That’s what Assemblywoman Barbara Lifton (D-125th District) is proposing in the wake of the New York high court’s decision that the state constitution does not recognize same sex marriage.
“Let’s get government out of the wedding business and have everyone, equally, have a civil arrangement,” she said.
The proposal Lifton supports would replace the word “marriage” with “civil commitment” in state laws, creating a legal contract she said would be accessible to everyone, while leaving the religious aspect of the union to religious institutions.
“Why should state government become a religious institution?” she asked.
Ms. Lifton makes her idea sound so simple: it’s just replacing one word with another, that’s all. But it’s much more than that. It fundamentally turns the institution of marriage, the union of a man and a woman before God and man, into nothing but an impersonal and emotionless legal contract akin to a business transaction. In other words, if gays can’t marry, then no one can.
Stanley Kurtz at The Corner responds to Ms. Lifton’s proposal:
And as we’ve seen with [Michael] Kinsley and [Jonathan] Turley, if we’re no longer talking about “marriage,” multi-partner “civil commitments” will surely follow. In any case, it wouldn’t take multi-partner unions to make the abolition of civil marriage a disaster. Just removing public support for marriage as an institution would be damaging enough.
This proposal has no chance of passage right now. Yet it’s a clear sign that as same-sex marriage spreads, more and more people (including traditionally religious opponents of gay marriage), will begin to look to the abolition of civil marriage as a “solution.” This is the reality of what same-sex marriage has brought: not a strengthening of traditional marriage, but calls for its abolition.
Indeed.
Added: If this proposal were to pass, does that mean that a New York man will no longer propose marriage to a woman, but he will instead propose a civil commitment? Just imagine that scene: the man and woman are at a posh, romantic New York restaurant. He gets on one knee, presents her with a beautiful diamond ring, looks lovingly into his girlfriend’s eyes and asks, “will you enter into a civil commitment with me?”
You may think I’m being ridiculous, but considering how the PC crowd has had quite a bit of success removing politically incorrect language (Merry Christmas) and behavior (praying in public school or any mention of God in public school) from public life, the passage of a proposal like Ms. Lifton’s would give the PC thought police ammunition to work toward eliminating any mention of the word marriage from public discourse. Since marriage would no longer exist, the phrase “we’re getting married” would be labeled “outdated and bigoted,” not to mention meanspirited toward gay civilly committed couples because, as long as the term marriage was still used, it could cause them to feel like second class citizens. Instead the traditional institution of marriage would be relegated to people’s homes and churches, absent from public life.
It may sound crazy right now, but I can see the moonbat left pulling something like this.



All that this proposal will do is place the “before God” portion of this institution back into the church, where it belongs.
Even if Ms Lifton is serious, the civil institution still has to be defined.
If there is nothing “special” about the gender of the people involved, then what’s so special about the number? Or the familial relationship between the members petitioning?
If there is nothing “special” about the gender of the people involved, then what’s so special about the number? Or the familial relationship between the members petitioning?
The specialness is manifest in the equality of application.
Common Law has dictated “two”; gays want only equal application.
I think it was cowardly and craven for two courts to wash their hands of Equal Protection enforcement, throwing it back to legislatures, when then didn’t in the 60s.
From the civil point of view, and I’m sure Darleen will correct me here, that’s the only real reason that the government is involved, because it is a civil contract between a man and a woman, currently.
No where in a marriage license does it specify what religion you have to be or if you even have to be a religious person, to get a marriage license. Religion does not enter into the equation, from the government side of things.
It’s purely a contractural arrangement, and as cold and impersonal as that may seem, it appears that way to me. Speaking as someone who has been through the ending of a marriage and experienced the “settlement of the contract terms” as it was.
rwilymz
Common law dictated one man/one woman … and?
You’re arguing in circles. Either The People can define a public institution or they cannot. If they cannot then the institution cannot limit itself by another other than age of participants (minors cannot contract).
I’m only shocked that there are still some commonsense judges in NY.
Not surprised that the NYTimes is wringing their hands…when the Left sez “power to the people” they don’t really mean it.
Religious people should be able to have whatever kind of religious marriage in whatever church they want, but it doesn’t make any sense for a religious sacrament to be codified within state policy. (Especially a secular state like the United States.) I completely support the idea that marriage licenses be replaced by some other legal document, while allowing every religion to perform whatever ceremonial rights they want and excluding whomever they please.
