGHTS of the individual from the TYRANNY OF THE MASSES. Mob rule sucks. Always has, always will.
Funny how “conservatives” understand that when it’s guns or tax money at stake and always seem to forget it when OMG TEH GAYZ are the issue.
Mmm, them was good chicken wings. Anyway…
“Were it to pass, Mike, should it be allowed?
Yup.”
Really? So any hypothetical example we could come up with of people voting for patently absurd or immoral statutes would meet your approval as a legitimate exercise in democracy? What about in Iraq? What if the Shiites exercise their collective will and make racist laws against Sunnis and Turks? Would that be alright with you? Institutionalized hatred? I will assume not, in which case I can say, by extension, that this point goes to the blue team.
Democracies require more than just ballot boxes. They require minority protections. When the majority errs in this regard (by which I mean when the majority gets it objectively wrong, as you acknowledged is possible like with bi-racial relationships), it falls upon the Supreme Court to do something about it. If you think otherwise, then you’re un-American. America’s Constitution is more populist than the parliamentary systems of England and Canada, but the Founders recognized that voters aren’t infallible, morality isn’t relative, and judges can better be trusted with hard legal cases than laypeople. I don’t care if you think that makes me an elitist, because I think it’s a necessary condition for having a full appreciation of what it means to be an American. I’m not questioning your patriotism, but asking you to rethink your position. And yes, sometimes the SCOTUS gets it wrong too, but it’s a necessary if imperfect check on the will of the people.
“I’m saying that they were always acceptable — they were illegally forbidden as it was clearly unfair treatment.”
A judge determined that miscegenation laws were “illegal” (I presume you mean unconstitutional). A judge rectified the situation. He acted as an “activist”, for civil rights in this case, and I’m glad that you approve. If we know something is without a doubt unjust, it doesn’t matter what a voter thinks about it, especially since this voter might be better off with the continuation of said injustice. The courts should, and thankfully sometimes do, supercede Congress when the situation warrants it. It’s not like they’re writing tax policy from the bench. Their jurisdiction is usually pretty clear, as with human rights which are non-negotiable and not subject to democratic whimsy. (But then they hold a hearing for Anna Nicole Smith’s fight for her inheritance. I like the concept of the Supreme Court, but I don’t much like this particular one.)
I said: “You say that love and other emotions being incorporated into marriage is less radical than allowing same-sex couples to get married. You’re obviously wrong.”
Your reply: “You proved me wrong so thoroughly, too. Danke.”
My reply to that: I did. The first transition involved rewriting the rules of the game. The second involves letting other people play the same game. Now unless you think same-sex couples are abominable, you won’t find the difference between them and straight couples as significant as the difference between marriage-as-property-transer and marriage-as-loving-partnership. I thought it was obvious, so I didn’t elaborate.
Mike, come on: “But since you cannot say what couples are infertile immediately, you cannot say “You can’t get married”.
That’d be unequal treatment.”
Let’s say a 70 year old couple applies for a marriage license, and you have to approve or reject their application. You can a) assume they’re getting married to fulfill their biological roles, or b) are unable to procreate, but acknowledge that it’s no business of anyone’s what they do in their spare time. If you assume a), you’re being stupid and/or mean, and if you assume b), you’re potentially a decent person with at least a minimal understanding of what marriage ought to be in American society.
You’ve argued that procreation is relevant for justifying who can get married, which is flat-out wrong and contradicts current social norms in the reddest of states; and defended the idea that if the will of the people is immoral, then it behooves the courts to respect it. And I’m not even oversimplifying! You acknowledge that these are your beliefs! They’re absurd!
And I don’t care if America votes to ban gay marriage, because, as I explained, whether or not gay marriage is right is not dependent on anyone’s opinions of it. It’s a “winner” for liberals and libertarians because they win this argument on principle. I’m confident that the Court will get it right too, eventually.
Mike, the reason that TM is correct about the inevitability of marriage equality is that your side cannot make a reasonable case against it. Most Americans are fair-minded and tolerant. Your side of this issue often comes across as mean-spirited and intolerant.
