The president called the Times’ report detailing the terrorist banking records program “disgraceful.”
President Bush on Monday sharply condemned the disclosure of a program to secretly monitor the financial transactions of suspected terrorists. “The disclosure of this program is disgraceful,” he said.
“For people to leak that program and for a newspaper to publish it does great harm to the United States of America,” Bush said, jabbing his finger for emphasis. He said the disclosure of the program “makes it harder to win this war on terror.”
The program has been going on since shortly after the Sept. 11, 2001, terror attacks. It was disclosed last week by the New York Times, the Wall Street Journal and the Los Angeles Times.
Using broad government subpoenas, the program allows U.S. counterterrorism analysts to obtain financial information from a vast database maintained by a company based in Belgium. It routes about 11 million financial transactions daily among 7,800 banks and other financial institutions in 200 countries.
“Congress was briefed and what we did was fully authorized under the law,” Bush said, talking with reporters in the Roosevelt Room after meeting with groups that support U.S. troops in Iraq.
“We’re at war with a bunch of people who want to hurt the United States of America,” the president said. “What we were doing was the right thing.”
“The American people expect this government to protect our constitutional liberties and at the same time make sure we understand what the terrorists are trying to do,” Bush said. He said that to figure out what terrorists plan to do, “You try to follow their money. And that’s exactly what we’re doing and the fact that a newspaper disclosed it makes it harder to win this war on terror.”
Watch the video of President Bush making these statements. He is justifiably angry. The Times has tried to undermine his national security efforts over and over again: first with the disclosure of the NSA terrorist surveillance program, then the phone records database program, and now the terrorist finance tracking operation.
As we have already heard, the Times has argued that the information was in the public interest. This argument is not only weak but frightening as well because the definition of what is in the public interest is so subjective that almost anything could be classified in that manner. E.D. Hill made a similar argument this morning on Fox and Friends. She argued that if the NY Times of today had existed in the days of WWII and received leaked information about the Normandy invasion, the Times would have published it under the guise that it was in the public interest to inform the American people of an invasion that was expected to cost so many of our servicemen’s lives.
E.D.’s argument is theoretical, of course, but it puts the Times’ “public interest” argument into perspective.
Ed Morrissey also commented on President Bush’s remarks about the New York Times and has excerpted part of the 9/11 Commission Report which recommended going after the terrorists’ finances.
Update: Check out Instapundit‘s response to Bill Keller’s defense of the New York Times. Here’s a portion:
A deeper error is Keller’s characterization of freedom of the press as an institutional privilege, an error that is a manifestation of the hubris that has marked the NYT of late. Keller writes: “It’s an unusual and powerful thing, this freedom that our founders gave to the press. . . . The power that has been given us is not something to be taken lightly.”
The founders gave freedom of the press to the people, they didn’t give freedom to the press. Keller positions himself as some sort of Constitutional High Priest, when in fact the “freedom of the press” the Framers described was also called “freedom in the use of the press.” It’s the freedom to publish, a freedom that belongs to everyone in equal portions, not a special privilege for the media industry. (A bit more on this topic can be found here.)


“Lee, I hope that you’re just being disingenuous and that you aren’t honestly asking these naive, ridiculous questions in any sincere way. I mean that.”
Gee, thanks Laura, Ive always admired your sincerity.
“Why would there be any reason to spy secretly? Because spying is to publicly what leftist is to patriotism. Hope that clears it up for you.”
Laura, I’ve seen the light. You’ve done such a wonderful job of clearing that up for me….
“Do you think Spain’s administration, given their reaction to the bombings that changed the outcome of their election, should be entrusted with our classified national security programs? Can you envision a scenario where they might use that info to help themselves in some way, maybe get a hostage released with it or just get al Queda off their back a while? Is that at all possible in your universe? How about the concept that info on a classified program should be shared with the absolute minimum number of people who absolutely *have* to know it in order to implement it? Check adj. #8, here. Although I guess to you that’s just a n. #2.”
Roger that, Laura, and a big 10-4. Are you in personal contact with Jack Bauer, by any chance?
“I’m frankly embarrassed to have to explain this to a grown person. That’s why I’d rather believe that you’re disingenuous, and accordingly speak to you in this sarcastic manner.”
Laura, I so sorry for your embarassment, and thank you for sharing what you truly believe because, as you know, your opinion is very important to me.
“We weren’t spying on a country (although we DO spy on our allies, and they spy on us, and there’s nothing wrong with that), we were investigating potential terrorists, and no notice was owed to those countries.”
Really? Well, in the coming weeks I suspect we’ll see what those other countries have to say about that. Hopefully they will read your well thought out comment, and if they do – well we both know that they will see the logic and clear-minded thoughts you’ve written, and not feel as if they don’t have to cooperate with the United States on terorists matters in the future — but hey, we don’t give flying fuck what those other countries think anyway!
Wow, I feel more Republican already! Thanks Laura!!!
Oh, OK Lee, then if someone talks extensively to you about releasing all this information, and then decides to do so against your objections, until something bad happens to you its OK?
epador – If nothing bad happens to me my argument that what they did was harmful to me is merely republican rhetoric designed to get my sorry *ss poll numbers up from the basement.
You have reached End of Thread.
Nothing more to see here, folks. Move along, and mind the Troll Crap.
Excellent response by Treasury Secretary Snow to Keller over at The Corner
Hey stupid unbathed LEE,
“Still no specifics about how it harmed the program”!
Just like you and the traitor democrats being oblivious to the near 3 millon slaughtered for killing the funding and failing to leave the South Vietnamese with the essential means to at least be able to defend itself , put up a fight rather that just being outright ran over and slaughtered.
How about those specifics asshole? Where’s the LSM , Red Cross and Amnesty Internationals response to the guaranteed disaster and human suffering should the democrat cowards pull another Cut n Run like Vietnam all in the name of scoring political points in attempts to smear a President in a time of war who has accomplished more than the incompetant and corrupt democrats can even lie and dream about.
This is like the democrat adult leadership giving a kid a bucket of ping pong balls to toss in the little bowl to win them a goldfish at the local carnival. They can’t even to that themselves but will take all the credit for it. Liars and Losers, that is all they are good at.
What gives the US the wright to look into the accounts of people from other country’s. Your not the world Police and definitely not the POLICE in AUSTRALIA. Look after your own backyard.
We ARE looking after our own back yard, pal, by tracking down the money trail of the bastards who want to harm us–and YOU. I guess you haven’t been paying attention, because this program caught the one of the chief bastards responsible for the Bali bombing. You know, the one that killed a bunch of your fellow Aussies.
Oops.
Aussie,
The correct response from you about this program should be “thanks.”
Thanks for your contribution Rob. Enlightening, as usual.
What gives the US the wright to look into the accounts of people from other country’s. Your not the world Police and definitely not the POLICE in AUSTRALIA. Look after your own backyard.
It’s how they caught the guy who blew up all those Aussie’s. I am assuming you care.