Kurtz’s empirical arguments about the effects of the liberalization of the institution of marriage are half-baked, unsurprising since most of his recent data comes from Holland. (Ba-doom-ching!) Birth rates might decline–oh no! We need more human beings!!! I think his “research” is motivated by a racist concern over the dramatic change in the racial make-up of the U.S.. He, out all the writers of the National Review excluding Jay Nordlinger, deserves the least attention.
DavidB
Even more than not asking religion, they don’t even ask sexual orientation or about love. ANY two adults, not family related, can get a civil marriage license, as long as it is two adults of opposite sex.
If same-sex marriage is to happen in our society it has to come from ss advocates persuading the majority of their fellow citizens it is in societies best interest to redefine the institution.
NO ONE is interferring with same-sex couples from privately taking all the legal avenues open to them to grant guardianship, set up inheritance, set up medical PoA, etc.
Matt
what is “racist” about worrying about the devaluation of family and children?
To paraphase Robert Heinlein, when a society rejects the moral imperative of “women and children first” it is doomed to extinction.
Darleen, the people get it wrong a lot of the time. The people opposed the legalization of bi-racial marriages. Thank goodness the judge who struck down that idiotic prohibition was smarter than the masses.
What is right, and what is wrong, is open to interpretation, but it ought not, and CANnot, be considered a popularity contest. People’s opinions, and people’s actual interests, are divergent in a very important sense.
It fundamentally turns the institution of marriage, the union of a man and a woman before God and man, into nothing but an impersonal and emotionless legal contract akin to a business transaction.
And here is the crux of the issue, from the perspective of the state, this is the only interest it has, the contractual dimension and the benefits that contract provides.
All religions have different standards that they impose on marriage. There are people who are married legally as far as the state is concerned that are not recognized by the Catholic Church. As far as the RCC is concerned any one who was not married under their auspices is not married.
Now my question is, should the state go to the Roman Catholic dioceses of the United States and tell then that since the US government recognizes married couples joined without the blessing of the Church that they should be forced to recognize those marriages as well? Of course not, the separation between the religious and civil aspects have been well understood since the founding of the country.
Since the state has no interest in what religious organizations do WRT marriage then any input from religious institutions on the conditions for marriage have no standing under the law. A church can marry any two people, they can call them married but the civil part will not be recognized by the state.
So what we are talking about with marriage as far as the state is concerned has nothing to do with the traditional aspects of the institution, the states interest begins and ends with only the civil contractual part of it. You could easily craft a domestic partnership law that would have no overt sexual aspect involved for say two same sex elderly people that want to join in a relationship with each other for their mutual protection in their golden years. These people might not be in a sexual relationship of any kind.
There is no reason not to extend the right to any two people who want to be in a legally recognized relationship. People in the same family have no need to marry because they are already related and that relationship is recognized by the state, marriage would be redundant. Well other then to make a big political culture war fight out of it.
Hmmmm.
Then we’ll have:
1. Multiple partner civil unions.
2. “Line” contracts.
This is where new partners are added to an existing civil unions.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Line_marriage
3. Then we’ll also have *Time* based civil unions.
This is where you agree to love, cherish and all that stuff for 4 years with an option to extend for another 2 years if some specified targets have been met.
…
Frankly the only people who’ll gain anything from this crap are:
A. gays.
B. polygamists.
C. Dirty old men looking to “marry” 18 y/o girls in short term civil union contracts with escape clauses. Considering that I’m slowly entering into this demographic let’s keep this one on ice for the moment just in case.
Joy. Let’s see what else we can collecively turn into crap.
Common law dictated one man/one woman … and?
Common law was superceded by statutory. History. Not just for high school graduation.
You’re arguing in circles.
That’s certainly news.
Either The People can define a public institution or they cannot.
No one suggested otherwise, did they?
The answer is “no, they did not, and I just made a false assumption by insinuating it.”
If they cannot then the institution cannot limit itself by another other than age of participants (minors cannot contract).
More history for yuz: We The People didn’t define “marriage” as “man – woman – one each” in more than about 1/3 of the states until about 10 years ago. So … technically … in most states, two guys could go down to the county clerk’s office and get a marriage license, and nothing under the law could have been done to prevent it. “Assumption” isn’t a legal basis for anything except getting yourself into trouble.