The Christian Right will have to move into the mainstream if it wants to continue to have any influence. A great way to do this is to preemptively allow the civil institution of “marriage” to be codified as a secular one, while demanding (and getting) a guarantee that their tax-exempt status won’t be affected by how they discuss this issue in their churches and whether they choose to allow gay people to get married within the context of their own religion.
Dobson, Falwell and Robertson probably won’t compromise, but them’s my two cents.
Because our system is designed to protect the RIGHTS of the individual from the TYRANNY OF THE MASSES. Mob rule sucks. Always has, always will.
So allowing 4 people to vote instead of all of the public helps you…how?
There are no rights that gays lack.
Marriage is not, nor has it ever been, a right.
Funny how “conservatives” understand that when it’s guns or tax money at stake and always seem to forget it when OMG TEH GAYZ are the issue.
Funny how Dems assume voters don’t know anything and then wonder why voters don’t vote for them terribly often.
Substituting a “Tyranny” by the voters with a “tyranny” by unaccountable judges is hardly a preferrable option.
Really? So any hypothetical example we could come up with of people voting for patently absurd or immoral statutes would meet your approval as a legitimate exercise in democracy?
Seeing as how it is not patently immoral or absurd, it’s an immaterial point to make.
This isn’t voting to legalize slavery.
What about in Iraq? What if the Shiites exercise their collective will and make racist laws against Sunnis and Turks? Would that be alright with you?
Whether it’s OK or not is irrelevant, since it is their country to do with what they wish. We as Americans have no control over that.
Democracies require more than just ballot boxes. They require minority protections.
A tyranny of the minority is worse than a tyranny of the majority.
When the majority errs in this regard (by which I mean when the majority gets it objectively wrong, as you acknowledged is possible like with bi-racial relationships), it falls upon the Supreme Court to do something about it.
Seeing as not allowing gay marriage is neither illegal nor immoral and the only reason it is an issue is that some judges “found” the right in centuries-old Constitutions when nobody else found it before is why it’s an issue now.
If you think otherwise, then you’re un-American.
Wow. Un-American. You, again, deeply wound me.
Notice how I have yet to question your patriotism, even though you’re clearly not fond of elections or voting?
Do you want to be reminded of problems SCOTUS made worse? Slavery would have withered away and no Civil War would have occurred — had Dred Scott not been decided. SCOTUS made segregation the law of the land in Plessy.
It’s significantly easier to overturn a law than a SCOTUS decision as SCOTUS isn’t fond of overturning itself.
America’s Constitution is more populist than the parliamentary systems of England and Canada, but the Founders recognized that voters aren’t infallible, morality isn’t relative, and judges can better be trusted with hard legal cases than laypeople.
Jefferson, actually, would rather vigorously disagree with that. As would the other Founding Fathers.
. I’m not questioning your patriotism?
But you also said:
If you think otherwise, then you’re un-American
Which is it?
My reply to that: I did.
I assumed adding “/sarcasm” was not needed.
I was wrong.
Alas.
Now unless you think same-sex couples are abominable, you won’t find the difference between them and straight couples as significant as the difference between marriage-as-property-transer and marriage-as-loving-partnership. I thought it was obvious, so I didn’t elaborate.
Yes, again, because replacing property for love as a reason for marriage is SO much less drastic than, oh, replacing the need for the opposite sex.
Because the REASON for marriage is so much more drastic a change than THE FUNDAMENTAL ASPECTS OF MARRIAGE.
Let’s say a 70 year old couple applies for a marriage license, and you have to approve or reject their application. You can a) assume they’re getting married to fulfill their biological roles, or b) are unable to procreate, but acknowledge that it’s no business of anyone’s what they do in their spare time.
As long as it is a man and a woman, it is not my concern.
If you want to change the rules, you need to actually go through the procedure to change the rules.
You’ve argued that procreation is relevant for justifying who can get married
Nope. But nice try, though. I said it was a historic reason why states got involved in the first place.
which is flat-out wrong and contradicts current social norms in the reddest of states; and defended the idea that if the will of the people is immoral, then it behooves the courts to respect it.