I’m only shocked that there are still some commonsense judges in NY.
Yeah? Which one’s that?
Not surprised that the NYTimes is wringing their hands…when the Left sez “power to the people” they don’t really mean it.
“Power to the Poeple” of the same sort in the 60s would have left blacks in the back of the bus, wouldn’t it have?
The answer to that is, of course, “Why, yes it would have; darn, you caught me being a superficial hypocrite yet again.”
There are still several states where the laws do not require a marriage license be gotten for a man and woman. In those states, if a clerk denies a license to two women, technically he is in violation of the law.
And that has nothing to do with the Constitutional argument that gays are the only people [here, as regards this specific aspect of property and contract law] to be left out of Equal Protection.
The issue is, for the simple-minded, We The People have every authority to define social and contractual institutions, but those institutions cannot deny the participation of everyone who chooses to participate. Equal Protection was so important that we put it in the Constitutino twice.
…devaluation of family and children?
What about letting two men or women get married devalues family and children in a way that 50% divorce rates among heterosexuals doesn’t?
While I agree that kids should have two parents the fact is that the biggest offenders at creating single parent famlies are hetrosexuals, the gays have nothing to do with it, letting them marry will not change anything in the hetrosexual world.
Then we’ll have:
1. Multiple partner civil unions.
2. “Line” contracts.
3. Then we’ll also have *Time* based civil unions.
1] only if laws are created forming them; allowing gays to participate in currently-existing laws won’t accomplish this.
2] only if laws are create forming them; allowing gays to participate in currently-existing laws won’t accomplish this.
3] we already have this; it’s called “no-fault divorce”.
Multiple partner civil unions.
You mean like the ones in the bible? I thought you all wanted to return to the traditional notion of marriage.
Sorry Darleen, our last posts crossed. My bad!
Well, last I checked Heinlein wasn’t an evolutionary psychologist OR an anthropologist, so I don’t see your point.
I find Kurtz to be racist, because I think he would still be up in arms if (hypothetically) people of European/Semitic heritage stopped having kids entirely, while all of the Hispanic, Asian, and African people subsequently replaced them with non-white offspring.
I’m glad that there are men and women who reproduce. They will still be doing so long after the Supreme Court has recognized gay marriage, or replaced the word ‘marriage’ with ‘civil union’ within the law. All of the evidence that suggests gay people make worse parents is bunk; and even if gay people were more likely to have gay children, which is a tenuous claim, that wouldn’t be relevant because being gay is perfectly normal.
If Kurtz cares so much about the family, he should investigate the crazy divorce rate amongst Congresspeople, especially Republicans.
Why is there a marriage restriction on family members “tying the knot”? If the word “marriage” is to be redefined from it’s traditional meaning then why can’t it mean anything the happy couple wants it to mean.
In fact, why just a couple? Marriage contracts don’t say anything about couples, does it? Why can’t all of my neighbors join each other in {Holy [redacted]} Matrimony. I think I’d like to marry my golden retriever; oh, wait, I haven’t got one; but if I did I’m marry her (or him).
And if we can have this much fun redefining “marriage” think how much fun we could have with “liberty” “privacy” “Right to Life, (Liberty & Happiness).” Pretty soon we’d be just like the pigs in “Animal Farm.” Or would we be in a predicament more like the other animals and be at the mercy of the pigs?
Matt
The laws against “mix-raced” marriages were not widespread, had little American historical precedence and the biological myth of “race” is in no way equivalent to gender.
Biologically and legally, men and women are different.
Understand, I AM in support of extending the public institution of marriage to include same-sex couples…but ONLY when it comes from a consensus of my fellow citizens and I will fight HARD against any attempt to designate same-sex marriage a “right” newly discovered by the judiciary. The implications for society and law are much more far reaching than people realize, or “same-sex marriage as a RIGHT” advocates will publicly admit.
Why is there a marriage restriction on family members “tying the knot”?
Because from a civil standpoint “marriage” is joining two unrelated people into a legally recognized relationship, marrying your sister is redundant; you’re already related in the eyes of the law.
Rick
Monogamy was a huge step forward in the rights of women.
Why should anyone wish a return to society with “women as chattel” to be bartered and numbered like prize cows?
“right” newly discovered by the judiciary.
All unenumerated rights were “discovered” by the judiciary including the right to free association, the right of corporations to be a “legal person” under the law, the right to have the bill of rights apply to individuals and override state law.
Read the ninth amendment to the constitution, it was out in there by the founders on purpose.
For thousands of years, the established definition of the word “marriage” has been one man and one woman.
Gays have the right to create a similar tradition that would grant them exactly the same legal status from the government – but they DON’T have the right to come in and redefine what the word “marriage” already means to people who are already married and hold the concept of marriage sacred.
After all, if someone came along and wanted the established definition of the word “Gay” to suddenly be changed to include pedophilia and beastiality, I’m sure Gay people would fight like hell to stop it.
This is what married people are fighting for now. Gays DON’T have a right to impose their beliefs on other people by changing what marriage means. They need to go do their own thing, start their own tradition, under their own terminology, and leave other people’s traditions alone.
Rick
But a brother/sister relationship doesn’t automatically confer the legal benefits that being spouse would add.
Again, YOU are drawing an arbitrary line at unrelated people, other people draw the arbitrary line at number, currently the line is number, gender, family relationship.
It is not incumbent upon the status quo to prove its position, it is incumbent upon the challengers to persuade those of the status quo to change.
Remember (since Matt decided to bring “race” into this) .. that it was moral persuasion that allowed the success of the Civil Rights movement.
I’ve yet to see a convincing argument as to why the state should be involved in personal relationships period. Marriage, as far as the state is concerned, is simply a legal contract. Marriage, as far as the church is concerned, is more than a legal contract.
My primary concern, should the state decide that marriage (the legal contract) be availabe to anyone, is that certain groups will try to use the courts to force the churchs’ participation (e.g. using their tax exempt status as leverage).
– MikeB
Monogamy was a huge step forward in the rights of women.
So then you are in favor of changing the institution of marriage when it suits you personally? Interesting, that is exactly how gay people feel.
No I don’t give a whit about the “traditional” notion of marriage. How other people live dosen’t effect me. But the specter of polygamy gets trotted out all the time in the “gay marriage” debate and I find it ironic that one argument is that marriage has been “unchanged for 1000’s of years yet you all seem to be OK with one of the major changes that was made to the institution.
The laws against “mix-raced” marriages were not widespread
By “not widespread” you probably mean “ubiquitous”.
At one time or another, every state had de facto laws or de jure practice against “miscegenation”.
…the biological myth of “race” is in no way equivalent to gender.
So because “gender” =/= race” the concept of Equal Protection does not apply?
You aren’t serious, are you?
Biologically and legally, men and women are different.
Biologically, in many ways, legally, in only a few.
Yet … Equal Protection is supposed to apply regardless.
Understand, I AM in support of extending the public institution of marriage to include same-sex couples…but ONLY when it comes from a consensus of my fellow citizens
Then you shouldn’t be quibbling, because that consensus is already achieved. See the 5th and 14th Amendments, and the words “Equal Protection”. Now, I will grant that this is one of those unforeseen applications of same that may be hard to swallow for some — or even most. But the consensus has declared, not once but twice, that We the People are to be treated equally, and given the same opportunities.
I will fight HARD against any attempt to designate same-sex marriage a “right” newly discovered by the judiciary.
Were you equally obstinate about the “newly discovered” “rights” of blacks? or women?
The implications for society and law are much more far reaching than people realize, or “same-sex marriage as a RIGHT” advocates will publicly admit.
Such as?
Gays will be forced to hire divorce lawyers before splitting up the goldfish?
Rick
Again… civil marriage is a public institution in which people contract. Parameters which define contracts are not about “rights” but about what the State considers in the best interests of citizens it is charged with protecting. Thus we have laws governing landlord/tenant relationships, business partnerships, etc. Two consenting adults cannot make a contract where one sells him/herself to another in slavery in return for forgiveness of debt.
But Darleen, the achievements of the Civil Rights movement would have been no less praiseworthy had EVERY SINGLE AMERICAN opposed them! Morality is not dictated by mob rule!