It’d be grand if you’d expend the energy to argue points I made and not one that you wish I made.
You acknowledge that these are your beliefs! They’re absurd!
Yes, stating the reality of why it was done means I support it.
Pure logic.
Hmm, so if I can explain the very tenuous legal reasoning behind Roe v Wade, it must mean I agree with it.
Shocking.
Well, I can even explain how Hitler gained power and I understand how he managed to win votes as he did. I suppose it means I’m actually a Nazi.
Wow, I am floored.
I can EVEN understand Communistic principles — why, I MUST also fully agree with Communism.
I mean, that IS your point, right?
I know, it’s an absurdly silly point I’d, personally, be too embarrassed to make in a public forum, but hey — I’m not you.
And I don’t care if America votes to ban gay marriage, because, as I explained, whether or not gay marriage is right is not dependent on anyone’s opinions of it. It’s a “winner” for liberals and libertarians because they win this argument on principle. I’m confident that the Court will get it right too, eventually.
Yes. Because when courts make decisions, it NEVER causes more problems.
I mean, abortion is not even a little hot as an issue, right?
Mike, the reason that TM is correct about the inevitability of marriage equality is that your side cannot make a reasonable case against it.
*sigh*
Yet again, I don’t CARE about gay marriage.
I DO care about groups deciding to go to lawyers in pretty robes to get what they cannot get through the legitimate, legislative process.
In case you missed it — if an Amendment was passed legalizing gay marriage, I’d applaud it.
I doubt you’ll read my statement this time either — but I’m putting it out there for you.
Again.
Most Americans are fair-minded and tolerant. Your side of this issue often comes across as mean-spirited and intolerant.
Hmm, I haven’t called anybody un-American.
The same cannot be said about the gay marriage advocates.
My beef is with HOW they go about what they want, not WHAT they want.
It really isn’t THAT challenging a concept to grasp, is it?
-=Mike
The Christian Right will have to move into the mainstream if it wants to continue to have any influence. A great way to do this is to preemptively allow the civil institution of “marriage” to be codified as a secular one, while demanding (and getting) a guarantee that their tax-exempt status won’t be affected by how they discuss this issue in their churches and whether they choose to allow gay people to get married within the context of their own religion.
If you don’t mind me asking — how would that be “the mainstream” when, in every state it’s proposed in, voters oppose gay marriage by healthy majorities?
I mean, if you want a group to join “the mainstream”, you might want to look at your side.
-=Mike
“Funny how Dems assume voters don’t know anything and then wonder why voters don’t vote for them terribly often.”
I’m not a Dem, genius. I’m a registered Republican and I voted for Dubya. Twice. Nice snarky little try you made there.
I also know when my own are being asses, and this issue makes asses out of a great many “conservatives” who just can’t WAIT to get the government to enforce their religious moral codes in this matter.
It disgusts me.
By the way, it’s not about marriage being a right. It’s about being treated equal under the law, and that IS a right we are all supposed to have. Some conservatives still understand and believe in equality and liberty. I’m sorry you’re not one of them.
Mike, it was difficult to muddle through your posting since everything was bold. I find it very difficult to believe that you would accept every vote of the majority but find no room to accept the need for a judiciary.
Let’s say, for instance, that the voters of South Carolina (your home state?) decided that women should show more modesty in their dress. Thus they passed a law by popular vote to outlaw mini-skirts. Not complacent with that law, they then go on to vote that women should wear head covering. This would be acceptable to you simply because the majority voted for it?
Mike, it was difficult to muddle through your posting since everything was bold. I find it very difficult to believe that you would accept every vote of the majority but find no room to accept the need for a judiciary.
I have far more faith in the voting public than in the courts. For every Brown v Bd of Education the SCOTUS rules, there is a Plessy v Ferguson.
Or Dred Scott, which did more to keep slavery alive and led to the War Between the States than anything else.
Or Kelo v New London
Or Hamdan v Rumsfeld.
Courts have a long history of making problems worse more often than they correct problems.
As for the bold, don’t get it either. I thought the tags were correct, but I can’t go back and edit to fix it.