Please explain what the “far-reaching” implications for society would be, were gay marriage to be legalized (or marriage scrubbed from the law). Empirical evidence would be nice. Slippery slope arguments are unsound, as rwilmyz explained above. Why should anybody care? The “family” has never been a static concept, especially not as described in religious scripture (not that I care about scripture, but I suspect you might).
For thousands of years, the established definition of the word “marriage” has been one man and one woman.
Sorry to be pedantic here, but I must; there’s too many others attempting to be pedantic to not return the, um, “favor”.
For “thousands of years” there was no word “marriage”. “Marriage” is an English word, and English, as we understand it today, wasn’t spoken before, roughly, the 1500s. Avail yourselves of dictionary.com to find the etymology.
Additionally, “for thousand of years” the United States of America didn’t exist, and laws of same had no meaning since they, frankly, didn’t exist.
We are talking about a US Law thing here, and that only goes back 230 years — almost to the day. [223 years, if you want to get really pedantic and start from the time of US creation by the Treaty of Paris and international recognition which came from it].
But, since we’re talking US law, and US state law at that — the feds still largely absolve themselves of marriage — it wasn’t until the last decade that states started legally defining marriage as “one man one woman”. Most states had vague definitions of “marriage”.
“Thousands of years” is wholly irrelevant to the issue.
Let’s see if this comment survives today…
rwil
Are you really saying there are no differences between men and women?
Should gender-specific public restrooms be banned? Gender specific gyms and the lockerrooms within? How about gender specific schools, camps, organizations?
If same-sex marriage is a “right”, what do you want to do to churches that preach the homosexual act is a “sin”? Lose their tax exempt status? What about schools they run, or facilities that host Little league teams?
The US military is a public institution that grants special benefits unavailable to people who don’t join AND the instition discriminates (original meaning of the word) on who gets to join ALL THE TIME. Is that a violation of equal protection?
Because the institution of marriage defines parameters for participation and grants benefits unavailable, does that mean it is a violation of equal protection that a single person cannot get those benefits? Three people? Six?
Stop conflating “equal protection” which deals with individuals with a CONTRACT.
Darlene you can’t possibly be so clueless as to say this: civil marriage is a public institution in which people contract. Parameters which define contracts are not about “rights” but about what the State considers in the best interests of citizens it is charged with protecting.
You are, at once, declaring gays to be incompetent to marry [i.e., in need of legal protection from the civil institution of marriage], and utterly in denial about a citizens freedom to contract — one of those 9th amendment court-created things you are going to fight tooth and nail to deny everyone.
rwi
US law didn’t spring whole, like Athena from Zeus’ head, it is based on English Common Law (which in itself was a formal codification of common rules towards the goal of consistency and unification)
Amazingly, on one hand ss-as-right advocates want to cite precedence when it comes to race, but don’t want anyone else to use precedence when they point out that no major western society in history has allowed same-sex marriage.
Are your arguments so poor about the societal benefits of including same-sex couples in family statutes you have to keep flogging the risible “ss as right” line instead of the legitimate course of getting the majority of the country to agree?
Please do not overlook that much of our law and judicial precedent stems from English Common Law (which has been around awhile…). As a citation, Marbury v Madison cites Blackstone and the laws of England.
rwi
where did I declare gays incompetent to marry?
Do NOT lie about what I am stating.
Gays can marry today. As long as the person they are marrying is the opposite sex. The State’s requirements to contract in the institution of marriage do NOT include any question of sexual orientation or romance.
Does the State have the obligation to define the parameters of landlord/tenant contracts? Should the State be require to enforce ANY contract between any consenting adults?
Darlene can’t get the point: Are you really saying there are no differences between men and women?
What KIND of differences? Physical? or legal? Do not not not equivocate around me, ever. Physical differences — me having a schlong and you having a cooter — does not imbue either of us with a presumption of LEGAL differences.
Should gender-specific public restrooms be banned?
Do not not not equivocate around me, ever. If you can point out the relevance, I will address it. Until then, you are red herring-ing.
Gender specific gyms and the lockerrooms within?
See above.
How about gender specific schools, camps, organizations?
See above.
If same-sex marriage is a “right”, what do you want to do to churches that preach the homosexual act is a “sin”?
Freedom of speech is also a right. You want to subordinate one 1stAm right under another?
Lose their tax exempt status? What about schools they run, or facilities that host Little league teams?
See above.
The US military is a public institution that grants special benefits unavailable to people who don’t join AND the instition discriminates (original meaning of the word) on who gets to join ALL THE TIME. Is that a violation of equal protection?
Frankly, yes. Gays ought to be able to join the military as well.
Because the institution of marriage defines parameters for participation and grants benefits unavailable, does that mean it is a violation of equal protection that a single person cannot get those benefits?
One person already has the pertinent property rights that are shared by act of marriage. So the example is meaningless.
Three people? Six?
No matter how dishonestly you wish to discuss this subject, the issue is not “Three people” nor is it “six”. It is two. Gays wish to be afforded the same rights to join that civil institution created for two that the rest of us enjoy.
If you wish to see “three people” marriages, then petition your lawmakers. But when it happens, you cannot deny the three person marriage to three men OR three women without running into Equal Protection.
Why is this so difficult for you to comprehend?
Again… civil marriage is a public institution in which people contract.
Darleen … sure no quarrel. But we do have the right to enter into contracts, unless of course your two men who want to avail themselves of civil marriage. So now you ahve to explain why two men should not be able to make the same contract aman and a woman can. Are there any other contracts where the sex of the participance are an issue?
Also : If same-sex marriage is a “right”, what do you want to do to churches that preach the homosexual act is a “sin”?
There are many things that are a sin under church law that are not against the laws of the states. Co-habitation is one; sex outside of marriage is another. Unless the are people who are being successfully prosecuted for calling co-habitation sinners then I don’t think you have much of an argument. Right now you are not married as far as the RCC is concerned if you were not married with the blessing of the RCC, is there anyone suggesting that the RCC should be forced recognize all marriage even if it does not conform to their religious beliefs?
Stop conflating “equal protection” which deals with individuals with a CONTRACT.
Why the equal protection he is talking abtou is the right to enter into the contract in question.
Dancing around citing “State Rights” and “Civil Rights” and “Constutional Rights” is skirting the issue.
The issue, plainly and simply, is that the Christian Right wants to force their church’s definition of marriage onto everyone — gays, straights, Jews, Mormons, Catholics, etc.
Suggesting otherwise is ignoring the elephant in the living room.
Darlene continues to astound:
Amazingly, on one hand ss-as-right advocates want to cite precedence when it comes to race, but don’t want anyone else to use precedence when they point out that no major western society in history has allowed same-sex marriage.
I’m unsure what you mean by “ss” here. Probably not the Nazi secret police.
Equality trancending race is a relatively recent invention as well, so you’re going to get nowhere arguing that racial equality is ancient. … if that’s what you’re getting at.
Are your arguments so poor about the societal benefits of including same-sex couples in family statutes you have to keep flogging the risible “ss as right” line instead of the legitimate course of getting the majority of the country to agree?
I’ve never argued posit#1 about any “societal benefits” of same-sex marriage. You, on the other hand, have alluded to societal anti-benefits that I haven’t seen you define. What might they be? You’re argument isn’t that poor that you can’t fill it out, is it?
And frankly, the “societal benefit” of striking down anti-miscegenation laws by court fiat rather than popular legislative deliberation are rather empty as well, since the only “benefit” is that it made a handful of couples happy and millions UNhappy. Striking down anti-gay marriage laws would have the same effect, frankly. It’s a wash either way.
where did I declare gays incompetent to marry?
Right here:
Rick
Again… civil marriage is a public institution in which people contract. Parameters which define contracts are not about “rights” but about what the State considers in the best interests of citizens it is charged with protecting. Thus we have laws governing landlord/tenant relationships, business partnerships, etc. Two consenting adults cannot make a contract where one sells him/herself to another in slavery in return for forgiveness of debt.
Posted by: Darleen at July 7, 2006 02:04 PM
You are declaring that there is no “right to contract” [in denial of a whole passel of case law], and that contract law is set up to prevent certain types of contracts in deference to those of us it is protecting. I.e., gays need protecting from the right to enter a marriage contract; which means they are incomptent to marry.
Now, “incompetent” is a legal term, and you should probably be aware of its legal meaning before you deign to lecture at Harvard Law School. …or lecture me, either. But you just said that gays are incompetent to marry. They need “protecting”. Like children.