Let’s say, for instance, that the voters of South Carolina (your home state?) decided that women should show more modesty in their dress. Thus they passed a law by popular vote to outlaw mini-skirts. Not complacent with that law, they then go on to vote that women should wear head covering. This would be acceptable to you simply because the majority voted for it?
I’d find it deplorable and would organize to have an initiative to overturn it.
But, since there is also, literally, no chance whatsoever of it ever occurring, I’m not terribly worried, either.
It is easy to be cavalier with an issue that does not resonate with you. I still doubt your sincerity, though.
Marriage is one of the most fundamental human institutions. Can you see why those to whom you would deny it would argue vehemently against you?
Let’s clarify the issue. Were it not for the hundreds of rights that are assumed with a civil marriage contract, I doubt that gays would care one iota for the legal impramatur. Some gays might view this as a fight for acceptance by society, but I expect that most simply want the same legal rights that straight people get once married.
So you believe that you can withhold rights to some fellow Americans just because a majority say so? And you think this is fair?
Please do not spew the same crap that gay people have the same right to marry as straight people. That argument goes over like a fart in church. We are talking about the right to marry the person one loves.
It is easy to be cavalier with an issue that does not resonate with you. I still doubt your sincerity, though.
An anonymous person on the internet questioning my sincerity ranks rather low on the list of concerns in my life.
Marriage is one of the most fundamental human institutions. Can you see why those to whom you would deny it would argue vehemently against you?
And you diminish the institution by stretching its definition to absurd lengths.
Can you see why those for whom the institution is important might not like your plans?
Let’s clarify the issue. Were it not for the hundreds of rights that are assumed with a civil marriage contract, I doubt that gays would care one iota for the legal impramatur.
Hundreds?
Umm, yeah.
Some gays might view this as a fight for acceptance by society, but I expect that most simply want the same legal rights that straight people get once married.
Am I wrong to question their sincerity?
So you believe that you can withhold rights to some fellow Americans just because a majority say so? And you think this is fair?
Seeing as how marriage isn’t a right, I won’t play the game by whatever rules you deem fit.
Please do not spew the same crap that gay people have the same right to marry as straight people.
Reality can be a bitch.
That argument goes over like a fart in church.
Because your argument is emotional and not logical. If you were being logical, you’d get the argument.
But you don’t. You’re blinded by your emotion.
Emotion leads to bad law.
We are talking about the right to marry the person one loves.
Seriously, spare me the maudlin performance.
-=Mike
At this point, Mike, we are talking past each other. Clearly I will not persuade you, and you certainly will not persuade me.
I firmly believe that within our lifetimes, we will see marriage equality. As a country we have tended to move toward more freedom and more equality (albeit with occasional setbacks).
“1.Two men marrying is equal but 3 is not? How?
2.Two men and two women all getting married together is subjugatory? How?
3. Who the hell are you to tell anyone that 3 people can not get married?
(hint to everyone else besides matt and rwilymz : they won’t answer those questions with anything that makes sense. watch and see.)”
As I thought, nobody will answer these questions.
Funny, huh?
It’s not a question of ‘slippery slope’. If 2 men are allowed to ‘marry’, then there is no logical reason not to allow 3 men to marry.
“Whether it’s OK or not is irrelevant, since it is their country to do with what they wish. We as Americans have no control over that.”
HITLER WON AN ELECTION. What kind of person are you? I’ve been accused of moral relativism for urging calm when dealing with psychos with nuclear weapons. You’re clearly a relativist, though, which is morally indefensible.
“Yes, again, because replacing property for love as a reason for marriage is SO much less drastic than, oh, replacing the need for the opposite sex.”
IT IS! There is no *need* for the opposite sex within marriage, because procreation could occur as it does in the Handmaid’s Tale, or even in test tubes. (Neither hold any appeal to me, except to demonstrate that marriage is unnecessary for the survival of the human species.) [Marriage as loving bond] is VERY different from [marriage as one-way contract (wife can’t opt out, and has very few rights)]; whereas [marriage as loving bond between a man and a woman] is so similar to [marriage as loving bond between a man and a woman, or two of each] that I can’t even believe you made me address this point again. You’re just being stubborn. As for the “fundamental aspects” of marriage: do you mean a man’s right to beat his wife with a stick no wider than his thumb? Stop being a traditionalist! You want to talk about a lack of logic? Well, what kind of logic is “because that’s the way it’s always been done!”? It’s not logic, it’s an emotional appeal to tradition. Bill O’Reilly is a traditionalist, and he’s a very stupid man. Again: do better!