Do NOT lie about what I am stating.
Don’t worry; I didn’t.
Gays can marry today.
Yeah? Who? Not the people they want to marry. And this is the same argument the state of Virginia made in 1965 or whenever they were justifying their miscegenation laws: “Blacks and whites can both marry — just not each other.”
Does the State have the obligation to define the parameters of landlord/tenant contracts? Should the State be require to enforce ANY contract between any consenting adults?
We’ve already gone over this, and you’ve shown yourself to be a dishonest discusser. The state can make any laws it wants to; it simply has to enforce them equally. The law prevents a rich white man from contracting himself as a slave the same as it does a poor black woman. It allws heterosexuals to marry the person they want. But not homosexuals.
Do you get it yet?
“Instead the traditional institution of marriage would be relegated to people’s homes and churches, absent from public life.”
As it should be.
Lee: “The issue, plainly and simply, is that the Christian Right wants to force their church’s definition of marriage onto everyone — gays, straights, Jews, Mormons, Catholics, etc.”
huh?
FORCE their definition?? The “Christian Right” (and a whole lot of non-Christian, non-Conservative folks) are not FORCING anything. They are DEFENDING against those who ARE attempting to FORCE a change in the historical and societal norm.
Period.
Not in all cases, it doesn’t.
Does anyone really need to be told that Lee is a superficial weenie?
While “the right” is against gay marriage by something like 3- or 4-1, “the left” is also against gay marriage by 3-2. Labelling this as a “religious right against sane sensitivity” is as dishonest as anything else.
Frankly, conservative rightists ought to be in favor of gay marriage since marriage is both a financial and productivity enhancer; married people live longer, use fewer public resources per capita, earn more money, pay more taxes, vote more often, etc. http://home.gwu.edu/~dcr7/marriage_meth_4.pdf
The more people getting married, the better off the nation is. [the more people staying married, too, but let’s forego the no-fault divorce issue for now].
Oh, but gay marriage is different, because it’s just so icky! And a queasy stomach is more important an issue than anything else …
To add a thick layer of substance…
You ever see a freestyle rap-battle? If not, when someone lays a verbal smack-down on their ‘opponent’, everyone standing around the ring hoots and hollers and yells things like “Oh SNAP! You got SERVED!” while waving their hands at funny angles. Same deal with breakdancing battles.
Point is, I totally did that after reading rwilymz absolutely demolish the “arguments” against gay marriage. Then he nailed it at the end of his post @ 3:26: it’s not about tradition. It’s not about the family. It’s about the butts. It’s unnatural (although the Greeks managed okay). Jerry Falwell said as much on Crossafire once: “The plubming just don’t work!” Portray him and Dobson as radical fringe clerics if you want, but they speak for a large group of people who care about this issue more than everybody else, the same people who expect the frickin’ Rapture to happen sometime. The CRAZY people. Why should anybody care what they think?
What was with the remark about “sin”, Darleen? What place does that have in a discussion of the legal status of anything? And so what if God hates fags? He also hates shrimp!: http://www.godhatesshrimp.com (no html skills, sorry about the non-linked link).
Sorry about chirping at you earlier, rwilymz. You’re pretty damn good at this. Lawyer?
Sorry … rwilymz. You’re pretty damn good at this. Lawyer?
No. Have familiy in law.
I don’t equate sentimentality with rationality. Both have their place, but they aren’t interchangeable.
The subject here is the ability of a 1-to-3% section of our population to avail themselves of a civil contract/institution the same as the other 97-to-99% of the population … in a society that is built upon equal treatment under the law.
I understand some people find it troubling, some disgusting, some outright scandalous. Same thing was thought 40 years ago when black males [eeeeeek!!] wanted to marry white females — and vice versa. A few people liked it, almost everybody hated it, [“troubling”, “disgusting”, “scandalous”] and our courts had no problem finding it within their authority at that time to enforce the Constitution upon the state.
Why they can’t find that authority now [“I know we left it around here somewhere …”] is beyond me.
The issue is NOT multiple-party marriages, polygamy, polyandry, legalized bestiality, anything else. The issue is: 1-3% want to have the same ability to make use of a law that the other 97-99% use everyday. The same law, not a different one.
It does no good to make the discussion into something it isn’t.
I hate Homophobes, who oppose ‘equal’ marriages between gay couples .
I hate Numberists, who oppose ‘equal’ marriages between 3 people.
rwilymz is just a filthy goddamned Numberist, no better than a racist or a homophobe or a sexist.
Who the hell does he think he is, telling us that 3 people can’t marry? What gives him the right?
Nobody has the right to tell me that 2 is legal but 4 or 5 or whatever is not.
Right?
Les, for wilfully ignoring the multiple times he trounced the slippery slope objection, you demonstrate yourself to be lazy and pigheaded. Or maybe you read it and you didn’t understand it. You can pick.
Legalizing gay marriage will not open the floodgates and wash away social norms, turning morality into an anything-goes Mad Max free-for-all. The same reasons for opposing beastiality (animals cannot consent) and polygamy (said relationships are inherently unequal and subjugatory) will apply whether or not Bert and Ernie can finally tie the knot.
I’ve yet to see any democrats or liberal organizations campaigning in favor of the constitutional amendment banning gay marriages. There are plenty of conservative church groups up in arms over this issue, and actively campaigning however.
Public opinion, and organized opposition, are two entirely difffent things. The organized opposition against gay marriages is principally from the religous right.
I think it was cowardly and craven for two courts to wash their hands of Equal Protection enforcement, throwing it back to legislatures, when then didn’t in the 60s.
Your argument is fundamentally flawed.
Interracial marriage did not permit men to marry women.
Gay marriage DOES allow men to marry women.
There is no equal protection argument to make here.
I think his “research” is motivated by a racist concern over the dramatic change in the racial make-up of the U.S.
When you can’t debate the point, just smear the person. Nice tactic.
Ignoring that one of the fundamental reason for governments to recognize women is to assist with parenting.
What is right, and what is wrong, is open to interpretation, but it ought not, and CANnot, be considered a popularity contest.
Except that is precisely what you advocate.
Just with a ridiculously small pool of people making the decision.
What about letting two men or women get married devalues family and children in a way that 50% divorce rates among heterosexuals doesn’t?
It’s ironic that many of the same groups who championed “no fault” divorces are now condemning the long-predicted huge problems that the “no fault” divorce caused.
It takes chutzpah to pass rules to deeply damage an institution — and then to use the damage that they helped cause to justify FURTHER damaging of the institution.
“Power to the Poeple” of the same sort in the 60s would have left blacks in the back of the bus, wouldn’t it have?
“Power to the people” would have also freed the slaves without the War Between the States.
SCOTUS kept slavery alive.
1] only if laws are created forming them; allowing gays to participate in currently-existing laws won’t accomplish this.
Feel free to provide ANY instance in which legalizing gay marriage WON’T cause these to occur.
Because from a civil standpoint “marriage” is joining two unrelated people into a legally recognized relationship, marrying your sister is redundant; you’re already related in the eyes of the law.
Says who?
If equal protection covers two men marrying each other, it also covers a dad and his daughter marrying.
What KIND of differences? Physical? or legal? Do not not not equivocate around me, ever. Physical differences — me having a schlong and you having a cooter — does not imbue either of us with a presumption of LEGAL differences.
Darleen can abort an unwanted child.
If you have an unwanted child, you have to support it.
Thus, a legal difference.
Freedom of speech is also a right. You want to subordinate one 1stAm right under another?
It routinely is subordinate to the 14th Amendment.
Notice how you aren’t allowed to advertise “Blacks need not apply”?
Yeah? Who? Not the people they want to marry.
You have no right to marry whomever you want.
They have to say yes.
If your girl says “no”, your rights were very much not violated.
You seem to mistake something “legal” for a “right”.
Marriage is as much a right as smoking.
We’ve already gone over this, and you’ve shown yourself to be a dishonest discusser. The state can make any laws it wants to; it simply has to enforce them equally.
Marriage between a man and a woman is very much enforced equally. Whether you LIKE that equality or not is more than a little irrelevant.
If you wish to change that — there is a well-known mechanism to go about it.
-=Mike
nd polygamy (said relationships are inherently unequal and subjugatory)
Feel free to explain how.
If the man and the women (since it never seems to be a woman with multiple men) say they want it — who are YOU to say they don’t warrant it?
You willing to sell out your argument?
-=Mike