“And you diminish the institution by stretching its definition to absurd lengths.”
How does letting gay people get married cheapen the idea of marriage for you? Marriage isn’t like Harvard Law School, where you get to brag about the credential based on its exclusivity. If you like the idea of marriage, you should have no problem with the SCOTUS letting every consenting adult enter into a lifetime partnership based on love and devotion. (The current legal alternatives are not available in all states, and lack the sanctity of the institution of marriage, so don’t try that route.)
“Am I wrong to question their sincerity?”
To question the sincerity of an entire movement that is demanding equality in the eyes of the law: yes, you are. Suggest an alterior motive, because I can’t even imagine one. Marriage is expensive, and so is divorce, so you can’t cash it out in terms of economic gains. Some mouth-breathers in the Bible Belt actually might actually believe that The Gay is trying to take over the world, and that being allowed to get married somehow plays an integral part in their scheme, but you’re smarter than that. People questioned the motives of First-Wave feminists and civil rights activists, but history has shown those insincere sceptics to be complete and utter douche bags.
And I know you know you’ve lost this argument. You’re being ridiculous, Mike. Gay marriage advocates cannot win support in the public forum, so they have to get the courts to impose it on people, which will lead to gradual public acceptance, as it did with bi-racial marriages and no-fault divorce. Don’t like things being imposed on you? Well, don’t get born in a developed nation next time.
And I don’t claim to be in the mainstream. I’m proud that I’m not, actually. Have you heard some of the shit Americans will believe? And the piece of shit movies they’ll pay to see? But creationists in the Bible Belt aren’t in the mainstream either. They’re a vocal minority who only care about imposing their morals on other people and I’d be happy to see them all go live in a giant bunker in Utah or Alabama or wherever and leave us folks who aren’t afraid of Spongebob Squarepants’ ambiguous sexuality here to deal with the Armageddon.
And all of your examples of the SCOTUS issuing immoral, fucked-up judgements are extremely dated. Hamdan vs. Rumsfeld isn’t, but it’s not in the same ballpark as Dred Scott. It’s a different issue, one that both sides can debate. The difference here is that rather than argue both sides empirically and/or ideologically, hardening the trenches, and then shaking hands (or hocking loogies) and walking away from the battlefield, you’ve been routed. I’m done rebutting every single point you feel like trying to make. Conservatives reading this thread either went away because there is nothing left to be said or they agree with those of us who accept the logic of same-sex marriage advocates. You’ve made it very clear that you don’t like the SCOTUS stepping in and righting the ship, and that’s fine, but I suggest you go start your own country where the majority has an unqualified right to exert its influence. You can’t accept the distinction between 1) majority rule buttressed by court checks and 2) an oligarchy, so I’m done with this issue. Take a deep breath and re-read a lot of this thread, because I think that you and other opponents of same-sex marriage have made as good a case as possible against it and lost the argument beyond a shadow of a doubt. Remember it when the SCOTUS forces Congress to respect gay couples’ wishes in the near future.
Les, it’s not a logical reason, but a moral one. And anyway I replied to your shitty slippery slope argument. (Search for “Don Juan”.) You guys got smacked down pretty hard, but it’s not your fault. It’s an issue that same-sex marriage advocates cannot lose in principle, so it’s a matter of time before that homophobe Scalia and his sidekick Clarence are replaced by people from this generation. It’s an issue of equality in the eyes of the law, and same-sex couples don’t have to earn your approval or defeat your lightweight attempt at ethical reasoning to deserve it. They have to persuade 5 out of 9 very well-versed legal scholars. America: love it, or leave it.
Let’s retire this thread before Les starts bringing up beastiality and people marrying their own eight-year-old children.